20 ms·
Why New York City Stopped Building Subways
- flatfilefan 9y agoIf you want to compare the development of Moscow subway from 1935 till now and planned 2020 https://stroi.mos.ru/mobile/metro https://stroi.mos.ru/mobile/metro And the map as a pdf https://stroi.mos.ru/uploads/media/file/0001/61/81fbd34f4412d3cdbb341d4f3589e1820974344c.pdf https://stroi.mos.ru/uploads/media/file/0001/61/81fbd34f4412...
- erentz 9y agoOne of the things the NYC region could do is unify operations and planning of NJ transit, LIRR, and Metro North into one through running network with a tunnel from GCT south with two more Manhattan stops then across the Hudson to another main station where the Hoboken terminal is (a bit more inland likely). Overtime the systems and fleets can merge. Instead you get this absurd patchwork of expensive stand alone projects, ARC, the huge building over of of a cap on the LIRR Hudson railyards which required maybe a billion in spending. Talks about a new Penn Station. Etc. As a plus you reduce the demand on the existing Penn tunnels used by Amtrak. If this had all be planned as one system the money already spent or being proposed to be spent on these disparate/disconnected things could provide do wonders.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> One of the things the NYC region could do is unify operations and planning of NJ transit, LIRR, and Metro North into one through running network How would this address the principal problem identified in the article, the rising cost per mile of building new track?
- erentz 9y agoThat unfortunately is an American centric problem, it’s particularly bad in NY but other parts of the country aren’t immune to it either. There’s a lot written about that elsewhere. My point in this instance is that even at the inflated construction costs you could still accomplish a lot more with better planning and linking these systems up. A tunnel and new stops in manhatten connecting them is going to accomplish a lot more for the same price as capping a huge rail yard. Building new tunnels that terminate three separate systems in different locations. And building a new Penn station.
- wil421 9y agoDoes any cross state combined public transit effort even exist in the US? Maybe DC, I am not familiar with Washington DC. It’s a nightmare in my city just between neighboring counties. Only 2 counties were included in the initial build out of public trains and not any significant expansion since. The other counties vehemently reject any such proposals. One county is going through expansion talks again but the train will only go one stop to their bus hub. I bet they will end up rejecting all of it. NIMBYism isn’t very strong in my city but it certainly is regarding public transport, trains especially.
- officialchicken 9y ago> Does any cross state combined public transit effort even exist in the US? Yes, AMTRAK [0] [0] https://history.amtrak.com/amtraks-history/historic-timeline https://history.amtrak.com/amtraks-history/historic-timeline
- wil421 9y agoAmtrak is the federal government. I am talking about one states public rail system connecting with another states rail system. New York to New Jersey was given as an example in the parent post. Amtrak is great for vacations or other travel but I don’t thinks its use case is daily commuters. At least it’s not the use case for the majority of the US.
- tspike 9y agoThe Amtrak Cascades line is actually state owned and operated: http://www.amtrakcascades.com/about http://www.amtrakcascades.com/about One example, at least!
- jcranmer 9y agoThere's not a lot of places in the country with "true" interstate integrated transit needs. Places like Chicago have far suburbs and exurbs within the commute shed in other states but are still generally within state. Even cities like St. Louis generally have a clear dominant locus in one state, which limits the ability of the other state(s) to play off the other state. The general exceptions to this rule are Kansas City and Washington, DC, where the workplace loci are truly distributed among multiple jurisdictions so that no one state is dominant. In DC, the standard subway (WMATA) runs across all three jurisdictions, although there is some amount of political football over funding. The commuter rail systems are not integrated, but that is largely due to limited capacity over the Long Bridge. (MARC, the Maryland system, is participating in the Long Bridge replacement project in part because they do intend to extend service to Alexandria once there's capacity to do so). NYC is a truly special case because it's simply so massive. In terms of geographical boundaries, there are roughly three natural independent sheds: trans-Hudson, trans-East, and trans-Harlem rivers. Each of these sheds is massive enough to let each of the three commuter systems that focus on their own sheds to not have to coordinate. These sheds also happen to largely coincide with different states: NJ is trans-Hudson, NY (or, rather, Long Island) is trans-East, and CT (as well as parts of NY) is trans-Harlem.
