4 ms·
I mean, Xen is literally descended from exokernels. The whole point of an exokernel is to securely multiplex hardware with as few abstractions as possible (whi
by monocasa 9y ago
I mean, Xen is literally descended from exokernels. The whole point of an exokernel is to securely multiplex hardware with as few abstractions as possible (which makes for a pretty sweet hypervisor it turns out). It's original paravirtualized MMU is straight out of XOK and AEGIS.
VMWare calls their system a microkernel (and so Wiki's rules therefore repeat that without other research), but the stack trace on the ESX wiki page pretty clearly shows a network card driver being called inside kernel context, so they have to be playing fast and loose with the term. From the outside it looks like earlier Vxworks; it's somehow a microkernel despite all of the code living in the same address space with no real permissions differences because it has multiple kernel threads and loadable modules. By that definition Linux is a microkernel too.
- naasking 9y ago> I mean, Xen is literally descended from exokernels. The whole point of an exokernel is to securely multiplex hardware with as few abstractions as possible Xen has far too much in-kernel code to be considered an exokernel. Linux on L4 had even less overhead than paravirtualized Xen. If exokernels truly efficiently multiplex the hardware in the most minimal manner possible, this wouldn't be possible. I can't comment on VMware beyond published documents since I'm not as familiar with it.
- monocasa 9y agoExokernels aren't necessarily ascetic like a microkernel. And Linux on which L4?
- ryao 9y agoVMWare ESXi relies on a guest to provide drivers. Seeing a network stack in kernel context makes sense given that the process handling the driver is a VM. The VM used to be Linux. I recall them being sued because someone thought that violated the GPL.
- monocasa 9y agoThey wrote a compatibility layer and run modified Linux drivers inside their hypervisor. That's separate from the Linux kernel that they use to boot and subsequently manage the hypervisor.