7 ms·
My mom is a PERS retiree. Not one of the rich ones, though she did retire at the perfect moment and she has a livable retirement income. One thing a lot of pe
by rootusrootus 9y ago
My mom is a PERS retiree. Not one of the rich ones, though she did retire at the perfect moment and she has a livable retirement income.
One thing a lot of people (who do not work in gov't) don't recall is that while the economy was roaring back then, Oregonians working for the gov't went for years without so much as a cost of living adjustment. Some of the perks they got from PERS were in lieu of getting a raise. So while I think PERS made some stupid decisions, let's not all heap blame on the workers and demand they suffer now. Gov't work pays crap and part of the benefit is supposed to be a little more long-term security.
- Eridrus 9y agoYes, this is an absolutely backwards way to pay people. When times are tough we end up tightening our belts on a whole host of services, but cannot adjust pensions because we have promised them. We should just pay people market rates and avoid saddling ourselves with a bunch of debt when times are good.
- jadedhacker 9y agoWhen is the government ever not tightening its belt? It's ridiculous that we can pay for bombs but not pensions. Just tax the rich some more. The debt never matters when it comes to killing but always matters when it comes to salving.
- scarface74 9y agoWith the median household income being $65000, when the average voter talks about "taxing the rich", they won't have any problem going after tech workers making in the low six figures. You may come to find that you may be one of the "rich".
- Eridrus 9y agoI quite agree with the comments about not spending so much on the military, but as a fraction of GDP, federal taxes have been pretty stable over the last 60 years https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/u-s-tax-rates-the-big-picture/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/u-s-tax-rates-the-big-p... with increases and decreases in a constrained range. This whole it or the defecit thing seems like a common talking point for progressives now that Republicans have shown their true colors, but if your goal is to actually govern a country, it does matter. At the very least you should be able to see how increasing our debt increases the payments we need to make to service that debt. 7.4% of our latest budget was just paying for the debt we've already racked up. That's tens of billions of dollars that could have been spent on something worthwhile, but instead we're just paying for the past.
- CryptoPunk 9y ago>>Just tax the rich some more. The rich can leave. You can't, especially at the state level.
- jadedhacker 9y agoThink about the implications of that statement. We're headed towards (actually already in) a world in which the very few are fabulously wealthy and the rest suffer needlessly. You can't raise taxes, the rich leave. You lower taxes, the rich suck money out of the local population until they get a better deal. All states are in competition to lower taxes. A much more comprehensive solution is necessary.
- CryptoPunk 9y agoAre you suggesting we create a world government to ensure there's nowhere on Earth people can flee to to escape high taxes? So what do you do when the rich leave for Mars? Chase them there to make sure you get your pound of flesh? Is this really the kind of world we should strive to create? >>You lower taxes, the rich suck money out of the local population until they get a better deal. Maybe you're looking at it wrong. The rich aren't cows to be milked. The relationship between an individual and a jurisdiction should be mutually beneficial. If the jurisdiction has something the wealthy individual wants, they will invest there. If the jurisdiction is losing wealth as a result of the activity of the wealthy individual, then clearly there are negative externalities that it is not punishing with penalties, or subsidies that it is providing without a proportionate benefit, that wealthy people are taking advantage of. The solution there is to change the way government programs are structured to make business models that suck wealth out unviable. If the programs that the taxes the rich pay for provide a greater benefit to the rich than the cost of the taxes, the rich will move/invest in that jurisdiction. The stable equilibrium is not zero taxes with no government. As for growing income inequality, the solution is not forcibly redistributing income with a totalitarian world government that destroys/sanctions independent jurisdictions until they fall in line. The solution is to find out what structural forces allow those with greater capital to accumulate wealth at a faster rate than those with less capital. Perhaps the government is introducing structural barriers to full economic participation. One example would be transaction taxes, like the sales tax. These advantage larger organizations that can avoid financial transactions by keeping their activity in-house, something smaller businesses can't do by virtue of being more specialized. Another example would be securities laws, which necessitate use of highly paid professionals to get approval from the centralized regulatory gatekeeper to offer stock to the public. It now costs $6 million to do an IPO, and many elite in the government and securities sector are looking to shut down unregulated cryptocurrency token sales that offer people who can't afford those sums a more affordable means of raising capital. Maybe those concerned with wealth inequality are not concerned enough about these things, and are inadvertently contributing to the very centralization that is behind these problems by calling for more power to be given to centralized governing institutions in their pursuit of tax collection. Something like 12 out of 20 of the wealthiest counties in the US are suburbs of Washington D.C. Maybe you're not looking in the right place for the source of the problem.
- blitmap 9y agoThis is absolutely true. I have several members of my family who work in the gov, and I have witnessed years of inadequate inflation raises - nothing else. The "trade" was a nicer retirement and better health benefits.
