3 ms·
People turn into thugs in large part because of their position in power dynamics. That is, it's most probably that it's the job that makes people thugs, not the
by barrkel 16y ago
People turn into thugs in large part because of their position in power dynamics. That is, it's most probably that it's the job that makes people thugs, not the people themselves (decent though they may be outside the job). Cf. Stanford Prison Experiment etc.
- tptacek 16y agoThe Stanford Prison Experiment suggests that we be on guard for situations where power dynamics encourage thuggish behavior. It does not, however, follow from the experiment that every law enforcement officer is a thug.
- dgordon 16y ago"Not every X is Y" is almost never a relevant or meaningful argument. It certainly doesn't answer "Position X promotes Y-like behavior, and so many "decent, average people" in position X will be Ys."