8 ms·
I'm confused. I don't see what makes most of the examples cited here "Brutalist" in any meaningful fashion. Brutalism is, of course, a fuzzy (and contentious)
by smacktoward 9y ago
I'm confused. I don't see what makes most of the examples cited here "Brutalist" in any meaningful fashion.
Brutalism is, of course, a fuzzy (and contentious) label to begin with. But the article cites two interpretations of the term that we could use to evaluate how Brutalist a given design is:
honest, unpretentious and anti-bourgeois
and
a sense of roughness, exposed structures and visible thought processes
The problem is, I'm not seeing a lot of either of these in the examples provided.
If you asked me to name a site whose design is "honest, unpretentious and anti-bourgeois," for instance, examples that would leap to my mind are Craigslist and HN -- both of which focus on simple (even drab) layouts dominated by plain old text. But the examples are full of vibrant colors, big images and irregular, unconventional layouts! They're refreshing and interesting to look at, but that doesn't make them Brutalist.
And to the other definition, "exposed structures and visible thought processes," I'd point to... well, I'm not sure what I'd point to. I'm not sure there is any web site that would qualify as Brutalist by this definition. Are there any sites that let their plumbing hang conspicuously out on the sides? Bloomberg and Dropbox and the Outline certainly don't. I'd think of this more as a site where you interact with it via an API or the developer console or some heavy, overwhelming user interface than as a news site that happens to have decided to use giant fonts and screaming neon colors.
If we want to have Brutalism as a valid design approach for the web, we first need to decide on what exactly the word means. Otherwise it will just become a parking lot for whatever trends happen to be fashionable at the moment, which is not a great way to build something that will make a lasting impact.
- sagichmal 9y agoBrutalist design encompasses both Craigslist and these examples. There are commonalities there, as well as differences.
- throwaway2048 9y agosuch as?
- dangerbird2 9y agoAlso Wikipedia and a certain tech-centric online forum, to an extent.
- ianbicking 9y agoThe ZK/U site (in one of the thumbnails) is one of the better examples, I thought: http://www.zku-berlin.org/ http://www.zku-berlin.org/
- return1 9y agoi dont get brutalist vibe
- smacktoward 9y agoYes, that one jumped out at me as an actually good example too!
- l9k 9y agoThis site is better viewed zoomed out to 60%
- agumonkey 9y agowindows 2 is about to sue
- return1 9y agoSince they are talking about departure from repetitive, orderly design maybe it should be called modernism. Or maybe they should drop the architecture analogy altogether, their point still stands though that the web is becoming so uniform that you need to look at the address bar to avoid confusion.
- niftich 9y agoAs for "exposed structures", I'd include the prominence of the box model underlying the rendered HTML, emphasized by visible borders and/or distinct backgrounds. As others are mentioning, the border-heavy http://www.zku-berlin.org http://www.zku-berlin.org (included in the article's examples) qualifies, and so do 1990s-style websites that appear to be authored with tables and don't try to cloak the inner workings of the layout.
- smacktoward 9y agoOoh, I like that. That's a very useful interpretation! Thanks!
- niftich 9y agoThen again, the label 'brutalist' is fraught with conflated interpretations that to some followed logically, yet in other contexts they appear to be in conflict. From the very beginning, the term sprung out of linguistic confusion between French and English [1], where Le Corbusier's French descriptor for 'raw concrete' was lost in translation and reinterpreted by English commentators as brutal, then art imitated life as later works seized on this attitude and were intentionally designed to be provocative [2]. So no one knows whether brutalism is concrete-heavy minimalism, or concrete-heavy bizarro-showoffism, but the core of it is the use of a drab but versatile, non-organic material, so one could venture to guess that any website that features excessive use of color and vibrancy, and cloaking the existence of edges between disparate functional blocks would automatically be disqualified on aesthetics alone. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12685595#12689331 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12685595#12689331 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12685595#12688364 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12685595#12688364
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoBrutalist architecture was a disaster, especially in countries like the UK where poor light and regular rain make grey concrete one of the most depressing and least durable of all possible building materials. The UK was littered with Brutalist "statement" buildings. Most have been pulled down now, and - with a few high profile exceptions, which have escaped the low-budget ghetto most of the movement settled in - the style is generally considered a mistake. I have no idea why anyone would want to copy the aesthetic in web design. But then the designs on show don't look Brutalist so much as "edgy" 80s magazine kitsch, which in turn influenced a certain kind of minimal web style which has actually been around since the 90s. It's true that web design lacks real creativity and diversity, but that's partly because web pages that are trying to sell you something - as opposed to making an artistic statement - are optimised to balance content delivery with behaviour modification with cognitive load. There are only so many ways to do that, and the affordable ones are already in use.
- aeneasmackenzie 9y agoHere is an "exposed structures and visible thought processes," website: http://motherfuckingwebsite.com http://motherfuckingwebsite.com
- pbourke 9y agoCame here for this and to also link http://bettermotherfuckingwebsite.com http://bettermotherfuckingwebsite.com
- comex 9y agoOff topic, but I don’t like the “improved” text color. Subjectively, viewing on an iPhone X, it just seems to make the text ever so slightly indistinct, harder to read. I suspect this is partly due to the “True Tone” feature, where the OS automatically adjusts the display’s color temperature to match ambient light. This makes the “white” background color appear less harsh (less blue) than in most displays, lessening the need for a lighter foreground color to soften the appearance. Or maybe you could just say that it reduces the perceived contrast, lessening the need for further contrast reduction. I’m not sure if that’s actually true, though. The actual contrast ratio between anything other than black and black should be infinity on an OLED display, or even if you account for a tiny amount of diffuse reflection of incoming light, it would just be a (large) value dependent on the brightness setting.