- Nav_Panel 9y ago>unify operations and planning of NJ transit, LIRR, and Metro North Everyone agrees but insiders who know about the current state of the transit organizations consider this suggestion so absurd as to write an April Fools post[1] about it. 1: https://pedestrianobservations.com/2018/04/01/new-york-area-governments-to-form-a-coordinated-transportation-planning-agency/ https://pedestrianobservations.com/2018/04/01/new-york-area-...
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> insiders who know about the current state of the transit organizations consider this suggestion so absurd as to write an April Fools post The difficulty comes down to regional politics. The regional rail systems (LIRR, Metro-North and NJTR) were set up to give those on Long Island, upstate/in Connecticut and in New Jersey, respectively, a dedicated regional transit authority. A politician attempting to unify operations would need to convince those voters should risk giving up their regional transit control.
- erentz 9y agoOh that’s golden, thanks for sharing. :-)
- jseliger 9y agoAn excellent point. This is also congruent: https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/1/1/14112776/new-york-second-avenue-subway-phase-2 https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/1/1/14112776/ne.... Oddly, the GAO effort to figure out why infrastructure costs so much isn't in the budget, last time I checked: https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/5/24/15681560/gao-report-transit-construction-costs https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/5/24/15681560/g...
- btown 9y ago> GCT south then across the Hudson to... Hoboken Effectively the PATH & 4/5 train already do this with a transfer at Fulton Street. And while unifying the system may look good on paper, I'd hate for the PATH to descend to the MTA's low standards of reliability and cleanliness. Better part of the system work well than all of it work poorly.
- biscuitt 9y agoI'm always amazed at how clean the Path train and stations are especially when transferring onto them from the subway. It's a completely different experience
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- officialchicken 9y ago> As a plus you reduce the demand on the existing Penn tunnels used by Amtrak. Amtrak has owned and operated the HRT (tunnels built in 1905) since 1976 when it took over the NEC from the failing Penn lines in the early 70's. It's the busiest segment of track (Interlock-A) in the world and out of the busiest train station in the world (NYP). You could reduce demand on the existing tunnels by building ARC.
- closeparen 9y agoCommuter rail ought to optimize for seating and ride comfort on long journeys with infrequent stops. Subways ought to optimize for capacity and efficiency on short, mostly standing-room trips within densely populated areas. Unification with subway rolling stock would be awful for commuter rail riders’ comfort and willingness to use the system. Unification with commuter rail rolling stock would be awful for subway crowding.
- erentz 9y agoNo one is suggesting unifying subways and commuter rail. Note that LIRR, Metro North, and NJ Transit are all commuter rail. (FWIW commuter rail is a bad term we use here in the states - something like “regional” rail would make more sense.)
- InclinedPlane 9y agoSeriously. I visited NYC last year and spent a few days hanging out with some friends out on Long Island. Traveling on LIRR is a very unfriendly process for anyone who doesn't do it basically every weekday and integrating LIRR travel with subway travel can be a non-trivial optimization problem. It's not super complicated once you get the hang of it, but otherwise it is just not obvious where you can get on and off trains, where the trains go and when, etc.
- temuze 9y agoNYC should stop building subways with tunnel boring. Instead, tear up the street, build the darn thing and then rebuild the street over it. This method is called cut and cover and it's what many countries do because it's substantially cheaper and faster: https://ny.curbed.com/2017/9/19/16335068/nyc-subway-mta-state-of-emergency-solution https://ny.curbed.com/2017/9/19/16335068/nyc-subway-mta-stat... Imagine if the 2nd ave line was done this way - sure you'd get a lot of pissed Upper East Siders, but their property value is going to skyrocket from the project anyway. As far as I'm concerned, they could deal with a year of inconvenience instead of getting it built over decades for magnitudes of money more. Of course, the City Council would never agree to this plan. It's easier for them not to disturb anyone if they want to be re-elected...
