111 ms·
Mark steal cookies, gets caught and serves his sentence in jail. Now Mark is out, looking for a job as a JavaScript developer but when Mark is Googled to check
by mrtksn 9y ago
Mark steal cookies, gets caught and serves his sentence in jail.
Now Mark is out, looking for a job as a JavaScript developer but when Mark is Googled to check about his involvement in OS projects and personal portfolio before his Github profile the article on CNN from 5 years ago is displayed and apparently Mark is a cookie monster.
Is Mark sentenced to never be employed again? Mark made a mistake but Is He really worse from all these people who commit crimes and never get caught or end up in the news?
Maybe the balance could be to not display Marks convictions until specifically asked for?
I don't say that I have the answer but I really don't understand the concept of unforgiveness.
Maybe we should approach all this from a utilitarian perspective? What's the utility of labelling Mark as a thief years after he paid for what he did?
- volak 9y agoThe problem is future employers don't know if mark made a one time mistake or is a serial cookie monster. Why would they hire mark over a similar employee with a clean record? Mark needs to be given the opportunity to demonstrate to an employer hes no longer a cookie monster. He needs to rebuild that trust. He would do this by taking a lower than average pay, agreeing to periodic cookie-tests, and giving the employer the option to terminate his employment at any time without cause. If mark really isn't a cookie monster anymore he should be fine with this precautions to minimize the company's risk - after a year or so when there is more trust these disappear.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoThis is not a realistic scenario: Pretty much all employers will just hire someone else.
- volak 9y agoIf I was HR and I had a choice between a Javascript developer for 50k with a clean record and a Javascript developer with a 5 year old conviction for 40k - I'd actually pick the later. But only if I could fire him immediately if he turns out to actually be a cookie monster.
- lovich 9y agoThat's how HR acts in practice though. Especially with automated tools, checking off a "have you ever had a prior conviction" box just gets you an automated rejection without a human ever looking at it
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoWhere I live they aren't allowed to ask anymore, I think. But they'll likely find out on a quick search.
- volak 9y agoYes a lot of companies do. Especially minimum wage jobs. Because there are vastly more people without a record willing to work. But now imagine you have a previous conviction but you are willing to work for less than minimum wage? If I value a fry cook for $10 an hour and I get 1 person with a previous conviction who wants to work for $5 - I'll hire him in a heartbeat so long as I could fire him at any moment. And since I'm a good employer I'll make him a deal to pay him $10 an hour after 6 months provided he stays clean and works hard. As it stands I'm not allowed to do any of that - so the convict remains unemployed and will probably commit more crime just to survive. I'll let my man Friedman take it from here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ca8Z__o52sk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ca8Z__o52sk
- lovich 9y agoThat's just going to make a space underclass. There's not a benefit to convicting people because hey, cheap labor. The same forces are already happening with prison labor. What you are suggesting is that any single mistake is now a permanent albatross around a person's neck and a reason for them to be permanently deprived. In a society where we have so many laws that everyone breaks several a day, this just leads to selective enforcement and corruption.
- jlarocco 9y ago> If mark really isn't a cookie monster anymore he should be fine with this precautions to minimize the company's risk - after a year or so when there is more trust these disappear. The problem is that "mark" will be bogged down with that punishment for the rest of his life at every job he works, so the punishment doesn't fit the crime. Being a former "cookie monster" should not mean a lifetime of lower pay and fewer employment rights. Facebook and Google's infinite memory, combined with all of our "zero tolerance" policies are going to make the United States a really crappy place to live in the not too distant future.
- volak 9y agoNot true - if mark has a resume listing a successful employment post-cookie incident I would call them for a reference. A good reference isn't completely trustworthy but 2 or 3 of them with good companies and I'd be convinced.
- Tehnix 9y agoTwo equal employees, that would be the eliminating point..
- octorian 9y agoAnd once Mark rebuilds trust with company A, all is good. Until, that is, Mark decides to get a new job. Once Mark goes to company B, they find the cookie monster article and make Mark completely rebuild trust from scratch. Then Mark has to move, and goes to company C. The cycle repeats again. Thus Mark is never able to truly get over the cookie monster incident.
