3 ms·
> I doubt a French court can issue a warrant that forces OVH to turn over data On the other hand: GDPR. All countries try to pull the same moves on the inter
by toyg 9y ago
> I doubt a French court can issue a warrant that forces OVH to turn over data
On the other hand: GDPR.
All countries try to pull the same moves on the internet, from Russia to Pakistan to the US and Europe. The difference is that a small market has little leverage. The EU already has data-retention laws that could be extended, and at that point any EU government would have quite a lot of leverage. It's politically unpalatable for now, but things change.
- dx034 9y agoGDPR is the other way around. It applies to non-EU companies that deal with EU citizens (or people living there). It doesn't gain access to data stored by a Canadian company in Canada on servers owned and run by OVH. It generally doesn't grant access to prosecutors, it tries to protect consumers and can lead to fines in case of violation.
- toyg 9y agoThe point is that it's basically a "global law". Non-EU companies could choose to ignore it, but they would risk losing access to the EU market, which is too big to ignore, and so they comply. A company could forego this or that individual nation, possibly even a big one; but the entirety of the EU market is simply too large to accept the risk. Similarly, a US company could relocate to Iceland and thumb its nose at the PATRIOT Act and so on, but then "good luck doing any business" in the huge US market. The principle is the same: big markets can impose rules that more or less the entire world ends up following.
- icebraining 9y agoBut you can choose to restrict your compliance to the GDPR to your EU clients. It's not the same as a law that applies to all your clients.
- gowld 9y agoYou've just rediscovered the jurisprudence of the Commerce Clause and the power of Federalism. Alexander Hamilton would be proud.