3 ms·
> CICO is a straightforward restatement of a law of thermodynamics The Second Law of Thermodynamics applies to closed systems only. Show me the ecosystem where
by WorldMaker 9y ago
> CICO is a straightforward restatement of a law of thermodynamics
The Second Law of Thermodynamics applies to closed systems only. Show me the ecosystem where food consumed and a human body is a perfectly closed system with no other inputs/outputs and I'll show you how that does not resemble the real world and you are making underlying assumptions you cannot prove.
- bitwize 9y agoIn a closed system, CI=CO=0, by definition, so I think you've got the wrong thermodynamic law.
- WorldMaker 9y agoApologies, I did mean the First Law, but the criticism still applies. The First Law of Thermodynamics also includes a closed system assumption.
- WorldMaker 9y agoUnless by "restatement of a Law of Thermodynamics" it is meant "restate of the Law of Conservation of Mass-Energy", at which point the criticism becomes that you now have a tougher isolated system assumption in the general case to prove. The real criticism, however is that you cannot just assume that CICO is a restatement of the Law of Conservation of Mass-Energy, because it relies on the spurious assumption that "nutritional calories" are sufficient approximations for the entirety of energy in the system. There's been a ton of work in chemistry and physics to untangle the mistakes of phlogiston theory, and caloric theory [1]. The SI unit of energy is now the Joule to absolutely distance from the problematic "calorie", and the confusion between what nutrition studies call a calorie and what Physics calls a calorie and what Joules are is an amazing mess. Nutrition "science" seems to me like the last bastion of some middle ground between phlogiston and caloric theory, and CICO the battle cry of its devout believers. [1] https://www.britannica.com/science/caloric-theory https://www.britannica.com/science/caloric-theory