3 ms·
Some of the comments miss an important distinction.. Science in the popular press, often refers to science versus completely non-science ways of forming an opin
by mistrial9 9y ago
Some of the comments miss an important distinction.. Science in the popular press, often refers to science versus completely non-science ways of forming an opinion or deciding policy. Meanwhile, science within a technical community, is subject to human error and manipulation, and relies on a reproducible result, as well as peer-review, to find answers to conflicting claims.
There are certainly non-Science ways of forming an opinion and deciding policy, in many cases totally legitimate. But once science is claimed, then of course it has to be subject to science rigors.
- m-watson 9y agoYes, thank you for saying this. I feel like, often, people use science as some ethereal being. It is a process that has to be used. If that process isn't happening it isn't science. That doesn't mean everything has to be science, but things that are science should be held to a certain standard but should also be taken with the extra weight if that standard is met.
- Bograff 9y agoIt's important to make the distinction between Pure Science and anything on the sliding scale from technical description to ELI5. There are levels to it, you and I know.
- m-watson 9y agoOh absolutely there is a sliding scale on both the actual practice of science as well as the reporting. From the practice of it, I know as simple anecdote I have participated in conducting research in hard science (physics), softer hard science (biology), social science (behavioral and economic), as well as straight policy analysis with a "scientific approach" through data science. The findings from those are reported differently and have stronger or weaker words and conclusions. I think that is where the practice sliding scale comes in, is how the researcher decided to write up and report their findings and appropriately identifying their methodology and short-comings. From the journalism side I think you end up with the problem the wide spread field of journalism has, you have to be read by your audience. That means something with a wider audience is probably going to be more on the ELI5 side which means both the reader and the journalist have to take any reported findings more lightly. The sliding scale, I believe, comes in with the rigor something is reported. That is both in the practice and the journalistic side. More details can give a more granular understanding showing limitations but some times broad strokes are necessary to get some information out to a wider audience or more quickly.
- WhompingWindows 9y agoNever mind the massive debate that occurs within the scientific community itself on some new or controversial claims. When the press gets its hands on the views of one dissenter and one proponent, it makes it seem like there are only sides A and B. This is not as simplistic as politics, where politicians form into immutable groups Left vs Right. We are dealing with numerous camps, and within each scientific camp, there are numerous arguments made for/against an issue. Take climate change, no doubt a controversial issue. To say it is "controversial" in the political sense would mean Left and Right (in the USA alone) have vociferously different stances on the issue. However, if viewed as a scientific controversy, we are now talking about detailed methodological concerns, like methods of data collection, analysis, kinds of statistical bias, and subtle changes in arbitrary parameters. Any scientist can tweak this or that in their model to make it conform more easily to their preconceived notions about climate change. Unfortunately, we also have some oil industry shills out there who got trotted out as an equally weighted side B to the side A of the dozens of scientists who would generally disagree. Then, you also have anti-science proponents who use the legitimate self-criticism of scientists to attack science as a whole. It's a sad state of affairs. Science should be reported in the press, but it should also be reported much better than it is. In the USA in particular, STEM education is lagging behind: the average person can't delineate the good science coverage from the bad, and we have ridiculous notions and conspiracies that fail to become filtered out (anti vax, climate change deniers, flat earthers, moon landing was faked, etc.) For me, reproducibility is one problem in a broader ecosystem of scientific problems, including science education generally, as well as misuse of statistics, and a saddening drive for incremental results at the expense of more broad-based thinking which might lead to fundamental breakthroughs. Our education systems must be reformed to deal with these problems, that's the only way out that I see.