10 ms·
> The tie-breaker is social, not technical. The tie-breaker is financial. Jupyter is winning because it's free, not because it's social. It becomes social beca
by dahart 9y ago
> The tie-breaker is social, not technical.
The tie-breaker is financial. Jupyter is winning because it's free, not because it's social. It becomes social because of widespread adoption, and it get's widespread adoption because it's free.
I love Jupyter, love love love. But there's a lot of hyperbole and opinion here. Mathematica is just a for-profit business, it's that simple. And it wouldn't be fair to deny the example that Mathematica, Maple & Matlab have set for free solutions like Jupyter.
There's nothing dishonest about a for-profit business. And if Mathematica wants to keep PDF export for themselves, so be it, that's their right. What's dishonest is expecting technical software and service for free and calling people names like vandals if you don't get it. Just celebrate Jupyter and enjoy that people are doing great work you get to use without paying. I don't love Mathematica or it's founder, but there's no real need to impugn Mathematica in order to make this point.
- stjohnswarts 9y agoExactly, you can be a programmer and be a capitalist too. May the best paradigm or hybrid of the various paradigms win.
- carreau 9y ago> it's free Well for you maybe – and we strongly believe it should be – but it's built on top of thousand of volunteers hours, grants money (Thanks Sloan, Helmsley, Moore) and donation from companies (Anaconda, microsoft...) and individual, and partners. NumFOCUS (https://www.numfocus.org/ https://www.numfocus.org/) manage all of that it's a 501c3 tax deductible ! If Jupyter is of help to you (or your company, organisation) think about contributing back (Code, Dev Time, Design, UX, translation, Legal, ...) Much Love from the Jupyter Team.
- ILikeConemowk 9y agoFernando, the creator of Ipython and ultimately what morphed into Jupyter is missing from your list. That dude is an inspiration.
- sonofaragorn 9y agoThank you for mentioning him, I didn't know of him. For anyone interested here is an interesting talk he gave recently: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xuNj5paMuow https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xuNj5paMuow
- carreau 9y agoSorry, Fernando as well as all the contributors are included in the "we, the Jupyter team". I did not start to mention individuals otherwise the list would be really long. I would encourage people to look at (at minimum) the steering council on Jupyter.org for a list of key people in the project. We are also striving to make contributing to Jupyter / open source recognized in Academia - for people like Fernando to get proper recognition, and future generations of scientists to have incentives to do this kind of work.
- ChrisRackauckas 9y ago>We are also striving to make contributing to Jupyter / open source recognized in Academia - for people like Fernando to get proper recognition, and future generations of scientists to have incentives to do this kind of work. And thank you for this! Do you have a post about what efforts are going on? I myself am trying to find out how to navigate academic spaces while spending significant time doing open source development. I am curious how you're pushing for changed incentives to help people in this kind of position out.
- nerdponx 9y agoI can only imagine how many billions of dollars in company value have been generated using the product of their uncompensated labor. Same goes for the rest of the data stack: Python itself, Numpy, Scipy, Scikit-Learn, Pandas, etc.
- carreau 9y agoFun fact, as far as the Jupyter team can tell, there are more full time Dev on Jupyter than CPython. Also pretty excited that bumpy recently got funding for 2 full time Dev that will work at UC BIDS!
- dahart 9y agoThank you for all your hard work!! Understanding what it took for Jupyter to be where it is, and how much work it took, who pushed for it, and how many people had to work to make it happen, this is important. You're absolutely right to emphasize that it's not free to build. I worry that promoting a mentality like the author's that open source and free to use is honest, and for-profit is "dishonest" dramatically undervalues and undermines your work as well as the funding model. If we treat Jupyter like it's our right, and not a miracle of funding and hard work, we will make it more difficult for Jupyter to attract help and to succeed.
- recharged96 9y agoIt's not free. Grant money means someone's paid for it (us, taxes). Volunteer is about credit, not fiat, but still costs something (gpl restrictions). Jupyter is great, it's revolutionized online education for example. But it's not as full featured as Mathematica, and like most Foss projects, slower to fix bugs, aka you get what you pay for. Both have a place unless you have hired, 100% dedicated help on juptyer. This is much like public radio vs corporate. Together they do the market needs.
- carreau 9y agoGrant usually differ from US taxes. And AFAICT, Jupyter received no money from govt source. Jupyter is not GPL but MIT, and volunteering is rarely about credit.
- infinite8s 9y agoI'm pretty sure some of Fernando's early work on ipython was funded through his NSF grants.
- acidburnNSA 9y agoFair points. Just to clarify I think the author was referring to Vandals [1] in the original sense rather than merely poking fun. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vandals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vandals
- gaius 9y agoThe tie-breaker is financial. Jupyter is winning because it's free This is it really Back in the 90s I was using a program called MathCAD, it provided a “notebook” interface by running as a plugin to Word 6. In terms of general usability and experience, 20-years-ago blows away modern-day Jupyter and it’s silly “cells” interface, which it does not because it’s better but because it’s trying to force itself into a web browser. I haven’t used MathCAD since but I bet in 2018 it’s amazing. I think few people who have used the commercial tools think Jupyter is better. But the commercial tools are soooooooo expensive...