- volak 9y agoNot true - if mark has a resume listing a successful employment post-cookie incident I would call them for a reference. A good reference isn't completely trustworthy but 2 or 3 of them with good companies and I'd be convinced.
- lovich 9y agoYou apparently live a privelaged life then. Laws are being passed in US states to prevent criminal history from being asked until an offer has been made precisely because people are not able to get over the result. The HR pipeline treats any sort of checkered pass as and immediate rejection, whether or not a hiring manager would treat it as such
- volak 9y agoTrue - 100% true. If I had a checkered past with no references I would expect to get denied for every job I applied to. To combat this prejudice I would fully expect to have to lower my expectations in the form of lower wage or other restriction. If I offer to work for half the normal pay not only will I definitely get hired but I'll get a good reference providing I prove myself capable and trustworthy.
- lovich 9y agoWhy would you get a good reference? Your boss can just always give a bad reference so that your forced to stay. After all he's getting cheap labor, and you have to risk never getting employed again. You're coming at this from a viewpoint that implies that companies want to help people, when we are already dealing with that fact that they absolutely do not
- gremy0 9y agoIf your criminal record is truly relevant to the job, then the employer should do the responsible thing and get a proper background check done. Which are factual and non-biased. Such things shouldn't be left up to google page ranking algorithms and media that tends toward sensationalisation. It's lazy and unprofessional. > Why would they hire mark over a similar employee with a clean record? Is it useful to have people with a history of low level crime habitually unemployable. Don't we want to reduce crime. > Mark needs to be given the opportunity to demonstrate to an employer hes no longer a cookie monster. Mark is innocent of further crimes until he is convicted and the employer would need to have reasonable cause to discriminate against him. We have parole and other such mechanisms where official bodies can decide how long a person needs to speed demonstrating they are no longer a criminal, and make sure the relevant people are aware of this. Why leave it up to some random employer armed with google. > He would do this by taking a lower than average pay, Why does he deserve lower pay. This is just enabling employers to take advantage of vulnerable people. > and giving the employer the option to terminate his employment at any time without cause. The employer has the right to terminate at any time for mark committing a criminal act. He doesn't need this. Plus this is europe and workers have rights
- volak 9y agoI don't like to break up arguments into tiny pieces and remark on each one - so I'll just wrap this up in 1 thought like a normal person. You are essentially complaining about human nature. Here in reality people want to know if you've violated someone else's trust before trusting you. We are social beings and if you present two people - "This one betrayed a friend, this other one has not" - 99% of people will choose the later. You will never ever convince a majority of people that someone who has demonstrated untrustability should be trusted the same as someone who has not. Regardless of how long he spent in a steel and concrete cage.
- gremy0 9y agoYou misunderstand, I'm saying there are fair and professional ways to find out if someone is trustworthy. Googling their name, and finding some 5 year old article is not one of these. It presents a incomplete picture that is biased towards attention grabbing material from for-profit media. Use proper background checks and references. There are also fair ways to deal with criminals, and staff you may not trust. Using google results as the bases of randomly deducting pay, removing employment rights, and other discriminatory acts, is not one of these. It would be far too easy for employers to abuse and doesn't lend itself to the employee having stability. This would just increase the chances of the employee returning to crime.
- bsder 9y ago> The problem is future employers don't know if mark made a one time mistake or is a serial cookie monster. Why would they hire mark over a similar employee with a clean record? Because for certain types of cookie monster, those who steal cookies, get caught, and serve their penalty are MORE trustworthy than the population at large.
- darkmighty 9y agoBut you're not talking about forgiveness, you're talking about forgetting. Forgiveness is when we acknowledge mistakes and give them another chance, forgetting is when we erase mistakes. Perhaps instead of artificially limiting our own memory we should be looking to learn to better forgive people in the age of perfect recall.