- 0x445442 9y agoNon government employees have had inadequate inflation raises but without nicer retirements nor better health benefits.
- ekianjo 9y ago> "nicer" That does not even start to describe it fairly. "Extremely sweet" would be more accurate since civil servants and the like get to retire with almost their best pay ever, while the rest of us get something averaged over dozens of years. > and I have witnessed years of inadequate inflation raises So you think the private sector gets "adequate" inflation raises? Not everyone works in tech.
- mhneu 9y agocivil servants and the like get to retire with almost their best pay ever That system changed in 1984. Now the FERS annuity is (for most people) about half of their highest pay. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Employees_Retirement_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Employees_Retirement_S... (It's still a decent deal, but it's not a defined benefit plan based on your highest pay)
- tedunangst 9y ago> the average annual rate of basic pay of the employee's highest-paid consecutive three years of service (commonly referred to as the "high-3" period).[3] The "high-3" period normally is, but does not have to be, the final three years of service ??
- DoreenMichele 9y ago
- tantalor 9y agoBorrowing from the future is not a good strategy.
- pessimizer 9y agoYou always borrow from the future.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoThis is a profound comment, even if off the cuff. Consider tens of trillions of fiat in worldwide liabilities, and how the entire world is relying on people yet to be born to carry the torch through taxes to pay for the debts we’ve amassed.
- dindumuffin 9y agoThankfully, those who are yet to be born will be many more numerous and possess better technology with which to pay the debt we charge up.
- cc439 9y ago"Thankfully, those who are yet to be born will be many more numerous" The 3rd world will be more numerous, the current citizens of the first world will not. We're already seeing societal strains rising from the introduction of 3rd world peoples intended to make up for the missing offspring of existing 1st world peoples so I highly doubt things will work out as easily (and peacefully) as you assume they will.
- Bud 9y agoIt had better be a lot better technology, since we have permanently reduced Earth's carrying capacity and ruined the climate.
- tedsanders 9y agoA fascinating digression. I conceptualize borrowing oppositely. When you borrow, you borrow from someone else's past/present labor and obligate your future labor. (Where 'you' can be an individual, organization, or society.) In my view, borrowing is always from the past. You cannot borrow that which has not yet been created.
- rayiner 9y agoFor the most part, government work does not pay poorly.[1] For example federal employees without advanced degrees earn a lot more in government than in the private sector: https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.washingtonpost.com/amphtml/news/powerpost/wp/2017/04/25/federal-employee-pay-benefits-ahead-of-private-sector-on-average-cbo-concludes/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.washingtonpost.com/amphtml/... [1] I’m willing to entertain the idea our economic system as a whole undercompensates secretaries and overcompensates executives. That’s a different issue.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Spooky23 9y agoThe federal government isn’t state and local. Also note that the Feds no longer have generous pension plans and rely on 457 plans similar to 401k. Someone in my family ran a fire department in the 80s and 90s. They had no money and in this state arbitration made negotiations difficult for management to win. So they gave away pension and health concessions that were cheap then. The number one issue with these systems are public safety pensions, because of the amount of overtime earned by these employees. Administrative staff and professionals are mostly exempt and not that big of a deal.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoThe pension and health concessions were never cheap to give away. Someone just had the brilliant idea that since voters aren't able to spend time analyzing and verifying the numbers, and there are no laws regarding how to calculate them, that you can just understate the costs and let the future deal with it.
- Spooky23 9y agoThat’s not really accurate either — it’s a complex issue. Nobody in 1990 would have predicted the decade of double digit cost increases that came in the 2000s and 2010s. Pension contributions did have fiscal impacts, at least in states that require that pensions actually be funded.
- racecar789 9y agoPart of the blame lies with GASB (Governmental Accounting Standards Board). Prior to around 2006, GASB allowed governments to avoid reporting pension liabilities on the balance sheet. Instead, pension liabilities were reported in the footnotes. From 2006 onward, GASB started to tighten-up requirements, and eventually brought governmental accounting in-line with private sector accounting (aka liabilities are reported in full). Once the new regs took effect...news reports about cities declaring bankruptcy started increasing.
- CryptoPunk 9y agoHow would not reporting the liabilities but still being obligated to honor them be sustainable? I don't see how the GASB can be blamed for requiring disclosure.
- acchow 9y agoTo compensate for the lower pay, aren't government jobs much lower stress? And have good job security? Hard to get fired even if you do very little?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- RhysU 9y ago> One thing a lot of people (who do not work in gov't) don't recall is that while the economy was roaring back then, Oregonians working for the gov't went for years without so much as a cost of living adjustment. So don't work there.
- rootusrootus 9y agoA luxury we have in the IT field today that seems so obvious, but did (and does) not seem as simple to everyone else.