5 ms·
In a survey of people I know, 0 out of infinity kept their Facebook accounts deleted. But lots of people told me they did. Probably 30% of people I know. Some
by prepend 9y ago
In a survey of people I know, 0 out of infinity kept their Facebook accounts deleted.
But lots of people told me they did. Probably 30% of people I know.
Some actually deleted.
Some said they did and didn’t (really weird since you can see their account).
Some thought they did, but screwed it up.
Some said they did but switched to Messenger, or WhatsApp or some other part of Facebook.
Over the past 5 years, not a single friend has stayed off Facebook. Although it would be cool to install an app that actually tracked this to see people who stay off.
I was hoping that this article would talk about how they did the survey through Facebook :)
- mr_spothawk 9y agoI kept my facebook, but deleted my social graph.
- thunfischbrot 9y agoWhat does that mean? Honestly curious, does it mean unfriending everyone?
- joejerryronnie 9y agoI'm pretty sure the OP is satire. What good is social media without the social?
- city41 9y agoI've done this in the past and am considering doing it again. Facebook is a good way to get updates on companies, products, organizations, etc that you are interested in. Kind of like Twitter but IMO much better. I deleted my Facebook account 2 years ago and haven't been back since, so not sure if the above is still true.
- mr_spothawk 9y agoyeah, deleted all my friends but kept the account. left a public message for folks who discover me. also... not satire. though, that feedback is appreciated.
- djsumdog 9y agoHow did you do that?
- thunfischbrot 9y agoIn a survey of people I know, there are many who claim that they "only use it very rarely", most who say they "should use it less", several who quit (incl. me many ca. 2012) and three who never had an account. Those three also never had whatsapp. Those who do not have fb accounts agree that it did not have a noticeable impact on our social lives. We use mail and calls to keep in touch, and we have more to talk about when we see each other, as we have not seen and read about most of each others' experiences already before we meet. The one thing I missed in the beginning was the simplicity of organizing events with people in common networks who I was not close with, e.g. study groups, student parties, study trips, I hear now for parents this also includes kindergarden activities etc.
- rdiddly 9y agoNo but they mention #deletefacebook "trending" (i.e. on Twitter, without even mentioning Twitter and apparently without seeing the irony). You might know a lot of people who want social cred for deleting their accounts, without actually deleting them. But it's also possible that Facebook is keeping those accounts active on purpose so others will continue interacting with them, which is a tool of temptation they can use to get those users to come back. 100% of the people I am deleted their Facebook account long ago, based on a fairly dispassionate assessment of the user experience and the loss of productivity when saddled with it.
- bowlich 9y agoI don't understand why go through the hassle of actually deleting (particularly since it is so onerous). It changes nothing. There's probably still a shadow account of the data you gave them. Deleting the account doesn't put everything back in pandora's box. You can just post that you're abandoning the account with where to reach you online, log out, delete the cookies, and block their domain (what I did) and have the same effect with the bonus that friends can still reach you if they wonder where you went.
- ModernMech 9y ago> There's probably still a shadow account of the data you gave them. Let's hope not, for Zuck's sake, because he just testified in front of Congress that when you delete your account it's gone from Facebook's servers for good.
- Phenomenit 9y agoSo do they delete your account in all of their backups as well?
- sdhgaiojfsa 9y agoUnlikely, although they do probably keep a listing of accounts not to restore. And of course you'll age out of their backups over time as well.
- Phenomenit 9y agoYeah but if they wanted to they could just restore the whole thing and ignore the list. I mean as long as you can't see them deleting everything from everywhere you can't be a 100%
- misterhtmlcss 9y agoLegally (I believe) they can't delete an account, they can only hide it or deactivate it. There are rules around the data that go beyond Facebook. Think about it. Someone's told the cops I've been using threats using my Facebook account and I hear that and request the service be deleted. Poof it's all gone. Somehow I don't think that's allowed or does anyone think I'm not making a valid and likely assumption here? Then sure they delete YOUR data, but all the inferencial data such as which sites you clicked like on, which sites you signed into with Facebook, the type of commentary or information you share you made/shared isn't yours and the knowledge gained also isn't the users it's Facebook's so that'll all be there. So sure they won't have your face or name, but they'll know everything else about you that makes you you. Anyway most people don't even know that Facebook owns Instagram or WhatsApp, so no matter what they say unless they are tech savvy they have up at most an account on Facebook, but not it's subsidiaries (I believe).
