10 ms·
From the BuzzFeed article that is linked [0]. > During the pause, workers are expected to use vacation days or stay home without pay; a small number of workers
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
From the BuzzFeed article that is linked [0].
> During the pause, workers are expected to use vacation days or stay home without pay; a small number of workers may be offered paid work elsewhere in the factory.
For these downtimes that are planned by the company, is it typical across the industry that workers have to use vacation days or go without pay? Or is Tesla shortchanging workers relative to other car manufacturers?
0. https://www.buzzfeed.com/carolineodonovan/tesla-model-3-production-shutdown-delay-elon-musk?utm_term=.jnL1P5p2O#.xlqPwzjeG https://www.buzzfeed.com/carolineodonovan/tesla-model-3-prod...
- bluedino 9y agoGM, for instance, has a shutdown almost every summer. It's usually around two weeks. It can be more, and a few workers stick around for the machines they can't really turn off. They also get to do some maintenance as well as let workers take time off in the summer, without affecting regular production. Sometimes (when sales are slow and inventories are full) the shutdown lasts longer than two weeks.
- mkempe 9y agoVolvo's summer factory shutdown in Sweden is even longer.
- froindt 9y agoIt's pretty typical for auto companies to shut down for ~2 weeks over the summer and in December. Ford does the same thing. It gives the companies two big windows for planned maintenance on their machinery which helps the plants run more consistently the rest of the year.
- csours 9y agoTo give a bit more context, hourly employees are laid off and draw unemployment during these planned shutdowns. It sounds super weird, but it's been happening for over 50 years, so everyone knows what they are getting into. The same hourly employees are hired back again at the end of the shutdown. I'm not exactly sure what happens for downtime more than a couple shifts, but I'm sure the union remembers it in the next negotiations.
- jessaustin 9y agoLots of people who work construction draw all winter.
- hoofhearted 9y agoWhere? Here in the D.C. area, construction does not stop because of weather. The exception would be extreme weather such as hurricanes, lightning and rain if the building was not closed in. It actually seems that construction increases in the winter, I guess because of fresh budgets. There is a joke that they only start breaking ground when it is the coldest time of the year.
- jessaustin 9y agoThis happens in DC too, although perhaps to a lesser extent due to your mild climate. Some construction continues through the winter, and most carpenters and laborers are happy to work instead of draw, but nobody is framing in the snow. It's true that excavation is easier when the ground isn't muddy, so "breaking ground" in the winter could make sense. You can't pour concrete when it's freezing, though, so if the timing is wrong the rain could mess up the excavation before you get a chance to place your forms.
- letlambda 9y agoI've never heard of a company paying non-salary employees during a plant shutdown. (In the US, things may be different in Europe for all I know)
- BLanen 9y agoAm I wrong in assuming that factory workers are salaried?
- froindt 9y agoI'm a industrial engineer and have worked at 4 factories and am familiar with far more. I don't know of a single company where production employees are paid salary. I talked with a production employee about it when starting my current job. They said "man I could never work a salaried job. I'd get so frustrated with it". There are pros and cons to the typical US salary structure. * If the company gets too aggressive in the expectation of hours worked, people just leave since they're not getting overtime pay. * I also have flexibility to start/end my day when I want within reason * I never have to take time off for doctors visits * I don't have a micro manager for a boss, so if I work 35 hours one week and 45 the next, nobody cares. In the US, hourly employees get at least 1.5x pay for working beyond 40 hours. It's often cheaper to pay for overtime than expand the workforce, so some companies hand out OT like candy at a parade. An employee can double their pay by working 66 hours compared to just 40. There are often also shift differentials. They might be a couple extra dollars/hour for nights and a couple extra for weekends. Most salaried employees are "salary exempt" and are typically not paid overtime.
- rdl 9y agoI believe there's no way in California for the kind of worker on Tesla's factory floor to be considered exempt, so he would almost certainly be getting overtime even if salaried. You could easily meet the 2x minimum wage annualized pay exemption, but the "administrative/executive" exemption would be an absurd stretch. A few people might meet professional exemption but probably not most of the workers, and the ones that do are likely already salaried. (I'm not a lawyer, particularly not an employment lawyer in California, though.)
- refurb 9y agoI would assume most union shops have protection against just "shutting down" suddenly and not paying employees.
- csours 9y agoNot really, other than future negotiations.
- Animats 9y agoHere's the UAW-FCA contract.[1] This would be a "temporary layoff" in a union plant. Beyond 10 days, different rules apply. Auto plants do this during model changeovers, so it's expected. Short layoffs are unpaid. Long layoffs come under the unemployment benefits provision. Tesla's production engineering people probably need to rearrange the production line. By now, they should know where the trouble spots are. [1] https://uaw.org/app/uploads/2017/03/2015-agreement-production-maintenance-and-parts-UAW-FCA-US-LLC.pdf https://uaw.org/app/uploads/2017/03/2015-agreement-productio...
- greglindahl 9y agoEven some US tech companies have shutdowns between Christmas and New Year's and force everyone, including salaried employees, to take vacation or unpaid leave.