5 ms·
Re the ongoing debate here about government pay (and whether it's high or low): I'm not super familiar with city and state government jobs, but I do know somet
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
Re the ongoing debate here about government pay (and whether it's high or low):
I'm not super familiar with city and state government jobs, but I do know something about military and federal compensation. They frequently pay less in salary, but have better benefits. This makes it an apples to oranges comparison when trying to talk about what they pay in comparison to non government jobs.
I was a military wife for a lot of years and I have spent a lot of time trying to figure out how to convey this. At one time, my army spouse was nominally making about half the income of someone else close to me, but take home pay for my spouse and this other person was nearly identical and I never spent a dime on doctor's visits or prescription medication. The primary difference in our quality of life was that my husband's income supported a family of four and this other individual was single and childless at the time.
So it gets really confusing because sometimes the take home pay for government jobs is less, but the total compensation package can be better. This means that two people arguing about it can both be right and unable to see the other point of view.
- rebuilder 9y agoIs there a standard measure of disposable income after taxes and necessities like food, housing, education, healthcare? It seems comparing how much people have available for discretionary spending would be useful in many cases.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI'm not aware of one and your question touches on some of the hidden forms of compensation that can be hard to measure (and can vary over time for the same person -- for example, we were sometimes in housing on base and sometimes not). The below examples are off the top of my head from memory as a military spouse and may be very out of date. The military will cover 75% of tuition for active duty members. Most states charge military members in-state tuition. When my ex took college classes at low cost community colleges in California, his books typically cost more than tuition. His tuition was practically pocket change. When he was stationed in a designated war zone, we got a tax break for that. When we were in on base housing, we did not get a housing allowance. We also did not get a water bill or electric bill. We only had to pay for a phone. While stationed in Germany, I got free dental care on base even though spouses usually don't get free dental anymore. Similarly, we could have gotten free braces for my oldest son while stationed at a different remote location. When shopping on base at a px or bx, you pay no taxes. They may or may not also have lower prices on some items. I routinely had a Power of Attorney so I could handle my husband's affairs while he was deployed. I never paid for such. We had access to legal assistance for free for such items. Medical coverage for the family is free, including out patient doctor's visits and most prescription medication. Further, I am alive when by all rights I should be dead in part because we got stationed at Travis AFB just as the shit was really hitting the fan. The hospital there is a teaching hospital that serves all military branches for eight western states. Most people have no idea how well developed the military medical system is and the sorts of resources that can be made available in cases of serious medical crisis. I have a genetic disorder that was diagnosed late in life. My husband's medical benefits alone were practically like a second income for us because I was in the ER all the time at zero cost. This was true even when visiting relatives who happened to live near military bases. I just went to the nearest military medical facility, even if it was a different branch of the military. Military personnel are sort of outcasts when deployed elsewhere in the US. We tend to not have a local bank account and military spouses have high unemployment rates because locals don't want to hire them. The military does what it can to make up for that, such as offering free check cashing on base at the bx or px. When in on base housing, I was able to check out a lawn mower and other items for free for purposes of maintaining the yard to the standard required by the military. I didn't have to buy any of those things. They even provided grass seed for free so we could reseed our yard when the 115 degree summer heat in the High Desert killed our grass. There are so many things you get for free in the military for just flashing your ID card that some people who leave after a single stint are shocked at how poor they are after leaving. A much higher percentage of a military check is discretionary than is the norm for most jobs. If you stay in 20 years or more, you will get retirement benefits without doing any retirement planning or savings whatsoever. As a young military spouse, 90% of my budgeting concerns was making sure we had enough food in the house. Retirement planning, stressing about medical bills and other normal issues for most Americans was simply not a part of my life.
- danmaz74 9y ago> military spouses have high unemployment rates because locals don't want to hire them May I ask why? Because they know you're going to move soon, or any other reasons?
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYes, they know you are highly likely to move again soon. But really it should say in part because... The benefits package makes living on one income viable. This contributes to spouses being less motivated to job hunt. Another factor is that frequent moves make it nigh impossible to develop a real career. If you have a serious education and want a professional career, this is largely out of reach for most military spouses. Nursing is just about the only exception that I know of. Nursing pays fairly well and there is typically a shortage of nurses just about anywhere you go. If you want any other kind of serious career, being a military spouse is a huge obstacle to working that out. If you are content to deliver papers or wait tables, you can probably get those kinds of jobs. But better jobs mostly don't want you (edit: and just may not have openings when you need them or may not exist at all in some locations).
- danmaz74 9y agoGot it, thanks. I suppose that the kinds of online jobs digital nomads do would be an interesting alternative, but those aren't for everybody.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoDigital nomads were not a thing 30 years ago when I was a young military wife. However, I do digital nomad type work currently. It fits in nicely with the kinds of expectations I have for my life that are rooted in having been a military wife. There are also times when I wish a regular job was a viable option for me because there are certainly downsides to what I do.
- 9y ago
- Roybot 9y ago> This means that two people arguing about it can both be right and unable to see the other point of view. Thanks for sharing this. This is something that has been extremely important for me to realize. When it comes to holding strong and passionate view points on any topic. I have to stop and understand that there is a reason that the person with an opposing view point may also be right from the perspective of their world view and I’m simply blind to it because I may never fully be able to understand their world view and they may never understand mine. We all go through anywhere from slightly to drastically different life experiences that inform our world view. And it’s something I force myself to be more conscious about. But thank you for bringing this up in your context and experience.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- scarface74 9y agoMy problem is that the pensions give the government a way of paying employees low and kicking the can down the road where later taxpayers bare the brunt of obligations that they had no say in. Just pay government employees more so taxpayers, the government, and potential employees can all go in knowing the trade offs and let the employees manage their own retirement like everyone else. Of course I don't have a problem with military families being provided cheap healthcare.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI don't think you understand why military benefits are the way they are. And I am not up for writing an opus on it in comments here. Suffice it to say that raising your right hand and swearing to give your life for your country is a little different from your standard job.
- scarface74 9y agoI never said that we shouldn't give the military the benefits they get. All of the benefits except for pensions are benefits accounted for now and part of the current budget - they are not based on bad math. I said you should pay government emmployees more now and let them save for their own retirements. You should want that instead of being forced to stay in for 20 years to get any retirement benefits. And being in the military is statistically not the most dangerous job. https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2014/03/15/dying-for-a-paycheck-these-jobs-are-more-dangerous.aspx https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2014/03/15/dying-for-...
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYeah, we are talking past each other. It isn't the danger per se. I'm aware other jobs can maim or kill you. But uniquely the military can ask you to die for the cause. There is a difference there. One of the reasons the military takes care of family is so military members can focus on the mission and not be distracted by worrying about such things. The military medical system needs to exist to support the mission. In times of war, soldiers need medical care. Owning the facilities and having military medical personnel is essential to be able to trust that treatment. So one of the reasons military families have access to free medical is because if you rest, you rust. Having doctors sitting around doing nothing waiting for war does not prepare them to handle the medical needs of a war time army. Treating the families of the military members gives them a means to practice medicine so they stay sharp. It's a very complex and elegant logic behind the decisions that have built the system we have currently. It is unlike just working for a paycheck. This is why words like duty and honor get used so much. Maybe I will blog about it sometime. This probably just scratched the surface. And I don't think you get where I am coming from at all.