4 ms·
I am bloody sick of that troll Nicholas Carr. Exactly the same things were said of printing - conservatives said that we would lose the ability to remember thi
by jdietrich 16y ago
I am bloody sick of that troll Nicholas Carr.
Exactly the same things were said of printing - conservatives said that we would lose the ability to remember things when all knowledge could be looked up in a book.
Exactly the same things were said of slide rules and calculators - that we would lose the ability to reason as our ability to calculate atrophied.
The obvious debunking of Carr's argument is the incredible level of skill so many computer users exhibit. Obviously we HNers are all aware of how bloody difficult programming is, but we forget just how complex a lot of very ordinary software is. Watch a skilled Photoshop operator or a really good Starcraft player in action and you'll see Carr's hypothesis go down in flames. Something as mundane as Excel is easily more complex than any system in the world just a few decades ago.
Carr is at the bottom of a very long line of dreary, reactionary trolls, cursing that the young people today don't know how easy they've got it, that they're going soft with their newfangled tools.
- sabat 16y agoI am bloody sick of that troll Nicholas Carr. Couldn't have put it better myself. He really thinks he's good at being reductive. cursing that the young people today don't know how easy they've got it Every generation is sure that these young kids today, with their hair and their clothes, just don't appreciate how hard things used to be. Every generation is wrong about that, of course.
- edanm 16y ago"Every generation is sure that these young kids today, with their hair and their clothes, just don't appreciate how hard things used to be. Every generation is wrong about that, of course." Funny anecdote: for years, my father kept telling me that "when he was a kid, we called our father sir". Made sense, until one day I read a book in which the character's father complained of the exact same thing, but the book was written in 1900.
- Qz 16y agoEvery generation is wrong about that, of course. Actually, they're right -- it's just that in the grand scheme of things, how much easier we have it today than the last generation, is insignificant compared to how hard life is in general. We do have it better, but it doesn't make us dumber because the world still needs smart people to keep it going.
- sabat 16y agoMeh. I'm old enough to have been aware of what things were difficult for the previous generation and how they're easier now. And: there are new things that we have to deal with that the previous generation could never have conceived. In my experience, life never gets easier; it just changes.
- lsd5you 16y agoEvery generation is wrong about that, of course. Since you've proved it with your powers of induction. Not saying that you are wrong about the next generation, but you might be.
- sabat 16y agoBlogga please.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- earnubs 16y ago"Watch a skilled Photoshop operator …" I've worked with a couple of people who are pretty handy with Vim, process control, Screen, etc. Watching them in their workflow, the hand movements, is mesmerising in the same way a dance can be. Purely anecdotal but they also have IQs that would be around the genius level.
- cturner 16y agoI consider mastery of a discipline and genius to be distinct. I'm fluid like that in screen and vim, and not particularly smart. Musicians get it - it can be awesome watching a conductor juggling a weak choir in rehearsal with batton and piano. People who have it probably have more mental energy to devote to other things - which would be a huge advantage - but that's not the sane as 'unprecedented insight'.
- integraleq 16y agoI would also agree with that sentiment. What you do on a consistent basis more than likely becomes "short-circuited" into your mental perception of the world that you navigate from day to day. Much like not using a programming language that you knew well for six months can, I believe, cause some kind of "mental atrophy" in that particular skill set.
- lotusleaf1987 16y agoUpvote. Carr doesn't know what transactional memory is obviously. Most people don't know how to do a lot of things, but with Google they know how to figure it out in 2-3 minutes. I remember Sherlock Holmes in I think 'A Study in Scarlet' tells Watson he tries to forget information that he doesn't have a use for so it doesn't clutter up his mind. I think that's pretty much how most people are now, why bother memorizing something if they know how to figure it out when it is needed.