- bigdubs 9y ago2nd avenue already got pretty torn up with access tunnels, it's not like tunnel boring helped a ton. Also a good chunk of NYC subways were built with cut & cover (sections of IRT 2/3 lines as an example).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Nav_Panel 9y agoThe alternative solution is to build stations "inline" with the bored tunnels. This can be done quite cheaply, assuming modern ventilation/engineering are used. Note that $2bb of the $4bb for the 2nd Ave line came from station construction...
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Note that $2mm of the $4mm for the 2nd Ave line Billion.
- Nav_Panel 9y agoGood catch, thanks.
- 9y ago
- greatamerican 9y agoCMD + F "union" 0 results CMD + F "corruption" 0 results
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- shmerl 9y agoThat's a pity. NYC subway could greatly benefit form circular lines or lines that go from west to east in addition to those from north to south. It's often required to take completely convoluted subway routes because of lacking connections.
- chrisaycock 9y agoBeyond the constant delays and overcrowded trains, the biggest impediment I experience is the lack of subways to the airports. LGA doesn't have any train lines, while JFK and EWR have "airtrains" separate from the MTA or PATH. Chicago's "L" goes directly to both ORD and MDW. My brief time there showed that things could be far more connected than New York's system.
- jcranmer 9y agoTransit to the airport is less helpful than you'd think. The main people who are going to want to use transit are the people who work there (being both lower income and not having to carry lots of luggage around), and the working hours of subways is generally inconvenient for airport workers.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> The main people who are going to want to use transit are the people who work there I live in Manhattan and regularly take the LIRR to Jamaica, from where I catch the Airtrain to JFK. It's a predictable-duration trip. It costs $10 to Juno to Penn Station, $7.50 (off peak) to $10.25 (peak) for the train ticket, and $5 for the Airtrain. And I don't get sick reading on a train like I do in a car.
- mi100hael 9y agoTransit to the airport is hugely helpful for travelers. A subway ride from LGA to a Manhattan hotel would be far cheaper and more efficient than taking a cab.
- dionidium 9y agoIf cost is an issue, there's the NYC Airporter bus, which is a flat $15 to Midtown. Or you can take the Q70 bus to the Roosevelt Ave - Jackson Heights subway station (in Queens). Airports are a particularly visible omission, for a certain class of people, but they aren't in the top 5 or so most valuable possible extensions to the subway system.
- titanomachy 9y agoUser costs for transit were pretty low in the early 1900's. The article says that in 1947 they finally increased the fair from 5¢ to 10¢ -- $0.61 to $1.12 in 2018 dollars. New York's fare is now $2.75, and in my city it's closer to $5.
- zanny 9y agoOn one hand, transit should be heavily subsidized and not profitable because profit motives in infrastructure choke the force multiplier economic effects of having said infrastructure. You need some kind of mechanism to disincentivize overuse though, so the 5 or 10c fare worked at the time for that purpose. On the flipside, the NY metro is so decrepid and underbuilt for its demand if you didn't have inflating fares driving potential travelers to clog up other, less efficient transit systems the lines for trains would be out in the streets nearly 24 hours a day.
- pzone 9y agoProfit motives in infrastructure don't necessarily choke anything. If you want cheap fares, ensure there is some competition. And if you really want to, you can subsidize fares. They don't need subsidies in Tokyo though, all of the companies running train lines are generally profitable.
- misterbowfinger 9y agoApologies for the strong tone, but how many articles do we need to actually get something done? It's exhausting to see article after article without action.
