3 ms·
I think it's less relevant today, because we now have multiple languages running on the JVM - and I think that was always the most powerful feature of the Java
by Cthulhu_ 9y ago
I think it's less relevant today, because we now have multiple languages running on the JVM - and I think that was always the most powerful feature of the Java program, the write once, run anywhere idea. Not so much the language itself, although at the time it was pretty good too.
- truncate 9y agoIIRC Steele talks about languages which are extensible by users not just compiler writers. Although, JVM allows you to have multiple language implementation on top of JVM, it still doesn't make it easy to extend a language the way lets say Lisp can. He speaks of having primitives in language which allow programmers to extend language (macros?).
- gizmo385 9y agoIf macros and LISP on the JVM are what you're looking for, that already exists: https://clojure.org/ https://clojure.org/
- truncate 9y agoYes I know. I'm not talking about JVM specifically, but extensible languages. I'm a Racket programmer myself, which has much more powerful macro system. I didn't make my point clear. What I was trying to say was these languages are still not mainstream and understood by wider audience, and the argument Steele makes is still relevant. All this lisp and macro goodness existed back then as well.