3 ms·
I am so glad you posted this, because for the last couple of years I've been missing old-school Godwin's Law - someone making an inapt comparison to Hitler or N
by geofft 9y ago
I am so glad you posted this, because for the last couple of years I've been missing old-school Godwin's Law - someone making an inapt comparison to Hitler or Nazis when Nazis weren't actually involved. Of late, discussions about how society should handle edge cases in freedom and robustness have involved actual Nazis with actual swastika armbands talking about the actual "Jewish question," and there were no inapt comparisons, just (confsuingly) genuine discussions of how much place Nazis have in polite society.
But your comparison is inapt: yes, we should train AI to systematically ignore negative sentiments it associates with people named "Adolf" or "Hitler" who are not in fact the Adolf Hitler who died in Berlin in 1945. Humans have difficulty in doing so, of course, but this is a bug in human cognition which is essentially the vulnerability that bigotry takes hold of: a justifiable negative impression of one person as an individual is imputed to other people who seem superficially similar. We see one person of a minority breach a social norm or even a law, and we think that others of that minority must be prone to doing similar, simply because their minority status is salient. We fail to realize subconsciously that membership in the same minority is not actually meaningfully correlated with this behavior, and when we see someone from the majority do the exact same thing, their majority status is less salient, and we don't impute the negative impression to the majority.
A good AI should be able to distinguish dictator Adolf Hitler from, say, saxophone inventor Adolph Sax or chemist William Patrick Hitler (the nephew of Adolf Hitler), and not cast aspersions on the latter two - even though human biases forced William Patrick to change his last name to Stuart-Houston. It should even be able to understand that Indian politician Adolf Lu Hitler Marak is a separate person who merely had parents with questionable taste, and the man is not on account of his name more likely to become a genocidal dictator than any of his political rivals.
And since our justifiable negative association with the Nazi leader is, fundamentally, that he weaponized this vulnerability in human cognition, it is one way of acting on our dislike for this Hitler to make sure that the AIs we build are not susceptible to the same vulnerability.
- kyle-rb 9y ago>And since our justifiable negative association with the Nazi leader is, fundamentally, that he weaponized this vulnerability in human cognition, it is one way of acting on our dislike for this Hitler to make sure that the AIs we build are not susceptible to the same vulnerability. Isn't that statement in itself an invocation of Godwin's Law?
- geofft 9y agoYou could argue that, I suppose. I think comparisons to Hitler are inapt when someone attempts to tar something irrelevant to Hitler's particular crimes (e.g., his vegetarianism) or particularly when someone attempts to compare their ideological opponent to Hitler on specious grounds. But I think there is room for apt comparison to Hitler: it would be a mistake for humanity not to learn from the experience of letting him rise to power. Godwin himself wrote a little bit about it: https://web.archive.org/web/20170209163428/https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2015/12/14/sure-call-trump-a-nazi-just-make-sure-you-know-what-youre-talking-about/?utm_term=.45f9bdc20512 https://web.archive.org/web/20170209163428/https://www.washi... (And I am totally open to criticism that this particular comparison is inapt.)
- klipt 9y agoSorry, but this is actually a real world situation that happened - I have a Jewish ancestor who was named Adolf before WWII but after Hitler's rise unsurprisingly chose to go by his middle name instead. You can ascribe it to "Godwin's law" as much as you like, I just find it a more realistic example than some hypothetically disadvantaged "Bob".
- geofft 9y agoAh! That's fair - but I think the spirit of Godwin's law is that comparisons to Hitler in particular, when the subject matter is more general than Hitler, yield unnecessarily hyperbolic responses (that - among other things - are bad at actually addressing the causes that led to the rise of Hitler and therefore weaken the goal of making sure that such a thing never again happens). We should make sure that an AI, who is probably making decisions on things like legal documents / public records and not just the middle name someone goes by, will not consider it a negative that someone is named "Adolf" if they aren't Adolf Hitler specifically. And we should for the same reason make sure that an AI will not consider it a negative that someone is named "Bob" if it has a newly-acquired specific negative impression of some other person named Bob. There isn't a difference in the cases. "Hitler" shouldn't be a special case because the rise of Hitler wasn't as much of a one-time event as we'd like to believe. When the next genocidal dictator with a somewhat rare first name gains control of a country, there will be people from the victim population who share that first name, and they should not suffer the same indignity at the hands of an AI, either. And on the flip side, when this genocidal dictator rises to power, the AI shouldn't be taught that Hitler was the only evil man who ever lived or will live; if it has the data to conclude that some actual individual (not a name) is as bad as Hitler, it should be able to conclude that.