2 ms·
The citation of "Godwin's law" in this way is so tiresome. Firstly, the law just says that Nazis will come up -- not that bringing them up necessarily invalida
by emodendroket 9y ago
The citation of "Godwin's law" in this way is so tiresome. Firstly, the law just says that Nazis will come up -- not that bringing them up necessarily invalidates one's argument. Godwin himself has endorsed likening some groups to Nazis.
More importantly, the example of the Nazis is useful in an ethical argument, because they're an almost universally acknowledged example of evil. Much like we aim to test our programs with extreme inputs, we can use the "extreme input" of Nazism to test our ethical arguments. If I posit some universal ethical standard, and then find that it doesn't seem to work if we take the Nazis, we've proven by counterexample that my standard is not universal after all.