- DenisM 9y agoI have unfollowed everyone, except for a few pages that post interesting events. This way I stay abreast of what's happening, yet suffer little consequence of attention-poisoning effects of FB.
- cfadvan 9y agoA good friend of mine, his wife, his parents and their extended family all decided to (and did) delete their Facebook as a result of this furor. I deleted mine after a few months of first making it, and I’d say all told I know more than a dozen other people who either never had them, or deleted them. They’re not using Messenger or WhatsApp. Some use email chains, others are using Signal, and only two reverted to Facebook. I guess we know different people? It’s probably one of the challenges when talking in terms of anecdotes.
- bertil 9y agoWhat worries me is that email chains (and WhatsApp in many cases) are significantly worst at keeping disinformation at bay: - Hardly anyone writes back the recipients, often copied in the different layers of the email, so disinformation spreads without being corrected; but - Spammers gladly collect the emails through those anyway.
- tedunangst 9y agoMaybe after the next election we can have content regulations for gmail too.
- musage 9y agoI got asked by FB to identify myself with my passport after 9 years of being on it with like 150+ RL friends and classmates etc. and I just thought "fuck that, show me the passport of the random strangers who didn't like my political posts", and haven't look back since. And by political I mean quotes by Noam Chomsky and Hannah Arendt and whatnot, not racist rants or whatever people primed with the notion of FB having some sort of liberal bias might dream up. So I took it as a compliment. FB had precious little to give me, and precious little use for what I had to offer. No worries, like reading a poem to a dog and only then realizing it's a dog. Still a good poem, but the dog wouldn't know. Now if only HN required email addresses for accounts, then I could be real productive. Merely being shadowbanned is actually kinda neat, I can still speak my mind however I want and don't have to check for replies on a site that has zero notifications anyway.
- djsumdog 9y agoIronically, being able to keep track of who deletes their accounts disappeared when they closed that hole in their API that was used to extract friends lists (it broke this app I wrote years ago): https://penguindreams.org/blog/discoverying-friend-list-changes-on-facebook-with-python/ https://penguindreams.org/blog/discoverying-friend-list-chan... Because I've lived in so many places and different countries, there are a lot of people who I can only communicate with over Messenger. I usually use the purple-facebook and purple-hangouts plugins. I never read status updates. I only update my status to promote my other blogs/websites. I guess I could switch to sending international texts or ask people for their e-mails (which also means asking them to remove my e-mail from spam since I run my own e-mail server and Google/Microsoft don't really use DMARC/DKIM/SPF and always mark my stuff as spam), but messenger is just easier. I think we'll only see people get rid of Facebook when there are better alternatives to connect on. Even then it's dumb to delete a Facebook account; just stop using it like people did with MySpace.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- textmode 9y ago"I was hoping that this article would talk about how they did the survey through Facebook :)" There is one type of "revolution" that arguably cannot be started on Facebook. The revolution to reclaim privacy from Facebook, to free ourselves from Facebook surveillance. Whenever this "conflict of interest" comes up, there is an unforgettable 1970 song I recall hearing as a youth. Hint 1: It was written before "rap" existed but many rappers and other artists attribute this man's work as a precursor to hip-hop. Hint 2: It has a repeating chorus that expresses a similar "conflict of interest", involving a different "revolution" and a different medium. Can any HN reader guess the song?
- asaph 9y agoThe Revolution Will Not Be Televised by Gil Scott-Heron. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Revolution_Will_Not_Be_Televised https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Revolution_Will_Not_Be_T...
- Terretta 9y agoPaul Simon’s “50 ways to leave your lover”. ;-)
- textmode 9y agoNot 1970.
- cinquemb 9y agoGil Scott-Heron had a great many songs and poems where I sometimes think what modern analogues would take the form of, esp when it comes to people's behaviors with internet connected applications, though reading through them today still gets the message home.
- textmode 9y agoNot only do I agree with you here, but I agree with you strongly on this as well: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16686723 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16686723 This is why I prefer clients and browsers small enough that I can edit and recompile quickly even on a computer with low resources.