- mrtksn 9y agoAm I? Do the victims forget Mark? Do his friends and family forget what Mark did years ago? Are the criminal records also deleted? You search For Mark Javascript, you are greeted with "You won't believe what Mark, a JavaScript Developer, did to steal cookies" headlines. A lot of the News is for-profit entertainment, it's not public record of Mark but public record of entertainment. The same "News" source might have omitted the news about Oliver the Cookie monster because he advertises a lot with them and they don't want to lose his business. Maybe it's simply not his potential employers job to forgive Mark. The employer is put in such a position because he's exposed to information that's not his business in first place.
- bad_user 9y agoYou’re an idealist, the world doesn’t work this way. Mark paid his debt to society by time served. And if you want to not hire ex convicts, you simply ask for his criminal record. Is that not a possibility in the US? Anyhow, Google giving you tabloids or other crap simply cannot be a reliable criminal record. And note we’re talking of somebody that’s actually proven guilty in a court of law. What about people being the target of scandals that aren’t guilty of anything?
- fixermark 9y agoRecently, some states have passed laws barring criminal record requesting for employment purposes.
- nsp 9y agoIf you’re referring to the “ban the box” campaigns in Sf/nyc et al, I believe those just prohibit asking on the application (so the candidate has a chance to win you over), not checking for a criminal record entirely.
- Supernaut 9y agoBecause if we know that he stole cookies before, he must axiomatically be considered less trustworthy around cookies than someone who has no history of treat theft. That doesn't mean that Mark doesn't deserve a second chance at life. But it does mean that, for the first while at least, you are ill-advised to give him the keys to the room where the cookies are kept.
- izacus 9y ago> Because if we know that he stole cookies before, he must axiomatically be considered less trustworthy around cookies than someone who has no history of treat theft. For his entire life? Even if he was a teenager or young? Doesn't american society even consider something as simple as possibility of changing your behaviour in 60+ years of life? I mean... half of my most successful highschoolmates, leading great companies and organizations, would be untrustworthy and unemployable by American logic since they smoked a bit of pot and got caught for it.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoSmoking pot is not the same as theft. One is harmless to society, the other is not.
- F_r_k 9y agoYet, some people have got a different point of view and think that smoking pot is not harmless to society. Same thing and op's point of view and yours
- lotsofpulp 9y agoHaving a different point of view doesn't make it valid, you need a chain of reasoning with cause and effect.
- izacus 9y ago> Smoking pot is not the same as theft. One is harmless to society, the other is not. With the current US system those both things will punish you for the whole life, even if you grow out of it. Even if its petty theft. Or large theft. Or a bit of pot. Or selling pot. Social media and background checks will damage your future prospects forever for a minor thing that doesn't make a difference in other societies.
- sheepz 9y agoThis a perfectly bad example, because your example makes the reader's intuition pump in a certain way. Consider the alternative story where Mark is a wife beater. Would still come to the same conclusion? Or does it say something about Mark's character or his possible future behavior?
- dx034 9y agoEven if that was his crime it shouldn't prevent him from getting a job. Forcing people to drop out of the labour market massively increases the chance of them committing another crime. Rehabilitation works best if you give people a second chance.
- 21 9y agoWhat's good for the society is not necessarily good for the individual. Him getting a job is good for society, but I don't want to be the one shouldering the risk. For the individual it's a high risk / low reward situation, so the rational decision is to pass. Tragedy of the commons.
- mrtksn 9y agoWhat risk? It's just easy to pass and assume that those who don't have News articles about are lower risk. Not all crimes are reported on the News as it's for-profit entertainment business that needs to pick the most shocking/entertaining incidents and portray those in a way that more people share it.
- 21 9y agoBayesian statistics, there are different priors. The probability of a convicted person to do something criminal again is not the same as the risk of an random unconvicted person, just like the risk of a flood reoccurring in a previously flooded area: > According to an April 2011 report by the Pew Center on the States, the average national recidivism rate for released prisoners is 43%.[2] > According to the National Institute of Justice, about 68 percent of 405,000 prisoners released in 30 states in 2005 were arrested for a new crime within three years of their release from prison, and 77 percent were arrested within five years. > According to a national study published in 2003 by The Urban Institute, within three years almost 7 out of 10 released males will be rearrested and half will be back in prison. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recidivism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recidivism
- sdenton4 9y agoDon't employers use actual background checks for this, though? With rules for what stays on the record and what disappears after a set number of years?
