4 ms·
His entire position is that, as an American Citizen, it really is none of their business what he was doing. Now that I think of it, shouldn't the job of Custom
by ghshephard 16y ago
His entire position is that, as an American Citizen, it really is none of their business what he was doing. Now that I think of it, shouldn't the job of Customs and Immigration be the following for returning American Citizens:
A) Confirm that you are an American Citizen.
B) Confirm that you are importing goods properly.
- viraptor 16y agoI don't disagree that he does not have to answer questions. That does not mean security staff cannot ask questions. Do you think it really matters what you answer? Would anyone say "I was organising an attack on X.", "I was meeting with Russian mafia.", etc.? Most of the people will say "business", "family visit" or something similar anyways. The person who doesn't - whatever the reason - is the one to look at. Still - I see the reason why the questions are being asked. Even if you don't have to answer. I'd really like to see if you'd get the same treatment if you simply said "I do not want to answer this question, because I'm not required to." with a smile instead of being passive-agressive.
- ghshephard 16y agoHow certain are you that you haven't just violated a law with that answer? And, how certain are you that response won't be used against you in a criminal case? I'm actually serious - I don't have the legal background to understand whether your response ""I do not want to answer this question, because I'm not required to." would put me in legal peril.
- viraptor 16y agoYou have doubts against my answer - which is ok of course. Yet, you don't question "none of your business", which is demonstrably worse in at least two ways (social interaction, perceived aggression). Can you show why? Even for a non-lawyer like me it shouts "verbal abuse of staff". > how certain are you that response won't be used against you in a criminal case? If there is a way to use that answer against me, I've already potentially lost any and all cases against me. If such response can be used against you, why do you believe your law to not answer will be honoured? You'll make a lot more mistakes of saying something wrong while proving you're right, since you will have to speak many more times. It is simply not a realistic scenario. You'll have to assume some things are not a work of government against you, in order to even begin fighting for freedom of not answering a simple question.
- ghshephard 16y agore: "None of your business" - Appeal to authority. The author is a Lawyer and states that is an acceptable response. If you indicated you had legal training, and that "...because I'm not required to " would not put you in legal jeopardy, I'd take you at your word. In general, saying less is probably the safest approach if you are concerned about legal jeopardy. Not answering gives the individual interrogating you less leverage. You do have a right to silence once the basics (Your identity) are out of the way. Ironically, that is how the entire episode ended - eventually a supervisor showed up and said precisely that "He has a right to remain silent. Just inspect his luggage and let him go."
- ciupicri 16y agoItem B would take a lot of time if it would be applied to all citizens like it was applied to him.