4 ms·
This is absurd. This is not private property. Ordinary law-abiding people do walk into government offices and ask questions, and when they get answers, do conti
by gowld 9y ago
This is absurd. This is not private property. Ordinary law-abiding people do walk into government offices and ask questions, and when they get answers, do continue asking questions and getting answers. Ordinary law abiding people to browse all the products on display at a store. Ordinary law abiding people do flip through all the pages of a catalog that is sent to their home.
This Orwellian attitude that looking at anything is criminal if the government retroactively decides they didn't want you to see it, is terrifying.
But as usual when it comes to authoritarian overreach by government, you're not de-facto wrong about the government sees things, but you are eloquently defending a morally horrific attitude.
- mistermann 9y ago> This Orwellian attitude that looking at anything is criminal if the government retroactively decides they didn't want you to see it, is terrifying. This is the big problem here. There's no way the way the Freedom of Information Act in Canada is written the way it is because of the democratic wishes of Canadians. Every day our government moves further away from governing according to the will of Canadians and more toward the will of.....I don't even know. Saying it is the will of politicians doesn't explain some of the strange behavior we've been seeing in this country for quite some time. If our fate is to ultimately live under a quasi-dictatorship masquerading as a democracy, then so be it, but I wish we could just be honest about it. This objectively false "Canada is a democratic nation" claim is infuriating to me.
- jessaustin 9y agoMan, if it bugs you, have some sympathy for us directly south! People get straight-up fierce about the civic platitudes around here.
- rayiner 9y agoGovernment documents and web servers are private property. (The information within might be public, but it's illegal to access private property in an unauthorized way to get public information). Ordinary law-abiding people do the things that property owners expect them to do (or what they reasonably infer the property owners intend them to do). If there are signs (literal or figurative) that the property owner doesn't want you doing something, then you don't do it--and you're charged by the law with heeding those signs. That's not Orwellian or authoritarian--it's a basic part of "social" behavior in a society with private property.
- shkkmo 9y agoFiles an a server may be considered "private". However, when you make those files available through a web server, you make the "public". You then have the ability to limit the access to those files through any one of a large number of techniques to make them private again. Now if there were evidence that they tried (and failed) to use one of these techniques or that the teenager in question deliberately circumvented these techniques, then you would have a point. One (not particularly good) way of limiting access to files without verifying identity would be to create a hash (say using the requesters email address and the request ID) and use this in the url to access the document (similar to how google docs implement sharable document links). If they had done this, then perhaps you could legitimately claim that there was evidence of intent to restrict access. An incremented ID is the opposite. It is a sign that you wanted people to be able to easily predict the correct url to download the next file from. Using an incremented ID is in fact evidence that this information was intended to be public.
- cecilpl2 9y agoExcept this teenager was explicitly authorized to access all those files. He literally asked the web server "can I have these files" and it responded with "yes, you are authorized, here you go". If he wasn't authorized, the server should have responded with a 403 Forbidden! Web servers are built around authentication and access rights! It is not the teen's fault that the government doesn't know how to configure them properly.