3 ms·
>The data was bad, the processes were bad, there was no replication. People are really quick to say this, but how many people have actually studied the 'racial
by foldr 9y ago
>The data was bad, the processes were bad, there was no replication.
People are really quick to say this, but how many people have actually studied the 'racial science' literature of the 20s and 30s and figured out to what extent it meets the methodological standards of today? Yes, we know that they drew incorrect (and reprehensible) conclusions. It doesn't necessarily follow that their methods were any worse (epistemically speaking) than methods that currently pass muster.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoStudies about people in general are of poor quality, due to difficult to define metrics. Even today, psychology and sociology studies aren't rigorous for the simple reason that it's hard to measure these things. Biological studies are hard too, it's hard to suss out the confounding variables and mechanisms of bodily functions. Just the premise of the "racial science" studies would render them invalid, how could they even have controlled for the myriad variables that we have no idea how to control today?
- foldr 9y agoWhich studies are you referring to? If you don't have anything specific in mind, then you can't really judge the quality or compare it to the quality of comparable research today.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoAs I wrote above, studies about people, which the aforementioned Nazi stuff would fall into. I don't have a specific study in mind, but I do know that the further you stray from math/physics/chemistry, creating metrics and isolating variables is very, very difficult. I don't need a specific study to know that. Any sociology/economic/psychology research should be taken with a grain of salt.
- foldr 9y ago>Any sociology/economic/psychology research should be taken with a grain of salt. So how is that not an example of "science going wrong"? Unless you are proposing that science is right by definition, or that governments should ignore most of the branches of science that are actually relevant to government. There are plenty of branches of physics that are at least as speculative as sociology, economics and psychology (e.g. cosmology). The only difference is that these branches of physics have few political implications.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoIt's not going wrong, unless it's making conclusive statements that are beyond the strengths of the study. That's why I say grain of salt. I understand what you're saying, but my point is that it's not science or the scientific method that results in undesirable outcomes, such as the Nazi example, but just a lack of any other good option. Governments (and people) should evaluate the merits of the information they receive. Properly conducted and repeated experiments with noted mechanisms of actions (e.g. vaccines) should have more weight than studies about trickle down wealth or whatever. Obviously, decisions have to be made, and some will be wrong unfortunately.
- foldr 9y ago>Properly conducted and repeated experiments with noted mechanisms of actions (e.g. vaccines) This is a good example of why it's not so simple as you're making out. Earlier, you put biology on your list of unreliable branches of science, and you claimed that you could know that the racial science of the 30s wasn't "real science" simply because it consisted of "studies about people". But vaccine science falls into both those categories! In reality you're deciding whether or not any given branch of science is methodologically sound not by examining any actual studies in the relevant disciplines, but simply on the assumption that any study which has arrived at the "wrong" conclusion must have had a bad methodology.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- emodendroket 9y agoThis does not seem to be a line of argument that flatters technocratic rule, especially considering that governance can hardly ignore the issues that are the purviews of economics, sociology, psychology, and other "soft" disciplines.