7 ms·
And the CEO himself pleaded guilty to money laundering. I remember people here were coming out in droves to defend the company against big bad government when t
by paxys 9y ago
And the CEO himself pleaded guilty to money laundering. I remember people here were coming out in droves to defend the company against big bad government when the site was first seized.
This line is particularly condemning:
> It was involved in 73 percent of all child trafficking cases reported to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children.
- AFNobody 9y ago> And the CEO himself pleaded guilty to money laundering. I remember people here were coming out in droves to defend the company against big bad government when the site was first seized. They weren't defending Backpage, they were condemning the power grab in the form of a law that was passed (but has not yet been signed) where they let this whole situation languish to make it easier to "sell" the new powers for the Government. You are confusing the fight over FOSTA/SESTA/etc. with the fight over Backpage just like the people who pushed those laws intended you to.
- stale2002 9y agoActually, I saw lots of people defending backpage. It is some sort of new age leftist thing, where the argument is that backpage somehow made things safer for sex workers.
- williamscales 9y agoI believe there is a valid argument that giving sex workers a platform where they can advertise relatively safely improves their safety. I, for one, did not really research Backpage that much and so was unaware of the reality of the allegations against them. For myself, I chose not to weigh in on the debate, even though I have the belief I stated above, because I didn't feel I had enough background.
- andymoe 9y agoNo, this is the actual sex workers saying “places like backpage, where I can vet clients ahead of time, keeps me safer.”
- oep2929 9y agoThe issue is when the only choice is “poke or be broke” it’s time to rethink our culture We’re all forced to sell our time but what we have to offer varies You wanna suck dick for a meal? You hiring people without tech skills? There’s a whole lot of “sucking it up” for a lot of women with little choice but to “suck for survival”
- jjeaff 9y agoSo you think if we had a better social safety net like say, the Netherlands, we would see less prostitution?
- noobermin 9y agoNot speaking for the green account, but, yes, I think improving the economic standing of all people would go a long way towards getting people out of the sex trade or from entering into it.
- loggedinmyphone 9y agoI'm pretty sure the comment you responded to was sarcasm, given the prevalence of red light districts in the Netherlands.
- stale2002 9y agoYes, I'm sure it works great for the upper middle class white escorts who are essentially small business owners. The issue is the effect that it has on trafficking, and that it makes trafficking much more profitable.
- noobermin 9y agoInstead of making assumptions about the people you believe you're saving, it would help to actually listen to them about what would help them and what wouldn't. Above I share an article from a former sex worker. Here is yet another that cites[0] sex workers as well. [0] https://www.thecut.com/2018/03/sesta-anti-sex-trafficking-bill-fosta.html https://www.thecut.com/2018/03/sesta-anti-sex-trafficking-bi...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- chc 9y agoDo you think backpage is actually less safe than working with a pimp? A place can be pretty bad and still preferable to the alternative if that alternative is bad enough.
- pharrington 9y agoNo. Turns out that question is irrelevant, because Backpage and pimps were empirically compatible.
- chc 9y agoYou're drawing a false dilemma here. The question isn't "Was it possible for pimps to go on Backpage?" but "How easy was it to work without a pimp on Backpage versus on the street?" That's the argument people were making — not that nothing bad ever happened where Backpage was involved, but that sex workers feel more required to put themselves in bad situations in the absence of something like Backpage.
- jakelazaroff 9y agoLikewise, the argument that people who support the takedown are making isn't "it was possible to use Backpage for prostitution", but "Backpage themselves were actively colluding with human traffickers". Maybe sex workers are less safe now that Backpage is gone, and that sucks — but it doesn't mean we let people working with human traffickers slide.
- chc 9y agoIf you look back a bit in the thread, the idea that I was disagreeing with is that this proves people were wrong when they said Backpage made many sex workers safer. I'm not saying we should let the Backpage people slide, but that the ideas "Backpage was involved in some very messed-up stuff that people should go to jail for" and "Backpage was better than the streets for sex workers on the whole" can both be true simultaneously.
- paxys 9y ago
- paxys 9y agoYou must have skipped over the many hundreds of "Backpage actually reduces trafficking" comments.