- lmm 9y agoPutting all the content in the middle third of my browser and wasting the rest with enormous empty white margins is not an improvement.
- rocky1138 9y agoI much prefer the original black on white, personally.
- rhizome 9y agoBrutalism is not about drabness, it's about the use of basic materials. Beyond that, I think a lot of what you ask appears to be an attempt to create a 1:1 relationship between the terms of an architecture (as defined by the article) and web design, which is a big ask.
- malvosenior 9y agoCraigslist is a great example of what actual brutalist design would look like on the web. Not the web, but ncurses and other cli like uis are probably brutalist. The examples in the blog post don't strike me as brutalist at all. More like Swiss modern, which at this point has been done to death. I think designers like the "clean" look but I find it to antiseptic and antihuman. Myspace was an example of a human (but not brutalist imho) design. Working in a hyper sterile environment as these designs all seem to me doesn't encourage creativity or jive with reality.
- naravara 9y agoWouldn't motherfuckingwebsite.com be the perfect distillation of the philosophy he's talking about?
- malvosenior 9y agoYeah.
- nostalgeek 9y ago> I'm confused. I don't see what makes most of the examples cited here "Brutalist" in any meaningful fashion. Because these examples have nothing to do with "brutalism" in architecture. It's just another buzzword misappropriated by (web) designers. 5 years ago everything was "flat" now everything is "brutalist" including what was "flat". Designers shouldn't pick a style because it's trendy, they should do their job as designers and actually design for their intended audience and medium. HN is no more "brutalist" than Craiglist. Effective web design should be optimized for fast loading times, readability, easy information retrieval and responsiveness. These issues are far more challenging than trying to fit a style du jour.
- inostia 9y agoIt also used to be called "anti-design". The concept has been around for a while. I really get annoyed when terms like "brutalism" are co-opted as yet another buzzword/trend/fad.
- JustSomeNobody 9y ago>I really get annoyed when terms like "brutalism" are co-opted as yet another buzzword/trend/fad. Along with native and real time.
- radley 9y ago> If we want to have Brutalism as a valid design approach for the web, we first need to decide on what exactly the word means. It's already been defined in the design community. Further, the post is well over a year behind common discussions on the return (not beginning) of Brutalism in web design. Brutalism in web design has been around since the beginning. Professional designers, influenced by artists popular during the 70s & 80s (Warhol, Laurie Anderson, Sex Pistols) used this approach deliberately as a way to challenge the bland markup style of early Yahoo et al... and now today's modern flat design.
- theoh 9y agoIt's a style or a sensibility in other words. Gorgeous rawness—not just accidental rawness. Don't ever try to convince an architect of that, though.
- joqje09309 9y agoI think you hit it with "unconventional layouts" bit. They're not neatly segregated along, with navigators aligned across the top or stacked on the left. Visual artifacts are all over, controls are all over. It's "brutalist" relative to the norm
- saint_fiasco 9y agoThe second definition might be a site like 4chan, where signing a post via tripcodes makes the cryptographic signature visible to users, and people quote other posts by referring to the post number, possibly even the same as the post id in the database.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bananarepdev 9y ago> And to the other definition, "exposed structures and visible thought processes," I'd point to... Have you ever got a stacktrace in an http 500 error page? There you have it :)
- someoneelse987 9y agoI like the word "brutal" in this context. > If we want to have Brutalism as a valid design approach for the web, we first need to decide on what exactly the word means. Otherwise it will just become... What's brutal about that though? Instead of "design by committees", do it brutally. Instead of A/B testing: throw it onto the screen. Instead of slick: rough. People will find the link that you want them to click, even when you are using design principles that are uncommon or "not like Google". A long as you are honest. And perhaps also brutal.
- pnathan 9y agobrutalism as an architectural concept does not connote violence. le brutalisme comes from the word "raw" in french; "raw concrete", that is.
- arkh 9y ago> I'm not sure there is any web site that would qualify as Brutalist by this definition. http://danluu.com/ http://danluu.com/
- keithpeter 9y agoAlmost Uses javascript at various point though.
- ReverseCold 9y agoLooks good in lynx
- tejon 9y ago+1 to this analysis. The very first thing I thought of when I saw the title was [1]. Most of the examples in the article just confused me. [1]: http://mlreference.com/ http://mlreference.com/
- lainga 9y agoAlso anything to do with Linux kernel development, I've noticed, especially lwn.net and lkml.org. On your last paragraph, I'm afraid that "web Brutalism" is already a parking lot. Anti-bourgeois? Really?
- GuB-42 9y agoI thought the same thing. Actually I thought "no css", make it the way pages look when only the html loads.
- ggg9990 9y agoI find JIRA also pretty “brutalist” in the style of Craigslist.
- dec0dedab0de 9y agoI'm not sure there is any web site that would qualify as Brutalist by this definition. maybe a page created on something like jsfiddle. Heck, sincewe compile js now, you could say anything that still has readable source counts.
- doomlaser 9y agoWikipedia is the closest thing that comes to mind. Anything that lets you form edit through html in raw html, or liberal markdown.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoSeems more Bauhaus to me.
- stephen_g 9y agoYeah, I think it's impossible for a web page or application to really be brutalist. Web pages, and really everything on the computer screen are a rendering of something. They don't have materials or material properties, they only represent or imitate them. So really they can never be honest to the materials. They can only imitate or evoke 'ideas' of brutalism.
- microcolonel 9y agoThe problem is that the people who complain the most about the "bourgeoisie" are the bourgeoisie themselves. Everyone else is content to live their lives without denigrating people for actually knowing what they're doing. Brutalism is stupid, anti-beauty, and destructive of mental health; which is why people who are just smart enough, and can afford too much beauty, thirst so much for it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- return1 9y ago> exposed structures and visible thought processes If you press F12, it turns any website to a brutalist one