3 ms·
I know it's not a very popular opinion but I think this is a good idea (disclaimer: i am not affected by this issue). The tech is there for the people, not the
by Tepix 9y ago
I know it's not a very popular opinion but I think this is a good idea (disclaimer: i am not affected by this issue).
The tech is there for the people, not the other way round.
- _jal 9y agoAs a general rule I agree. But in this case it demonstrates that Ether is run by people, not math. That is not what many people want. And indeed, I treat it the same way I do scrip in video games. But until you take away the ability to "rebalance the economy", it will stay a video game.
- factorialboy 9y agoThe point of contention is "all people" or "some people".
- rebuilder 9y agoOn the other hand, if you want human arbitration of contracts, then it seems like that is already available outside the crypto space. It's not a cut-and-dried issue, but personally I do tend towards the view that interfering in contracts via hard forks undermines the credibility of the whole idea behind smart contracts. As it is, it seems smart contracts simply do not work as they should. They seem to be vulnerable to both technical and political risks, which is actually worse than a regular contract.
- Tepix 9y agoIt would be part of a planned hard fork (for other reasons). There will not be a hard fork just for this issue.
- cslarson 9y agoI'm quite torn on this one myself but for now the downsides are outweighing the good. Just the fact that it is very contentious is a big problem. It just isn't worth another possible network split or negative pr it would bring. Ethereum is trying to be a particular kind of base layer blockchain - it needs to encourage the development of non-hard fork solutions to these issues, like better auditing, insurance, etc.