- noobermin 9y agoIf you actually listen to sex workers and people who were victims of trafficking, this is not the way to go. Law enforcement can be very unhelpful to sex workers and giving them more powers puts them in danger. Moreover, not having online platforms to screen customers and share information amongst themselves isolates sex workers and further endangers them, forcing them to engage in dangerous work on the street. Here is a good link on this[0]. Here[1] is also a short interview of the author. [0] https://www.allure.com/story/sesta-sex-trafficking-bill-celebrity-psa https://www.allure.com/story/sesta-sex-trafficking-bill-cele... [1] https://youtu.be/2TEcWKz_TAg?t=8m52s https://youtu.be/2TEcWKz_TAg?t=8m52s
- sgc 9y agoOr they could look at the current guilty plea and the public evidence tied to it and come to a reasonable conclusion. That anecdotally some people are helped does not make up for the crimes committed against even more vulnerable members of society using that site. I disagree with the new law, but the site had to go.
- jjeaff 9y agoWe're not just talking about trafficked adult women. Backpage is alleged to have facilitated a huge number of underage child sex trafficking transactions. Apparently, with some knowledge of what was going on.
- AFNobody 9y agoWhere were they and in context on HN? And please prove there were hundreds.
- nopressure 9y agoNah, people were alarmed here only about whores not being able to sell themselves.
- orbitingpluto 9y agoUnfortunately all this might mean is that child trafficking cases not reported on Backpage have a much higher chance of never being reported. So I don't view the statement particularly condemning RELATIVE TO (note the emphasis!) non-Backpage child trafficking cases. Furthermore, the age distribution of victims between Backpage vs non-Backpage victims probably differs considerably.
- azinman2 9y agoIt also cuts off a significant channel. Only time will tell, but chances are it could make a large impact in reduction.
- pfisch 9y agoThat is bullshit. I'm sure there are already 100 other sites doing this. This is like shutting down piratebay. No one really cares except the owners. As if you would shut down your very profitable human trafficking business because backpage.com is down. You already have your dungeons and people or whatever is entailed in this sick shit. You would just go to another site.
- creddit 9y agoThis argument is so often used; that shutting down access to one means of doing an illegal or negative act doesn't matter because there are other means and it's always false. Any time you increase the cost of doing something by a non-trivial amount you are almost certain to decrease the amount that thing is done. The assumptions you make that you lead you to your conclusion aren't clearly based in fact: 1) It is effectively costless to move to a new service 2) Any new service has equivalent demand 3) The profits are significant (your very profitable human trafficking business) The first is clearly false. You'll need to move all your workflows to a new platform, learn the new platform, understand how to market on it, etc. The second is also clearly false. These are marketplaces meaning there are strong network effects. Backpage was likely the best marketplace meaning it had very large portions of both the supply side and demand side. Now, how do you what service to move to when no service is dominant yet? You don't. You almost certainly see decreased marketplace effects in the "100 other sites doing this". For the third, is there any reason at all to believe the human trafficking business is "very profitable"? It seems like a very small market with very high costs. Of course, a further effect here is the deterrent that shutting down such a website will be to developers who may wish to replace backpage. A further example of what I will call "the fallacy of costless transfer" is in suicide prevention. Removing access to easy means of suicide, prevents the likelihood of committing suicide. Hence why there is to be a net around the golden gate bridge to catch jumpers.
- praneshp 9y ago> I remember people here were coming out in droves to defend the company Including this week, when someone linked either a troy hunt or krebs post about it.
- ubernostrum 9y agoMost of what I saw was "the government said they needed these new laws since they couldn't go after Backpage with existing laws, then they seized Backpage and pressed charges before the new laws were in effect, what's up with that".
- psyc 9y agoI don't know whether people literally defended the company or not, and I'm willing to take your word for it. However, let's be careful not to confuse defending this one company, with defending constitutional rights or (separately) the moral/ethical legitimacy of voluntary sex work. Those strike me as things some HN readers would be more likely to defend.
- fahayekwasright 9y agoI bet a sizable amount of sex worker advertising is now on Tinder and Instagram. Shut them down too?
- mtgx 9y agoBut none of those charges that got him needed SESTA to exist...and he was charged with 79 felonies: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20180409/18423839598/federal-backpage-indictment-shows-sesta-unnecessary-contains-zero-sex-trafficking-charges.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20180409/18423839598/feder...
- ryanlol 9y ago>This line is particularly condemning: Given the scale at which Backpage operated, it really is not.