4 ms·
It... it is accessible from a link That's what a url with an id in it is a link
by samatman 9y ago
It... it is accessible from a link
That's what a url with an id in it is
a link
- rayiner 9y agoA "link" is a DOM element in a web page which references a URL, but a URL is not itself a link. To point a finer point on it: the fact that a URL is referenced in a link means that a user is supposed to see and access it.
- doomtop 9y agoSounds like you might be thinking of an anchor element. People ask for the "link" when they mean the URI all the time.
- rayiner 9y agoWikipedia disagrees: > In computing, a hyperlink, or simply a link, is a reference to data that the reader can directly follow either by clicking, tapping, or hovering. A hyperlink points to a whole document or to a specific element within a document. Hypertext is text with hyperlinks. The text that is linked from is called anchor text. A software system that is used for viewing and creating hypertext is a hypertext system, and to create a hyperlink is to hyperlink (or simply to link). A user following hyperlinks is said to navigate or browse the hypertext. The URL in the abstract is not a "link." A link is an element in hypertext.
- always_good 9y agoYou're just being stubborn. Link is used to mean a URL by the layperson. For example, I don't think I've ever heard my family say "URL" in their life.
- ozzmotik 9y agoa "link" is something that connects two entities together in some arbitrary way. a chain link for instance connects the constituent entities of a chain (other links) together. a link in a linked list connects different nodes together. and a hypertext link connects two hypertext resources together. what you're doing is picking one specific definition and applying it liberally to all potential interpretations and contexts of said word. this is why i tend to espouse the virtues of generality over specificity; when you get too specific, you start eliminating the actual utility and flexibility of language. a link in terms of computing is most certainly NOT just a hypertext link, that is only one very specific interpretation of the concept at hand that you're falling back on to try and further your argument. liberally ignoring all the other possible interpretations is quite intellectually dishonest imo. still, you're entitled to perceive things how you want and argue it whatever way you desire. just know that the majority of reasonable and educated individuals will disagree with you. you're up shit creek and you keep denying every paddle that's offered to ya m8
- jakeogh 9y ago"wikipedia disagrees" like it's a source?
- oarsinsync 9y agoIf it helps, the Oxford English dictionary has updated the definition of “literally” to literally include “used for emphasis while not being literally true.” Whether we like it or not, language evolves. If “literally” can, then literally any other word can too.
- gitgud 9y agoObscurity does not mean security. Just because the link wasn't referenced does not imply it is sensitive information. Should you not have the freedom to type what you want into the address bar of a browser?
- rayiner 9y ago"Security" is irrelevant--there is no obligation to "secure" private property. Obscurity, on the other hand, implies that the property owner did not intend for people to access certain property. That is what matters.
- prophesi 9y agoThere is an obligation to secure sensitive information of people. Obscurity is not security, and so Nova Scotia was improperly storing the data.
- rayiner 9y agoThe fact that Nova Scotia might have violated a separate obligation to secure sensitive information doesn't make accessing that information not trespass.
- munk-a 9y agoYou're correct, but I strongly suspect this is a case of the government trying to deflect blame from their horrendous security to "those young hackers" and that this whole situation could probably be resolved peaceably by ensuring the data in question is deleted from the dude's computer.
- prophesi 9y agoI would agree if it took an actual exploit to obtain the information.
- PretzelPirate 9y agoWhen accessing a document on the web, you ask the server if you can have it. The server then says "yes" or "no" based on a set of rules. In this case, he asked and the server said "yes". This is like going to a library, asking the librarian if you can check out a book, being told yes, and then later being arrested because they meant to say "no".
- ljm 9y agoA link is nothing of the sort, it's a colloquial term that connects one point to another. It is not unique to HTML or programming in the slightest. In those terms a URL is always a link because the only practical reason for inventing the concept of a universal resource locator is to link one thing to another without them coming into conflict. There is no reason for a URL to exist except for it to be a link and it has nothing to do with the DOM.
- lewilewilewi 9y agoYou're right - a URL is an address, and a link is a sign saying 'go here'. The address still exists with or without the sign.