4 ms·
After 1950, I think the continental/analytic split had grown so pronounced that reconciling the two is somewhat hopeless. I think most philosophy departments in
by philwelch 9y ago
After 1950, I think the continental/analytic split had grown so pronounced that reconciling the two is somewhat hopeless. I think most philosophy departments in English-speaking universities are so analytic-oriented that asking English-speaking philosophers to rate late-20th-century Continental philosophers is somewhat pointless.
- coldtea 9y ago>I think most philosophy departments in English-speaking universities are so analytic-oriented that asking English-speaking philosophers to rate late-20th-century Continental philosophers is somewhat pointless. You'd be surprised, since Derrida, Lacan, Foucault, and all kind of post-modernists and late-20th-century continental philosophers also had made inroads in US universities. Perhaps more on other humanities departments (e.g. social and gender studies) rather than philosophy?
- philwelch 9y agoThat’s my understanding. Literature and gender studies departments love continental philosophy.
- coldtea 9y agoUnfortunately US departments take it to a level of absurdity, academic solipsism, and middle-class liberal puritanism that's not present in their continental counterparts (who could be very involved with society, daring public intellectuals, and hated middle-class salaried intellectualism -- even if they did work for universities often themselves).
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoYes, this. It also doesn't help that the need for translation means that some of the newer material is not available, or bad translation simply makes it seem more obscurantist than it is.
- pmoriarty 9y agoAs much as I dislike Analytic philosophy and like Continental philosophy, I can't let this criticism pass without defending the Analytics. Some Analytics have been very involved with society and be "daring public intellectuals". Bertrand Russell, a seminal figure in Analytic philosophy, was famously politically active and outspoken. Daniel Dennett is a contemporary example, but I'm sure there are others. Analytics just don't tend to make social or political criticism a part of their professional philosophical work unless they're explicitly doing political philosophy. I would agree that the subject matter that many Analytics tend to focus on, like the philosophy of language and preoccupation with trivial philosophical puzzles is, ahem, pretty academic and not exactly of burning concern to most people outside of Analytic philosophy departments. They're far from alone in this, however, as the same could be said of much of the rest of academia in all sorts of disciplines, including a lot of Continental philosophy -- how many non-philosophers would be interested in Derridian deconstruction or Merleau-Ponty's phenomenology of perception? Even among philosophers, it takes a special breed to be interested in that stuff.
- coldtea 9y ago>As much as I dislike Analytic philosophy and like Continental philosophy, I can't let this criticism pass without defending the Analytics. I was referring to US-based "continentals" (social criticism, gender, etc) not to Analytics with the above.
- cmrdporcupine 9y ago> Perhaps more on other humanities departments (e.g. social and gender studies) rather than philosophy? (former philosophy student here) -- honestly, yes. I think you'll find that within American academia that the influence of continental philosophers is mostly within the sphere of 'critical theory' not philosophy depts. That's not to say that each department doesn't have its contingents of continental specialists. There's plenty of them. But at least at my school, they were the minority, and looked on with what seemed to be a mixture of bemusement and separation. Like a rival but tolerated religion. That might be slightly exaggerated, but at my school in the 90s there was really only one prof I was able to study continental philosophy with (he was good, at least). My wife just finished her BA in anthropology, and the profs threw around continental philosopher names like candy. But there wasn't a single course accessible to her that actually studied those theorists in depth and with seriousness. IMHO this is a serious problem and part of the reason that post-structural etc. theory is often either taken as a pseudo-religion (by a kind of adherent who does not have a deep philosophical depth in it) or hated and derided (by people who see it all as nonsense.)
- pmoriarty 9y agoThere are schools in the English-speaking world where Continentals are studied seriously and in-depth, and from a Continental perspective. But they're rare, and getting rarer even in the non-English-speaking world. Like it or not, Analytic philosophy is just winning -- in philosophy departments, at least.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoTo me it's a different discipline. I'd study both. But I frankly feel they study different topics.
- beedeebeedee 9y agoYeah, I can confirm that. There was one professor in my department (my advisor) who didn't teach analytic or ancient philosophy. To take any other courses in continental philosophy, I had to go to the german department and comp lit department, and those were so lacking in rigor that it was hard to take seriously.