4 ms·
This essay seems like it was largely written to make the author feel smart while doing very little to illuminate or clarify their ideas and insights (which seem
by antonym2 9y ago
This essay seems like it was largely written to make the author feel smart while doing very little to illuminate or clarify their ideas and insights (which seem to boil down to basically calling Donald Trump Hitler and suggesting his voters are uneducated imbeciles who must be stopped by academia, which is among the least original thoughts possible to express).
To disguise what is really a bland central point and weak call to action at the end (hey, let’s try harder people is how the essay ends), the author dresses up the language to obscure what he really thinks and vomits forth a labyrinth of self referential jibberish which does little to enlighten anyone of anything while wasting the reader’s time.
It is a singularly academic trait to believe that bullying one’s readers into submission by attempting to cudgel them with their lack of knowledge in your particular domain is an effective persuasive strategy. Dominance games of this sort make these people generally unemployable in the real world.
Reading this sort of reminds me of listening to the rapper “The Game.” Most of his records consist of name dropping of other rappers and quoting the words of others. There is a reason The Game had a short career.
Likewise, here we have a piece of writing which is a network of references to authors few have read, unnecessary deployment of $10 vocabulary words which would best be replaced by shorter words which are more generally known. Orson Wells, Kurt Vonnegut and Ernest Hemingway perfected writing. This guy and his kind ruined it for the rest of us for their own benefit.
A great way to determine if someone really knows something is the clarity of their writing. By this metric, the author has very little to communicate.
If Richard Feynman can explain quantum physics to a 3 year old, this writer can call Trump Hitler and suggest his voters are uneducated morons without wasting everyone’s time with the unnecessary and obfuscatory language porn.
The reason people don’t respect these academics? There is no penalty for them to be wrong and their ideas are not provable. They are effectively employed via tax dollars by the state to disseminate fundamentally political ideas to their students while feigning impartiality. They never read outside of their own domains, resulting in a permanent state of educated ignorance.
Being obligated to pay 1/4th of our already overly expensive college funds to sustain the employment of people like this makes little sense anymore, Fire them and get your education from YouTube.
Don’t pay for it anymore.
- HoppedUpMenace 9y agoI see how the author would reference various sources and names to support their position, much like you would in a scientific paper, but it does come off as a bit egotistical and self-righteous when you have to drop so many names to support your unoriginal thoughts (The Game analogy is spot on).
- pasabagi 9y agoDisclaimer: I don't like the writer either. However, I don't think he's trying to browbeat anyone. I think he's just living in the humanities bubble - and this is all really middle-of-the-road stuff if you're in that world. >Fire them and get your education from YouTube. The problem is, you wouldn't get anywhere with the humanities by watching youtube. The online resources for philosophy are pretty bad, and for literature it's even worse. I think the point about the humanities - and about culture in general, is that you don't want to live in a society without it. You don't want to have a society where there are no politics professors, or sociologists, or philosophers. They aren't expensive, and they make it so if somebody is interested in one of those fields, they can actually find an expert. And if you don't have any experts, you end up with a shambolic politics, a dysfunctional society, and shitty philosophy. A lot of what america does wrong is to ignore people paid to think deeply about things in favour of the gut feelings of charlatans. People commonly notice this when scientists are ignored by politicians. Perhaps it would be worth it to extend the thought to other fields.
- belorn 9y agoIn light of this article and that it already made the Hitler comparison, I would like to point out that the nazi did also employ a lot of people in charge of political, cultural and philosophical area of their society. In their view they had a lot of employed experts, and yet from the rest of the worlds perspective they all were in a extremely limited bubble. The answer is naturally not to stop having experts, but maybe what we need in days of extreme polarization is experts on social and cultural bubbles. The humanities bubble can't continue forever.
- thisiszilff 9y agoThe fundamental thesis is > Three generations ago, literature professors exchanged a rigorously defined sphere of expertise, to which they could speak with authority, for a much wider field to which they could speak with virtually no power at all. Hence all the references to various scholars and their works. Nowhere does the author bash Trump or say his voters are uneducated imbeciles. The quote most related to this is > For going on 50 years, professors in the humanities have striven to play a political role in the American project. Almost without exception, this has involved attacking the establishment. As harmful as institutionalized power can be, as imperfect as even the most just foundations inevitably appear, they are, as it turns out, all we’ve got. Never has a citizen been so grateful for institutions — for functioning courts, for a professionalized FBI, for a factually painstaking CBO or GAO — as since November 2016. Which boils down to "The humanities anti-establishment position needs to be toned down. This election when many of us did not get an outcome we wanted, we realized the value in having strong and trustworthy public institutions." The main theme of the essay is self-awareness: > Yet the editorial logic of right-wing media resembles closely the default position of many recent books and dissertations in literary studies: The true story is always the oppositional story, the cry from outside. The righteous are those who sift the shadows of the monolith to undermine it in defense of some notion of freedom. Considering the essay starts out with > Can the average humanities professor be blamed if she rises in the morning, checks the headlines, shivers, looks in the mirror, and beholds a countenance of righteous and powerless innocence? The takeaway is that humanities professors have become ineffective because they've traded expertise for politically motivated analysis. There's a feel good, all inclusive, woo woo diversity culture about the humanities, but its come at the price of critical analysis and discerning judgment. Instead of providing a a critical, reasoned opposing view, they've become increasingly radical and reactionary. Instead of seeing their view as a small, but important contribution to the greater project of society building, they've tried to monopolize the project. The end of the essay reaffirms that the humanities have something to offer, but that that offering has to be a balanced towards improving the establishment instead of encouraging critiques with no means of improving or fixing it.