- allengeorge 9y agoAh. You've not lived the experience that's Toronto transit: 1. Eglinton Crosstown started in the 1990s. They started boring, and when Mike Harris became premier he cancelled the project, so they filled in the existing tunnel. 2. Sheppard subway (aka. the Stubway) built despite objections of planners, who said that it would be woefully underused. Built anyways because of political pull. 16 years later, still woefully underused. 3. Transit City proposed and supported by provincial government. First, funding was reduced by the provincial Liberals. Then, Rob Ford, claiming a "war on the car!" cancelled it, pushing all the money into... 4. The Scarborough Subway. Originally estimated at a 3-stop 2B line, it's now a 1-stop 3.5B+ line - and its cost keeps climbing. All politicians support it because Scarborough is vote-rich territory, despite its ridership projections being lower than that of the Sheppard subway. It's a frickkin mess. 5. Meanwhile, the Relief Line (which everyone acknowledges is needed) languishes because of the perception that it'll serve the "downtown elite". I mean - it's not all doom and gloom I suppose: the Crosstown is finally being built, again, 25 years later.
- Nav_Panel 9y agoThis article touches on but doesn't explore in great detail the history of elevated lines in NYC. Some of their traces have been incorporated into the current system, most notably as the 7 train in Queens and the J/M/Z (including the Ridgewood/Middle Village spur), but many were torn down. Some lines in Brooklyn that people aren't even aware of (beyond the 2nd and 3rd Ave lines): * The Myrtle Ave elevated, running from Downtown Brooklyn down Myrtle and connecting with the M's Ridgewood spur. Torn down in the 1960s. * The Lexington Ave elevated, running from the Brooklyn Bridge waterfront across Downtown Brooklyn and Bed Stuy, connecting to the current J/Z line near Broadway Junction. Torn down in the 1950s. * The Fulton St elevated, since replaced by the A train, that ran over Fulton St all the way into Downtown Brooklyn. Torn down in the 1940s. You can see these elevated lines crossing Northern Brooklyn in this map from 1949: https://www.nycsubway.org/perl/caption.pl?/img/maps/system_1948.gif https://www.nycsubway.org/perl/caption.pl?/img/maps/system_1... I personally would have found these lines quite useful, but what took their place was a collection of bus routes, running along old streetcar routes (read: weird routes that stop suddenly at borough and neighborhood boundaries). And NYC buses cannot be trusted...
- electricslpnsld 9y ago> This article touches on but doesn't explore in great detail the history of elevated lines in NYC. Some of their traces have been incorporated into the current system, most notably as the 7 train in Queens and the J/M/Z (including the Ridgewood/Middle Village spur), but many were torn down. You don't even have to leave Manhattan to see elevated lines, just take an uptown 1.
- busterarm 9y agohttp://forgotten-ny.com/1999/12/remnants-of-the-ninth-avenue-el-when-is-a-subway-not-a-subway-when-its-an-el/ http://forgotten-ny.com/1999/12/remnants-of-the-ninth-avenue... This one would have been convenient for me if they'd kept it.
- jcwayne 9y ago> You can see these elevated lines crossing Northern Brooklyn in this map from 1949: https://www.nycsubway.org/perl/caption.pl?/img/maps/system_1948.gif https://www.nycsubway.org/perl/caption.pl?/img/maps/system_1... Using a Perl script to wrap a (non-animated) GIF of an old map. So much history in that one link.
- spikels 9y agoWhat’s fascinating to me about this history is that most of NYC’s subways system was built by two private competing firms, the IRT and BRT. The city then became heavily involved first by creating the competing but government financed IND, then with price controls, and finally a full takeover. Once it was a publicly owned monopoly the NYC Subway’s long decline began. Pretty much the same thing happened in SF but with street cars instead of subways.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- malandrew 9y agoThis is spot on and the same observation I had, yet I'm puzzled as to why it was downvoted. A system that profits simply runs better. The best rail systems in the world in Japan are for-profit. https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2012/05/secret-tokyos-rail-success/2044/ https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2012/05/secret-tokyos... (<-- also from citylab.com) https://www.quora.com/Is-Japan-rail-profitable https://www.quora.com/Is-Japan-rail-profitable
- rayiner 9y agoThe big difference is not for-profit status, but the fact that Tokyo's and Hong Kong's subway operators own much of the property around the stations, and make a ton of money leasing it: http://money.cnn.com/2015/03/30/news/hong-kong-mtr-subway-property/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2015/03/30/news/hong-kong-mtr-subway-pr.... Economically that makes a lot of sense. Transit infrastructure creates a positive externality: it benefits not only the rider, but the shop or office that the rider goes to. NYC's MTA can only recover from one side of the transaction: the rider. JR and MTR, as major landlords around the stations, can recover from both sides, capturing some of the positive externality.
