5 ms·
Tyranny of the majority much? Elected officials don't exist to simply determine what 50%+1 of the voting population wants. They're not supposed to act as a popu
by pc86 9y ago
Tyranny of the majority much? Elected officials don't exist to simply determine what 50%+1 of the voting population wants. They're not supposed to act as a popularity sieve.
You should be voting for people because they generally share your views, yes, but more importantly because they're willing and able to become experts in the things you need to be an expert in in order to be an effective lawmaker.
- 076ae80a-3c97-4 9y agoAs someone who lives in the UK, this is funny and also makes me cry a little.
- fredley 9y agoCould be worse, could be in the US.
- OtterCoder 9y agoHaving watched even a little C-SPAN, I really, really don't understand the 'expert' argument that always gets trotted out. Senators range from well meaning but unable to keep up, to complete blathering idiots. They don't have time to be experts in anything.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago> You should be voting for people because they generally share your views I have actually come to disagree with this sentiment. Look at what we have right now in the US: pretty much complete gridlock when it isn't just partisan curb-stomping. No one is willing to compromise, no one wants to discuss things rationally. Everyone goes in with their answer and attempts to beat others into accepting it and it's our fault, as voters, because it's what we ask of them, because we keep being told that we should vote for people who share our opinions. I think we should vote for people not because they share our views, which are likely based in ignorance, but because they demonstrate the ability to make informed decisions and come to reasonable compromises. Look for the ones who think things through, who are willing to admit they made a mistake, and who will change their opinion in light of new information.
- haZard_OS 9y agoYou make a good point but for one wrinkle: How many politicians can admit to a mistake and actually change in response to new information? Add the characteristic of "able to make genuine compromises" into your search and it seems your results would hover around 0 every time.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoDon't blame me, I voted for the other lizard. If we continue to vote for people without these qualities, our elected officials will continue to lack them.
- dclowd9901 9y agoThere is no incentive to vote for a compromiser when the other side won't. All you're doing is sacrificing all your footing for the sake of movement in the wrong direction. We're at a gridlock because a significant portion of this country is woefully misinformed about just about everything and are puppets to an incredible machine of profit and no-holds-barred capitalism.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoAnd by participating in that system under those terms you are only encouraging it. Change begins when someone decides to do something different, and it's usually a risk, but if no one takes it everything stays the same. You have no one to blame but yourself if you refuse to even try.
- fjsolwmv 9y ago"we" don't get to decide who gets funding from the Party elites, free airtime from the media, etc.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoThen we don't have a democracy and therefore shouldn't even bother voting.
- firstplacelast 9y ago>but more importantly because they're willing and able to become experts in the things you need to be an expert in in order to be an effective lawmaker. Did you not watch the latest Zuckerberg deposition? Most of our officials do not care about becoming experts in anything. They're old, tired, and ignorant and they are mostly concerned with maintaining power, not learning new material.