5 ms·
The rules for qualifying for a rental license are detailed, and pretty reasonable. They permit renting out a room, or your house if you live in it, but do not p
by vkou 9y ago
The rules for qualifying for a rental license are detailed, and pretty reasonable. They permit renting out a room, or your house if you live in it, but do not permit turning an apartment complex into an AirBnB hotel. In short, you can let on AirBnB, as long as you are not diminishing housing stock. [1]
It's not perfect, but it's pretty damn good.
[1] http://vancouver.ca/doing-business/short-term-rentals.aspx http://vancouver.ca/doing-business/short-term-rentals.aspx
> Short-term rentals are allowed when:
> It's your principal residence, in other words, where you live most of the year and the residential address you use for bills, identification, taxes, and insurance
> It's a legal dwelling unit (a home with an address that complies with all applicable regulations, including building code and fire safety)
> You have a short-term rental business licence
> If you're renting, your landlord allows you to sublet your home as a short-term rental
> If you're in a strata, your strata bylaws support short-term rentals in your building
- conanbatt 9y agoShort term rentals do not diminish housing stock, and help a city get more tourism which is by all means good for the whole. Its one more case of locals that vote vs non-locals that dont, even if they are way more numerous. If Vancouver finds itself short of houses by whatever measure, they have to look elsewhere.
- borne0 9y ago>>Short term rentals do not diminish housing stock If houses that would otherwise be rented or occupied are being used for short term rentals how can this be true?
- conanbatt 9y agoThe people that stay at short term rentals are also dwellers. They are taking up the time the longer term rentals aren't taking.
- borne0 9y agoWe disagree on the definition of dweller, cities require more than just vacation seekers to function. And the longer term renters aren't taking up those dwelling since it's more profitable for owners to rent out short term, but the reason that anyone wants to rent short term is because it's an interesting place to be, which it won't be if it's all people on vacation. I'll call this the Ibiza Quandary.
- conanbatt 9y agoIt's no quandary at all, the visitors and the landlords agree. Only a minority disagrees. If the rate of visitors reaches a rate where where the occupancy rate of airbnbs is makes them less interesting than long term units, congratulations, you have found market equilibrium.
- borne0 9y agoSo people who simply want to live in a city near to where they work and their children go to school have to be subject to market corrections where a single massively financed pseudo-hotel can massively distort a major cost of living assignment? Ridiculous. This is where common-sense regulation is needed.
- conanbatt 9y agoWhy do you call it distortion? Its the opposite: the distortion is having empty properties, hotel taxes and zoning. You make a weird argument: you mention the people that work in the city and want to live near it, and this argument has at least 2 flaws. The first one is that in a numbers game, the people that lose out on this exchange is a much smaller number than all the rest. That is, a small proportion of people see their conditions relatively worse because of how a third party does with their property. IF you put it up to a vote of all people involved, they would lose out big time. The second is that you dont take into consideration that airbnb has made it cheaper and easier to travel for people of that socio-economic status as well. Its not only hipsters and software engineers that user airbnb. You have to weigh in the benefit of the consumer.
- vkou 9y agoWhen I buy an apartment, and sublet it to a long-term tenant, one unit of housing exists. When I kick that long-term tenant out, and turn it into a AirBnB hotel, I just took one unit of housing from the market for locals, and added one unit of housing to the tourist market. > more tourism which is by all means good for the whole This is contentious. The city may be better off as a whole if it did not have 4,000 homeless people, many of whom were priced out of their apartments, due to tourism, foreign buyers, etc. To many people, more tourism brings little to no benefit, while a reduced housing stock brings much direct harm.
- conanbatt 9y ago> This is contentious. The city may be better off as a whole if it did not have 4,000 homeless people, many of whom were priced out of their apartments, due to tourism, foreign buyers, etc. Homeless people existed in SF long before Airbnb existed. > To many people, more tourism brings little to no benefit, while a reduced housing stock brings much direct harm. Yes, to long term renters. There is no doubt that long term renters would prefer no short term renters existed. They would also prefer for all units to be rent controlled, or that landlords and property owners gave their properties for free.