2 ms·
We need a journal that exclusively publishes papers with results that were totally contrary to the hypothesis. So long as the researchers aren't outright inept
by Waterluvian 9y ago
We need a journal that exclusively publishes papers with results that were totally contrary to the hypothesis.
So long as the researchers aren't outright inept or fraudulent, what's there to be ashamed about? Those would be some of the more interesting papers to read, in my opinion.
- lisper 9y ago> We need a journal that exclusively publishes papers with results that were totally contrary to the hypothesis. No, that won't help. You'd end up with the Journal of Creation Science and things like that. What we need is pre-registration: https://cos.io/prereg/ https://cos.io/prereg/ We also need to change the culture so that positive results are not disproportionately rewarded.
- 3JPLW 9y agoNegative results are really hard to do right, and even harder to do interestingly. There are so many possible confounders in experiment design and execution that they generally aren't worth evaluating. So we choose to spend our time reviewing and evaluating those experiments that do seem to have at least some chance of saying something interesting. Even then, though, depending on the discipline, if the researcher did everything perfectly, they're still saying that there's a 5% or some% chance that they just "got lucky" and there is no underlying effect at all.
- haZard_OS 9y agoThere are several. To offer but one: http://www.jnr-eeb.org/index.php/jnr/index http://www.jnr-eeb.org/index.php/jnr/index I would actually prefer that each and every journal devote at least half of their space to negative results. I have seen some sublime experimental setups that produced negative results. I can't begin to imagine how instructive it would be to see more such experiments.