3 ms·
>devices that do a fetch-decode-execute-retire loop against a register file and a memory bus have perversely little in common with what neurobiology is concerne
by foldr 9y ago
>devices that do a fetch-decode-execute-retire loop against a register file and a memory bus have perversely little in common with what neurobiology is concerned with.
A key point of the article is that we can't really be sure this is the case, since the analytical tools used by neuroscience arguably wouldn't reveal this kind of structure even if it did exist.
- sigi45 9y agoWe do know this already. Our brain is not a pure blackbox. It is also a counterargument for the paper itself: If you know so little about two different systems, than you can't take any tool from system 1 and use it on system 2 and expect any resemblence or transfer of results.
- foldr 9y agoWe don't know that there aren't parts of the brain that use a fetch decode execute loop. The paper points out that although the 6502 does in fact work that way, this is far from obvious when examining it at the transistor level.
- sigi45 9y agoNot knowing something doesn't mean we don't know anything. Yes we are not 100% sure that there is somewhere a fetch decode execute loop but right know with the knowledge we have, it is unrealistic.
- foldr 9y agoWhat makes it unrealistic?
- sigi45 9y agoBecause we do know how neural network works and our brain is a huge one. Why would you wan't something like this to be in our brains anyway? Its already a problem to have data an processing divided.
- foldr 9y agoWe don't know how the neural networks in our brains work at anything like the level of detail required to draw the conclusion you're suggesting. What I want is obviously irrelevant.
- gus_massa 9y agoThe nice part of evolution is that most of the times you can see some leftover of the intermediate steps. For example, for the eye you can find animals with different complexity of eyes from a simple flat photosensitive area to a full eye of vertebrates (or cephalopods, that have a different but similar eye design). So in most case you can get some people to specialize and understand the simple models and create concepts and tools to understand the more complex models. In electronic circles you still have floating around a lot of mini-integrated circuits with 20-50 transistors that are easy to understand. And you can learn to group individual transistors in mall groups that do something useful (for example limit the output current, simulate a resistors, amplification, ...) Then you can learn to decode the intermediate models with 100-1000 transistors, and then the models with a few thousand of transistors, and then ... So, it's very suspicious that there are no animals with a minibrain with is finite automata of 3 states. There are also some cases where all the intermediate steps dissapared, for example the transition form prokaryote(bacteria) to eukaryote (animal, plants, protozoa, ...) And IIRC nobody understand the intermediate steps. But there are some clues, many structures are shared between prokaryotes and eukaryotes, mitochondria are probably trapped bacteria (they have their own DNA and too many external membranes, ...)
- foldr 9y ago>So, it's very suspicious that there are no animals with a minibrain with is finite automata of 3 states. What is your basis for saying that no such animals exist? Exactly how many states there are depends a great deal on the level of analysis. How many states does a 6502 have? At the physical level, an enormously large (possibly even infinite) number. At the level of analysis appropriate for programming one, considerably fewer.