3 ms·
Proximate cause is irrelevant. This is a product liability issue because the product failed, which means strict liability applies.
by gamblor956 9y ago
Proximate cause is irrelevant. This is a product liability issue because the product failed, which means strict liability applies.
- fmihaila 9y ago> Proximate cause is irrelevant. This is a product liability issue because the product failed, which means strict liability applies. I am not a lawyer, but it is not clear to me just yet that the product failed. We don't know what the investigation will show.
- gamblor956 9y agoCar steered itself into a concrete wall. That is, by definition, failure. It doesn't matter whether it was properly following its coding to follow lane lines.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I am not a lawyer, but it is not clear to me just yet that the product failed. It's not clear to me whether it was a design defect or a manufacturing defect, but it's pretty clear that the lane keeping system drove the vehicle into a barrier which was not, in fact, located in a traffic lane, killing the occupant, which is pretty obviously a failure.
- fmihaila 9y ago> It's not clear to me whether it was a design defect or a manufacturing defect, but it's pretty clear that the lane keeping system drove the vehicle into a barrier which was not, in fact, located in a traffic lane, killing the occupant, which is pretty obviously a failure. Reflecting on your reply and gamblor956's post below, and after reviewing the published photos, I concede this looks like the most likely scenario, and if that is what actually occurred, it would unequivocally be a failure. (That said, there's still a chance, however small, that whatever seems obvious now ends up being invalidated by the investigation. I just don't like feeling certain about things like this, especially from a distance.)
- theclaw 9y agoFailed under what conditions, though? The manufacturer gets to specify the conditions under which they consider their product to be safe and suitable for a particular purpose. The car was not used under those conditions and the result was injury through misuse of the product. If my toaster causes me serious injury because I used it in the bath, that is my problem.
- gamblor956 9y agoProduct liability (in the US) attaches to the normal usage of a product, whether that is an intended usage of the product or not. A toaster is not normally used in the bath, so that does not create product liability issues. A car is normally used for driving...in fact, that's a car's primary use...so product liability would attach to its driving-related functional failure.
- taneq 9y agoTo be fair, a car isn't normally used for driving on the freeway without looking where you're going for 5+ seconds at a time.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The manufacturer gets to specify the conditions under which they consider their product to be safe and suitable for a particular purpose. No, they don't, otherwise they could disclaim everything.