3 ms·
One thing that came to mind is that computers are notoriously brittle compared to a brain. If you damage a single transistor in the processor you can bring down
by phkahler 9y ago
One thing that came to mind is that computers are notoriously brittle compared to a brain. If you damage a single transistor in the processor you can bring down the whole thing. Not so sensitive with components in memory. We know the brain can take some damage and still function quite well, but are there single neurons or tiny groups of them that will basically bring down the system if damaged?
I also think the brain has important features more detailed in function than a 6502 so the applicability of the methods isn't necessarily invalid. For example, we don't know why neurons can transfer mitochondria between them, we don't know what is encoded in DNA, we don't even know how instinctive behaviors are encoded (or perhaps I just don't know).
As someone who once reverse engineered a processor from the gates up, I honestly don't know how one could do it top-down. The details at the bottom are critical, but also not critical. Decoding the microcode was critical, but determining precise timing and some other things was not needed to write a fairly functional emulator.
- darkmighty 9y ago> We know the brain can take some damage and still function quite well, but are there single neurons or tiny groups of them that will basically bring down the system if damaged? I like this question. I'm not a neuroscientist though, but I think most neurons come in fibers that contain several of them. So even if a certain connection was critical, a single one dying will still leave a functional fiber. Because neurons are plastic (to a limited but significant extent), any effect from that single neuron can be partially or completely compensated.
- titzer 9y agoWell, multicore CPUs are generally manufactured with a higher core count than they are sold as. Automated testing detects defects and bins individual wafers based on the maximum clock frequency at which they run without errors. So in some sense, CPUs are robust to some flaws in the lithography process by virtue of disabling broken cores/cache banks. Of course, this isn't done dynamically like a brain.