11 ms·
Basically the article confirms what I wrote back when the shooting occurred (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16754438 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=
by mschuster91 9y ago
Basically the article confirms what I wrote back when the shooting occurred (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16754438 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16754438): Youtube (and the other social networks!) desperately need a customer support that actually deserves to be called a support.
When you have a service where people's livings depend on, and you take away their income source (in corp doublespeak: demonetize them) AND at the same time offer them only canned responses or, worse, no contact at all, some of them WILL be driven to desperation. Hell, the inhumanity actually IS the word "demonetization": it sounds harmless but it is everything else than that.
And even worse: Youtube has recognized that there is a problem with the consequences their non-existence of a support has, but, typical for US culture, they head for fighting the symptoms (increasing "security") instead of fixing the problem (hire support staff with a decent bit of leeway).
- RunningRabbit 9y agohear hear!! All those big (tech) whales with no way to normally contact them, it is insane.
- spondyl 9y agoI always wondered why tech companies had such an impenetrable inward communication until I came across the following insight: "If you have a billion users, and 0.1% of them have an issue that requires support on a given day (an average of one support issue per person every three years), and each issue takes 10 minutes on average for a human to personally resolve, then you'd spend 19 person-years handling support issues every day. If each support person works an eight-hour shift each day then you'd need 20,833 support people on permanent staff just to keep up. Amazing."[0] It's not necessarily the exact same source that I discovered back then but the idea is the same. Even a tiny portion of customer service would still soak up a large amount of money, perhaps rightfully so, but at the scale some of these companies are, it quickly becomes unsustainable. [0]: https://plus.google.com/+DeWittClinton/posts/1hRWj489oEz https://plus.google.com/+DeWittClinton/posts/1hRWj489oEz
- pavlov 9y agoIt's a misleading estimate because it doesn't define "user". In the case of YouTube, there are a billion users but only creators would require support. Maybe there are 100,000 YouTube creators who get paid anything meaningful? (I have no idea, just guessing.) If 0.1% of them require support, that's 100 requests per day. Any moderately successful mom-and-pop SaaS gets that much. There's no financial reason for Alphabet not to provide personal support to YouTube creators. They just don't want to.
- polishTar 9y agoWhat you're suggesting is how it already works. Partnered creators all have access to a creator support email (with a 1 business day SLO). Top partnered creators (aka the "creators who get paid anything meaningful") will also have a partner manager they can contact for 1-1 advice/support/etc.
- pavlov 9y agoGreat. So maybe the bar for support is set too high? Someone making $50 / month on YouTube is meaningless to Google but may spend an enormous amount of time on that content in the hope of a breakout. Those are probably the people whose mental health is most at risk. It’s Alphabet’s community, they own it. Extending more support to dedicated members may not make direct business sense but it could be the right thing for long-term community health.
- ci5er 9y ago> ... for long-term community health I understand words like books and bricks and apples, because these words have physical referents. I have no idea what "long-term community health" means. What does that mean? And why would anyone invest more in it than in barricades and highly weaponized security guards? (I'm not actually promoting an armed response to whatever a 'community' is, I'm just using it as a rhetorical foil to try to understand the pros and cons of investing in whatever a 'community' is)
- JKCalhoun 9y agoAm I being crass to also suggest that YouTube, perhaps more than any other platform, is a magnet for unstable people? I'm not trying to make a blanket claim regarding mentally unhealthy people (who I have heard are less violent as a group than the general population) and not trying to absolve YouTube of their role in this with their "marketing decisions" but it seems that YouTube specifically should maybe tread more carefully than other platforms. Besides the monetary angle there is the dangling chance at fame, an audience, acceptance that draws, in some cases, maybe more fragile people.