3 ms·
I don't think you understand why military benefits are the way they are. And I am not up for writing an opus on it in comments here. Suffice it to say that rai
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
I don't think you understand why military benefits are the way they are.
And I am not up for writing an opus on it in comments here. Suffice it to say that raising your right hand and swearing to give your life for your country is a little different from your standard job.
- scarface74 9y agoI never said that we shouldn't give the military the benefits they get. All of the benefits except for pensions are benefits accounted for now and part of the current budget - they are not based on bad math. I said you should pay government emmployees more now and let them save for their own retirements. You should want that instead of being forced to stay in for 20 years to get any retirement benefits. And being in the military is statistically not the most dangerous job. https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2014/03/15/dying-for-a-paycheck-these-jobs-are-more-dangerous.aspx https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2014/03/15/dying-for-...
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYeah, we are talking past each other. It isn't the danger per se. I'm aware other jobs can maim or kill you. But uniquely the military can ask you to die for the cause. There is a difference there. One of the reasons the military takes care of family is so military members can focus on the mission and not be distracted by worrying about such things. The military medical system needs to exist to support the mission. In times of war, soldiers need medical care. Owning the facilities and having military medical personnel is essential to be able to trust that treatment. So one of the reasons military families have access to free medical is because if you rest, you rust. Having doctors sitting around doing nothing waiting for war does not prepare them to handle the medical needs of a war time army. Treating the families of the military members gives them a means to practice medicine so they stay sharp. It's a very complex and elegant logic behind the decisions that have built the system we have currently. It is unlike just working for a paycheck. This is why words like duty and honor get used so much. Maybe I will blog about it sometime. This probably just scratched the surface. And I don't think you get where I am coming from at all.
- scarface74 9y agoI'm not arguing with you about any of the benefits that the military gives families in the present. Just that instead of pensions - pay more.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoOne of the reasons for the pensions is that service can chew you up and spit you out. My father had shrapnel in his head. Because of it, he couldn't get new life insurance. It caused blind spells which caused him to quit at least one job that I know of. He was sometimes unemployed for months at a time after leaving the army. There are lots of veterans who are disabled and never get their act together again. You see high rates of homelessness. Anyway, I am going to stop here. I don't think you have really understood anything I have said and my comments are being downvoted.
- scarface74 9y agoThere is already a model for that - disability. If you are in the private sector and no longer able to work after you have put into social security, you are eligible for disability. I'm also not arguing against former soldiers being eligible for additional compensation in the form of separate disability insurance if they were injured in the line of duty.