- sanderjd 9y agoI used MathCAD in physics and chemistry classes in college. I frequently wonder what happened to it, because I share your perception that while Jupyter is very nifty, it is hamstrung by the limitations of the browser environment. I'm waiting impatiently for the coming revolution of non-web collaborative internet-connected rich client applications.
- tincholio 9y agoAs a die-hard Emacs user, I think that org-mode with it's org-babel capabilities blows Jupyter out of the water, and it produces much better, readable output. You can use it with pretty much any language, and combine several languages in a single document without any issues. Besides all this, it's just a plain text format, and you can extract all the code into proper source files for later offline use, too ('tangling', in literate programming parlance). Jupyter uses a rather obtuse json format which is not practical to work on directly. Of course, it's not web-based and it requires some basic knowledge of Emacs, but functionality-wise is so much better that it ends up being frustrating to use Jupyter when collaborating with other people. There are some workarounds (EIN, and ob-ipython modes help, but it's not quite the same)
- emj 9y agoRequiring basic Emacs knowledge is just too much, just looking through the features of org-babel I can't really find anything that makes it better suited. Except not having to bother with a webbrowser, that is a nice plus, but hardly important for most people I work with.
- rotorblade 9y ago>> The tie-breaker is social, not technical. > The tie-breaker is financial. Jupyter is winning because it's free [...] It is a bit more nuanced than that. Personally I do not pay from Mathematica usage, so why do I like Jupyter more? The Mathematica notebook interface is horrible. You may go "oh, neat" the first few times you try it then, at least I, get more and more frustrated on all the idiotic issues * Indentation/text-wrapping. Write a long line that starts wrapping, it gives it a little indentation to signify this, an your next line that you have indented is slightly more indented, but it is really hard to see, so you have no idea of where your line-breaks are. * Brackets. "[" are used for function calls and for part-specification. The number of square brackets in your expression makes it necessary hard to read when it is big enough. * Jumping text. The notebook interface does not have the "auto-complete brackets" (maybe v11 does), so you add your first, all the text in the Cell gets reformatted and you have to find the fucking place you wanted end the bracket. This is akin to working with images in MS Word. * Exporting. The notation is just ugly, fine, that is personal, but "Sin[]" as "sin()"... ok. Ah, good, it has a "Copy as Latex", nice... "Sin[]" -> "\text{Sin}[]". Really? Who in the world uses "\text{Sin}" for the sine-function and square brackets for function-calls when typesetting maths in Latex? It is just a complete nightmare to try and incorporate these things into your workflow, at least for me. Jupyter just behaves as you'd expect. Just that it is so much smoother to work with wins. For me, I do symbolic calculations, SymPy can do some things much easier than Mathematica, but a lot of things it can't or you have to work some more to get going. That Jupyter allows you not to have an aneurysm every day at work, which makes you actually wanna spend the extra time working it out.
- improbable22 9y agoThese are matters of taste, I use both & find Mathematica's notebooks much better than Jupyter. Editing text in a web browser is just painfully clumsy, and plain text is not great for reading mathematical expressions of any length. But obviously it depends what you're doing with it. You complain about Sin[] but not about ugly things like np.sin()? Also I think you're looking for Sin[θ] //TraditionalForm //TeXForm
- rotorblade 9y ago
- klmr 9y ago> The tie-breaker is financial. It can be both financial and social: individual institutes are all too happy to pay for Mathematica licenses, and consequently institute members can use it to produce reproducible research with it. However, the reproducibility of the resulting notebooks is drastically hindered by the fact that a reader essentially also needs to pay for Mathematica to get the full benefit out of these notebooks (even if they are readable without Mathematica). As a consequence, few people bother using it even though they can afford to. Social drivers disincentivise its usage. By a similar dynamic, Git beat out the competing DVCS: in this case mostly technical rather than financial factors that drove individual actors to prefer Git over alternatives (due, to a large part, to GitHub). But many people don’t actually care about technical considerations (or even prefer other systems over Git in this regard). What people most care about is seamless integration. In the end, a social driver caused Git’s adoption.
- blablabla123 9y agoAlso not to forget that Jupyter is just different to Mathematica. With Mathematica you can do symbolic computations, yes also Statistics and Machine Learning, but also Group Theory and what not. Jupyter does a great job as an interface for certain Statistics and Machine Learning tasks, also I'm quite sure that it needs less resources but that's all. That said, I'm still missing a free but powerful tool for symbolic computations like Mathematica or Maple. > The tie-breaker is financial. Exactly, it cannot be emphasized enough. Of course as a student you get these powertools for a small price or even for free. But if you are not in University, those tools are super expensive. For a reason but there is still a need for far more open source in this area. EDIT: I'm just realizing there is Sympy, niiceee...
- hpcjoe 9y agoMaxima, the gpl'ed version of Macsyma (which I used in grad school days for stat mech calculations on spin systems with Potts, Ising, and other models) is available for most systems. There is a Jupyter kernel for it[1]. I am personally more a fan of Julia than Python, and Julia + Jupyter is an awesome combination. [1] https://github.com/robert-dodier/maxima-jupyter https://github.com/robert-dodier/maxima-jupyter