- ccccccccccccc 9y agoI think that is a stretch of a statement. There are plenty of public services that work great as well as many private services that absolutely suck.
- rmason 9y agoAs a native Detroiter one of the saddest things to me was that the city never got a subway. I don't believe you can have a truly world class city without a subway. There were multiple efforts to create a Detroit subway starting in 1910 but each one fell short. Finally in late 1928 the subway was approved! Two stations were built but construction stopped with the great depression. Today sadly no one even knows the location of the two stations. Here's the winner of a dream subway contest for Detroit: http://jackson-woods.net/transit/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/DM1800_b.png http://jackson-woods.net/transit/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/...
- rdiddly 9y agoI don't know the detailed history at all, but in an intuitive & oversimplified way, I wouldn't think big transit projects ever had much of a chance in the home of the auto industry. Seems like they would want to demonstrate what an automobile utopia looks like.
- rmason 9y agoWell the auto industry did fight the subway which is why despite overwhelming support it took so long. Detroit did have an extensive trolley system. I found out that when the trolley's were secretly purchased and discontinued by GM in 1956 that 25% of Detroit families didn't have a car. The majority switched over to the bus lines which were expanded. Course the buses were made by GM ;<). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_conspiracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_consp...
- gascan 9y agoMy god, did that happen to every trolley line? Makes me want them back all the more.
- rmason 9y agoWell my dad was called a conspiracy theorist and worse for advocating that GM bought up Detroit's trolley line. I am just glad that he lived long enough to see the truth come out and be proven right.
- jdlyga 9y agoOn the average morning or evening commute, there's at least 2 - 3 lines with delays, and even a couple with "planned work". My commute tends to blow up twice a month, and I have to take a Juno/Uber/Lyft.
- francisofascii 9y agoWhy not just dedicated bus lanes to avoid the need to go underground?
- moate 9y agoThere are already bus lanes. The bus can't move people nearly as far nearly as fast as an underground transit system.
- zeristor 9y agoPrivate US money didn’t just build NY subway lines, London’s Central Line was also built by an American.
- abalone 9y agoIt's a decent article but at the end I found it glaringly silent on the current state of the "lure of the suburbs." Isn't that waning? That seems important here. To summarize, the article is premised on "three broad lines of history": - lure of the suburbs - battles over control - deferred maintenance costs It concludes by noting how battles and costs are still big factors, but nothing on the "lure of the suburbs." It just mentions in passing that the city population is growing, but doesn't connect any dots. The diagram makes it seem like that yellow "line of history" is still sky high off the charts. But there is in fact a big migration back into the cities. People don't want McMansions in the burbs as much. Empty nester baby boomers are moving back too. This is undoubtably why the article is written in the first place and what is placing more pressure on overcoming the other two problems.
- majormajor 9y agoEveryone slices the numbers differently, but it's pretty hard to say the suburbs are dying out based on the data. https://www.vox.com/2015/1/22/7871687/death-suburbs-myth https://www.vox.com/2015/1/22/7871687/death-suburbs-myth "This shows that at almost every age level, the country continued to de-urbanize from 2000 to 2013. Various trend pieces about empty nesters moving to the big city simply aren't reflected in the data." My experience is that people are overall more willing to trade space for urban convenience than they used to be, but still not so willing/able to trade both space and affordability for it. In places where the suburbs are also stupidly expensive - NY and CA - you don't see it as much. Everywhere else in the US - where property in the suburbs gets dramatically cheaper once you're five, ten, fifteen miles outside the city center - that's hard to resist.
