4 ms·
The problem is that most normal market forces don't apply. Often neither the patient nor the doctor know the price of the 'product' on offer. And to the exten
by dagw 9y ago
The problem is that most normal market forces don't apply. Often neither the patient nor the doctor know the price of the 'product' on offer. And to the extent the doctors do know the price they have an incentive to offer the more expensive drug since they make more money that way. And since the patient is rarely paying the full cost they have no reason to price compare and will simply 'buy' what they're told is the best. In most cases Patients aren't even paying for their insurance (to a first approximation) so they don't even have a secondary intensive to keep their premiums low.
Finally people are really bad and uncomfortable with putting a price on human life. I feel perfectly comfortable weighing the pros and cons of different cars or laptops at different prices, and perfectly happy to walk away if I can't find anything I like at a price I want to pay. I have no idea how I would react to having to put a price on how much I'd be willing to pay for a 70% chance to keep my daughter alive for another 2-4 years. But I suspect if forced to decide I would give the highly irrational answer "everything I own plus everything I can borrow", and all the companies in the field are completely aware of this fact
- watwut 9y agoEven where patient don't negotiate, insurance company could. I have seen itemized lists of hospital stay where band-aid or temperature measuring costed ridiculous money. Not everything costly is death vs life choice. I think a lot would be much cheaper, if there would be better price transparency. The bad transparency is not so much about bad feeling of putting price on it, but also that it is profitable. The same entity that hides prices will turn you back if you are not insured without visible bad feeling. Also, plenty of people are uninsured or under-insured and money they have to pay out of pocked hurt them. They postpone doctor visit till the last possible moment, they take half dosage etc.