3 ms·
Yeah, prohibition has worked out lots of times.
by busterarm 9y ago
Yeah, prohibition has worked out lots of times.
- jakelazaroff 9y agoWhen people refer to prohibitions failing, they're generally referring to consensual or victimless crimes: drugs, alcohol, (non-coerced) prostitution, gambling, etc. That's not the case here. Coercion and violence are component to human trafficking. Taking down Backpage and similar websites isn't "prohibition" any more than laws against murder are.
- busterarm 9y agoAnd I think you missed the point completely and that's exactly why my comment had to be made. The fact that you use murder here is a perfect example. Prohibition measures are all about restricting the availability of something to curb the desire of it. With the sole exception of the Quaalude, it has never worked. A single government had to convince a global industry to stop its production entirely. There were only like 7 or 9 labs making it though. Oh and with designer drug labs in China, you can actually get ludes made now if you're clever. Human trafficking, coercion and violence is a side-effect of a desire creating a market. Driving that market underground will not eliminate the market, you have to eliminate peoples' desire for that thing. You can't globally stop the production of human beings to curtail this market like they did with Quaaludes... Murder is just about the freest, easiest thing you can do if that's your desire. Murder rates are on the decline because it's just something not that many people want to do anymore.
- creddit 9y agoSee Singapore's drug use policies.
- busterarm 9y agoWhich are the complete opposite of prohibition. Singapore's policies have nothing to do with restricting access. They're torture, life imprisonment or the death penalty. Apples to Oranges.
- creddit 9y agoI'm very confused by how you mean this. I don't see why the type of penalties used means the policies aren't for restricting access under your definitions. It seems abundantly clear to me that they restrict access by making it so immensely costly to traffic drugs (ie provide access to drugs) that few are willing to do it. This is criminal justice 101 stuff.
- jakelazaroff 9y agoThe crux of the prohibition argument is this: > Human trafficking, coercion and violence is a side-effect of a desire creating a market. But this will never be a legitimate market. We're talking about money being exchanged for sex with children. That is inherently violent, and has absolutely nothing to do with whatever market may or may not exist. The argument against prohibition is that making the thing illegal is more harmful than regulating it. That's not the case with murder, and it's not the case with human trafficking — any occurrence of it is harmful, regardless of how you regulate it.
- anonbanker 9y agoThis is the most clever "No True Scottsman" fallacy I've ever seen.
- jakelazaroff 9y agoAre you talking about my excluding murder and human trafficking from the definition of "prohibition"? That's not a "No True Scotsman" fallacy. They're illegal, but it's disingenuous to say laws against them are tantamount to legal prohibition a la alcohol. Look at the Wikipedia article got prohibitionism [1]: literally every example is of a victimless crime, which murder and human trafficking clearly are not.
- azinman2 9y agoFor the opposite effect, see legalization of marijuana. It was never fully removed from the (black) market while illegal, but since legalization easy access has meant usage has dramatically increased.
- nickthemagicman 9y ago99.9999999999999 % of ads were for legit prostitution on backpage. There were also many other uses for backpage. You think if a child trafficker posts a single ad on Hacker News...that the entire site should be shut down? No this was heavy handed and a huge step towards censoring the web as we know it.
- scottie_m 9y agoIn your hypothetical the site admins would have to be aware of the ads, profiting from them, laundering the profits, etc. In that case yes, burn HN down and scatter the ashes. Of course thst isn’t what they’d do, is it? They’d report the ad, delete it, and try to prevent any more such ads from appearing, which is the polar opposite of the actions taken. by Backpage. I’d also like a citation on your numbers, and how you can tell the difference between “legit prostitution” and someone being trafficked or pimped. I’d add that if you actually care about broader issues of censorship, you could not be doing a worse and more counterproductive job of promulgating those beliefs if you tried.
- nickthemagicman 9y agoWhat about forums sites like reddit/8chan/4chan who don't have enough admins to monitor the thousands of forums that are created on a periodic basis.... What about if the admins wanted to take a week off? There's no doubt this gives the govt massive censorship power and forces a beauracratic burden on sites to hire more admins. You're cool with throwing away our liberties and free internet all over something so statistically miniscule in comparison to the rest of the web.
- scottie_m 9y agoWe try to prohibit plenty of things, like murder and rape. What’s wrong with that? The imperfection of our attempts in. Omway invalidates those attempts, and the prevailing wisdom supported by evidence is that prohibiting violent crimes has better outcomes than not. Raping children and trafficking them for the purposes of rape is pretty violent, and while some black market will exist, it’s worth constraining, and fighting. This isn’t prohibition against adults choosing to smoke some pot or have a drink after all, and trying to parlay the semantics of that prohibition to this discussion is grossly inappropriate.
- busterarm 9y agoPeople don't seem to want to consider that prohibition of these things is exactly the measure that creates violence around them. This is exactly the thing that sex workers are opposing this law and the destruction of Backpage for. I'm not saying make it legal and I'd happily throw the switch on any human trafficker or child rapist myself. The point is not to take people who are already in a desperate situation and put them in the way of more harm. That's what this does. It's an easy win for whatever politician is pushing this but does next to nothing to combat the real problem.
- scottie_m 9y agoRaping a child is violence. Kidnapping is violence, as is trafficking humans for the purpose of being raped. These are inherently violent acts. You cannot take the violence out of raping kids or sex trafficking them. Prohibition measures are all about restricting the availability of something to curb the desire of it. No one thinks that you’re reducing demand for raping children by cracking down on child rapists. People think that they can reduce the rates of child rape by arresting people who rape children, and facilitate the rape of children. They also think that it’s worth saving some people from being raped, even if it’s a given that you can’t save everyone. Murder is just about the freest, easiest thing you can do if that's your desire. Murder rates are on the decline because it's just something not that many people want to do anymore. What? No. The risks of being caught for murdering someone have increased, so it’s far from free and easy unless you don’t care about losing your freedom or life as a result. The same applies for trafficking children for sex. You reduce activity by increasing the cost in the cost:benefit relationship. While people driven to murder will still do it, you reduce things like casual killing, or murder for hire. While you’re not going to make pedophiles lose their desire to rape kids, you can reduce the willingness of the people supplying them with kids to try and profit from those urges. Prostitutes were so much safer when they had pimps and had to stand out on the street and hop into peoples' cars, right? I question both your reasoning and your motives, given that you’re switching between talking about child sex trafficking and prostitution.