- kodablah 9y ago> Is Mark sentenced to never be employed again? This is not Google's fault and they should not be the one's being punished. If a government wants to have a say here they can, but in general society will act on information and you can't hide it from them.
- ataturk 9y agoI think you are all misunderstanding the purpose of all of this. Google and government are working together to relieve you of as many rights and freedoms as possible. What one can't accomplish, the other can, which is why they work in conjunction. As far as crimes go, all will be guilty of "serious" crimes in the future because it is the easiest way to strip you of your rights as a citizen. It's just all so obvious what is going on here.
- DannyBee 9y ago"Maye the balance could be to not display Marks convictions until specifically asked for?" This is basically the status quo before. But ... the employer is going to background check mark and find them anyway, because they are public record and available in easily searchable databases (see Lexis, etc) In practice, this stuff simply doesn't affect any employment case (at least in the US). None of the right to be forgotten stuff allows you to avoid any of the above except the "easy google search" (which again, practically doesn't matter). So the argument you make should be limited to that. (and i think it is entirely reasonable to question whether your neighbors, who won't background check you, but will search google, should find it)
- alistairSH 9y agoTo the employment case... With the pre-Google system, at least Mark gets his foot in the door and has a chance to impress the prospective employer during the interview process. While his conviction may still impact his employment prospects, at least he has a fighting chance. With Google in place, Mark never receives a call-back. The employer doesn't bother. How much does this impact Mark in the real world? I have no idea. But, I'd prefer the non-Google system and avoid the potential of Mark never finding meaningful employment.
- DannyBee 9y ago"With the pre-Google system, at least Mark gets his foot in the door and has a chance to impress the prospective employer during the interview process. While his conviction may still impact his employment prospects, at least he has a fighting chance." While this sounds like intuitive it is, AFAIK, wrong. I'm pretty sure there are ssrn papers/etc on this, where they found that 99% of employers (or something ridiculous) had non-overridable policies, so in practice, no, there was no fighting chance. I'd personally prefer a system where neither could be used after a cooling off period depending on crime.
- alistairSH 9y agoOof. I knew those policies existed. But if it’s truly 99%, out system is well and truly broken.
- arnarbi 9y ago> Is Mark sentenced to never be employed again? The argument seems to be that because society does pass that sentence already, we who disagree should "fix" it by making sure society doesn't learn that Mark is a cookie monster. Does that not sound backwards? If the answer to your question is really "no", then we wouldn't need to have this discussion. I suppose I can see the argument that things are unfair to Mark because other people got away with stealing cookies without having it on the public record.
- mrtksn 9y agoI agree that it’s backwards but it’s not realistic to expect that from now on people will act rationally and not dismiss without a chance for an explanation a perfectly capable coder, Mark the Javascript developer, simply because his crime ended up in the news. News doesn’t cover all the criminals even if they are convicted. For the most part, It’s an entertainment and the editorial process can make Mark unemployable because his crime brought a lot of ad impressions but the wife beater never ended up on the news because wasn’t shocking or interesting enough.
- briandear 9y agoAppeal to CNN. They’re the ones that published the info. It happened. Can’t change that. It’s up to the employer to decide if it is relevant or not. Hiding the fact doesn’t change that it happened. The reaction to what happened is the responsibility of the employer — it certainly isn’t Google’s job to make judgements.
- Guanjin 9y agoI'm someone who once upon a time had a very bad trip after consuming some hallucinations, then freaked out and resisted when the cops attempted to arrest me. Local news heard the story and had a field day reporting on it. I served 3 months for it but now it will follow me around for the rest of my life. I'm not a bad person but one might get that perspective googling my name and there's essentially nothing I can ever do about that except try and manipulate the page rank and/or change my name. I appreciate that there are people out there like you that consider the views of people like "Mark".
- mrtksn 9y agoEveryone makes mistakes, only some are punished and even less ends up as subject to the entertainment 'news' industry. I hope you're doing well and I'm glad that you're not repeating your mistake.