3 ms·
From the article: If vaccination campaigns and modern sanitation systems don’t outpace the pathogen, they anticipate a return to the pre-antibiotic era when mo
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
From the article:
If vaccination campaigns and modern sanitation systems don’t outpace the pathogen, they anticipate a return to the pre-antibiotic era when mortality rates soared.
“This isn’t just about typhoid,” ...“Antibiotic resistance is a threat to all of modern medicine — and the scary part is, we’re out of options.”
Typhoid is endemic to Pakistan, where poor infrastructure, low vaccination rates and overpopulated city dwellings persist.
Experts are also reinforcing hygiene habits for prevention: washing hands frequently, boiling drinking water and eating well-cooked foods. In the longer term, modern sanitation infrastructure is needed.
---
We aren't out of options. The article itself provides options: Fix the infrastructure problems. Make sure people stop living in filth and have access to clean water and modern sanitation.
This is handwringing and it also amounts to justifying not fixing the infrastructure problems, which I frankly find not only disingenuous but also disgusting.
Furthermore, in the pre-antibiotic era, people went to "the baths" -- usually located at a natural hot spring -- where they took hot and cold treatments. It's harder to kill infection that way and it really helps to have access to modern water infrastructure, but it is possible to kill infection that way.
There are other options for treating infection beyond that, such as herbal remedies. For decades, antibiotics have been the slam dunk, sure fire answer that is convenient because you can pop a pill and head off for your job while recuperating, but they aren't the only means we have to kill infection.
There is also research on reversing antibiotic resistance. But those studies get largely ignored while the public focuses on these kinds of dramatic stories because, in the minds of most people, news means bad news, a point I have made many times before and don't feel like harping on by giving my same tired examples involving Y2K and the Kuwaiti oil well fires.
There are myriad other options. We just don't really like hearing that for various reasons.
I would much rather see the world focus on how to get the infrastructure built and how to come up with effective solutions rather than more dystopian fiction indulging macabre fantasies of a future without antibiotics where we can't really be arsed to solve it because we are such drama llamas.
- maxerickson 9y agoYeah, improving infrastructure is likely to be the most effective step. There's ~400 reported cases of Typhoid per year in the US, out of 12.5 million globally. Access to clean water makes a big difference. There's also cheap, effective vaccines. Just need to build/rebuild the trust needed to get them to the people they would really help.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThe article says this is happening in Pakistan. This probably means a wealthier, more developed nation -- or non profit from such -- needs to step up and work on this as an act of enlightened self interest. Because letting third world countries live in filth is threatening to export antibiotic resistant infections to the rest of the world. This not my problem attitude is going to make it our problem and it's dumb.
- wbl 9y agoPakistan has nuclear weapons and a large army. They don't need aid they need better leaders.