3 ms·
Fingerprints as used above wouldn't satisfy the "beyond a reasonable doubt threshold." They are circumstantial evidence of the identify of the suspect, but fing
by gamblor956 9y ago
Fingerprints as used above wouldn't satisfy the "beyond a reasonable doubt threshold." They are circumstantial evidence of the identify of the suspect, but fingerprints aren't as unique as once claimed, nor are the imaging techniques (including resolution) referred to in the article sufficiently detailed for a proper fingerprint ID in the first case.
It's questionable whether the bathroom situation would satisfy the threshold, as it's based entirely on the testimony of an officer who somehow was able to ascertain gender but not (approximate) height, (approximate) weight or build, or race from his brief glimpse of the assailant. Moreover, it assumes the officer was correct about the gender of the assailant. Finally, it assumes that the officer was truthful in his statements. All in all, reasonable doubt exists at multiple levels and a good defense attorney only needs a single element of doubt.