4 ms·
Analytic philosophy was largely a reaction to the idea that philosophy was developing into a mass of meaningless, incoherent, poetic mumbo-jumbo. For example, B
by philwelch 9y ago
Analytic philosophy was largely a reaction to the idea that philosophy was developing into a mass of meaningless, incoherent, poetic mumbo-jumbo. For example, Bertrand Russell said:
> Hitherto the people attracted to philosophy have been mostly those who loved the big generalizations, which were all wrong, so that few people with exact minds have taken up the subject.
Analytic philosophy is the tradition that grew out of this reaction, and focuses on precision in language and logic, with a particular focus on the philosophy of language because it turns out it's hard to map natural language to the kinds of rigorous logical propositions that analytic philosophers prefer. Continental philosophy is the tradition that rejected this critique and burrowed even deeper down the path they were going, eventually inventing postmodernism and poststructuralism and other new and exciting forms of what analytic philosophers would consider mumbo-jumbo.
- pmoriarty 9y agoYou've basically described all of Continental philosophy as "a mass of meaningless, incoherent, poetic mumbo-jumbo". First, that's really not a particularly charitable way of describing it. Second, it bespeaks an Analytic approach to things they don't understand -- that is, to assume they're meaningless and not important (or at best some trivial little puzzle to solve). Third, it really doesn't help to understand what Continental philosophy is actually about. Now, if you'd described Continental philosophy as difficult or incoherent to you, then that would be more reasonable. But it should be pointed out that plenty of analytic philosophy that is also difficult and incomprehensible to some (though I would grant that for the most part Analytics at least try to be clear in their language -- something that can't be said of most Continentals).
- kome 9y ago> "a mass of meaningless, incoherent, poetic mumbo-jumbo". Also: are new developments of analytic philosophy really that "clear" in their language? Usually, no. For example, is Saul Kripke really that "meaningful, coherent and logical" or he is just developing his own jargon? In my opinion, analytic philosophy often tries to be rigorous with concepts that just are not rigorous to begin with. And they just end up by creating an "ordinate mess".
- philwelch 9y agoI haven’t read a ton of Kripke, but the fender and more jargon-filled analytic philosophy is still in a different style. I think the best oversimplification is that analytic philosophers are more like mathematicians and continental philosophers are more like artists and poets. (And, fittingly, many of the foundational analytic philosophers were also mathematicians, and the continentals, poets and playwrights.)
- philwelch 9y ago> You've basically described all of Continental philosophy as "a mass of meaningless, incoherent, poetic mumbo-jumbo". No, I’m saying that’s the perception that motivated analytic philosophy. I didn’t really try and break down what the continentals were up to after the schism because I don’t really know or care. If you view the history of philosophy as an eternal, wide-ranging discussion, the analytics just kind of stopped talking to the continentals at one point and that’s probably the most fair thing you can say about it.
- tenaciousDaniel 9y agoYou misread him. He didn't describe it that way. He said that's how it is viewed from the perspective of analytic philosophers.
- euyyn 9y agoI think his description complements coldtea's pretty well.
- wsy 9y agoThat last sentence could not be less true. To give just a few counterexamples: Postmodernism is represented on the analytic side, too, e.g., Feyerabend: Against Method (unfortunately not on the list). The late Wittgenstein (#1 on the list) can not be clearly labeled analytic or continental. As final example, reading Foucaults (#12) insights about power structures in society and how they shape our view of reality, and considering that mumbo-jumbo, seems pretty unphilosophical to me.