3 ms·
It certainly seems true that the owners of capital are suffering from the reproducibility crisis as much as anyone is. What 'danharaj is arguing, I think, is th
by geofft 9y ago
It certainly seems true that the owners of capital are suffering from the reproducibility crisis as much as anyone is. What 'danharaj is arguing, I think, is that the owners of capital are not well-placed to solve it.
The very nature of capitalism is that people who produce monetizable results should be rewarded for that work, and that people who don't shouldn't. This is fundamentally incompatible with doing science in a reproducible way: paying for positive results and not negative ones gets you p-hacking as an emergent effect. Of course the capitalists don't want to pay for non-reproducible positive results, hence the firestorm. But they more strongly don't want to pay for negative results.
The capital owners in the science industries will probably end up doing something sort of like what the capital owners in the software engineering industries have done: begrudgingly accepted that a non-capitalist approach (open source development across multiple companies without proprietary advantage) produces better results for everyone, and figured out a way to kind of support it. Much like the capital owners in the software engineering industries, they still won't be very effective at it. Their nature will be to still try to extract proprietary advantage when possible, to cut costs per the tragedy of the comments, etc., and so this model will only work well when funded by companies rich enough that they can allow themselves not to show an immediate return on their sponsorship.
- AstralStorm 9y agoAlso capital owners would preferably not pay at all and have you work for free. They cannot approach this ideal only because the workers are not constrained spatially (like serfs) not forced (like slaves) to work for them. Sometimes they ate forced due to economic factors to do labour at marginal gain or even loss...