- abalone 9y agoDidn't say that. I said that lure of the suburbs is waning. Skyrocketing costs in cities are a symptom of that and the Vox article concedes as much.
- majormajor 9y agoYou said "there is in fact a big migration back into the cities" and that's the part that the numbers disagree with. Instead, there has been a slowdown in the continuing move to the suburbs. And a suburb-centered population is one that still won't move so quickly on transit and the like, at a state and national level.
- BasHamer 9y agoA name mentioned twice might have warranted a paragraph. Robert Moses, the subject of "The Power Broker" a Pulitzer Prize-winning biography (worth an audiable credit). He ran the Triborough and build a lot of bridges, parks, parkways etc. Most of those bridges do not have rail decks, because he also believed the future was cars, and rail would compete with his source of revenue, toll fees. It is hard to overstate the impact that one person had on the NY infrastructure, but this article very much understates his impact.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoIs there an possibility of a smarter above ground (read: bus) system? What would be the effect of small buses running more often? Perhaps with a technology component that allows them to effect the timing of the traffic lights? If you could cut back on car traffic - which is a positive regardless - then buses are going to benefit.
- ordinaryperson 9y agoA bus can carry about 100 people max. A subway train can carry 1,000. About 5.7 million people ride the NYC subways every day, buses aren't going to cut it. For a real-world NYC example, check out the planning for buses to temporarily replace the L train: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/03/nyregion/l-train-shutdown-14th-street.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/03/nyregion/l-train-shutdown...
- chiefalchemist 9y agoYes. But other than rush hour or special events how often is that 1000 ppl capacity reached? Shouldn't the whole system be more flexible? Does everyone have to leave work at the same time? How economical is it to run subway trains with few passengers? It seems that a whole lot of resources (i.e., money, including ongoing maintenance) is being tossed at outlier situations.
- ordinaryperson 9y ago> But other than rush hour or special events how often is that 1000 ppl capacity reached? A single train can carry 1,000 people. It's not a "rush-hour event." > Shouldn't the whole system be more flexible? Does everyone have to leave work at the same time? The work day is still roughly 9-5, nothing the MTA does is going to change employers' opinions on scheduling. Good luck telling your boss you want to come in 2 hours late to avoid subway overcrowding. > How economical is it to run subway trains with few passengers? Train frequency is slowed down significantly during non-peak hours. Don't get me wrong, there are efficiencies to be had -- like not having a live human at every station 24/7 -- but unions fight those measures. > It seems that a whole lot of resources (i.e., money, including ongoing maintenance) is being tossed at outlier situations. I'm not sure what you're proposing. Buses? Again, buses won't work -- see above. They could massively increase fares but that is essentially a tax on poor people. What they need is for both the state and city to cough up more money to address crumbling infrastructure and overcrowding.
- deevolution 9y agoI suspect that once we have switched fully to autonomous cars on the road, the subway will cease to exist.
- noobermin 9y agoIf recent events are any signal, that won't happen for a while. Here's a good sobering reading[0]. [0] https://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/self-driving/toyota-gill-pratt-on-the-reality-of-full-autonomy https://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/sel...
- reconbot 9y agoThis was an April fools joke but hit's every good policy idea NYC could do spot on. https://pedestrianobservations.com/2018/04/01/new-york-area-governments-to-form-a-coordinated-transportation-planning-agency/ https://pedestrianobservations.com/2018/04/01/new-york-area-... From a local controlling agency, from unifying our commuter rails, from joining with the path. All these things would be good for the city and people who live here but I cry because I'll never see a sliver of it in my lifetime.
- CryptoPunk 9y agoIt's remarkable that an article that in-depth managed to not make a single mention of the word "union", when unions played the central role in driving up costs. I think that points to the meta problem hamstringing development of subways, and so many other things: the hold unions have over not just politics, but culture, and especially academic culture.
- stmfreak 9y agoCost per mile has risen 10-20x in inflations adjusted dollars? That's your problem right there.