5 ms·
"There is no cure for apathy. If they don’t want to work they won’t. They’ll blame whatever they can regardless of format." That's a little harsh, and also doe
by pmoriarty 9y ago
"There is no cure for apathy. If they don’t want to work they won’t. They’ll blame whatever they can regardless of format."
That's a little harsh, and also doesn't even acknowledge that the teacher has any responsibility to engage their students and spark their interest in the subject.
Students might not do their homework and engage with the subject for all sorts of reasons apart from apathy. They might have depression, be too stressed out, or have a host of other emotional problems that affect their performance and engagement. They might have taken on too large of a course load, or might not be getting enough sleep because of work they're doing outside of school or be preoccupied in taking care of their family. In some schools, the students' own safety, or that of their family, might be their overwhelming preoccupation.
When I was young, I had a lot of trouble motivating myself in subjects I didn't find interesting, but excelled in those I did. You could call the cause of my performance in the former subjects "apathy", but the teacher also has a role to play here, and need not be just a helpless bystander.
On occasion I was lucky enough to have talented teachers who were able to interest me in subjects that I found completely uninteresting before I took their class. But way too often I had teachers who would read straight out of the textbook during class, who you could tell really did not enjoy teaching, or who just weren't particularly good at it.
In those cases, the students have to rely on whatever interest they have in the subject to keep them going. If they don't have that interest, then they have to find motivation some other way. This can be difficult for kids who are still maturing and finding their way in the world.
My own performance at university improved tremendously when I went back after working for many years, and I was able to harness a tremendous motivation that I just didn't have when I was younger. I was also able to eliminate distractions, focus completely on performing well at school, and over the years had finally learned how to learn (a skill usually not taught at school). As a result I greatly outperformed virtually all the rest of my much younger classmates.
Finding a sense of direction, becoming effectively self-motivating, seeing academic performance as more important than partying or other outside interests, knowing how to learn, understanding how tough it is as an adult in the "real world" and what a difference having skills and knowledge could make, having a genuine interest in the subject matter, valuing knowledge and learning for their own sake, and many other things that could help students perform academically are things that schools could help students with, but unfortunately usually they don't.
- sykh 9y agoThe statements you quoted are about apathetic students. Do you have a cure for apathy in learning? I don't. Teachers come in a variety of talents and have a variety of teaching styles. One thing that colleges do poorly is align a student's learning style with a teacher's teaching style. Is a teacher supposed to be a great motivator? I don't know. I do know that I'm not particularly good in the inspiration department. I'm enthusiastic. I think I'm good at explaining stuff. Students might not do their homework and engage with the subject for all sorts of reasons apart from apathy. They might have depression, be too stressed out, or have a host of other emotional problems that affect their performance and engagement. They might have taken on too large of a course load, or might not be getting enough sleep because of work they're doing outside of school or be preoccupied in taking care of their family. I was attempting to only reference apathetic students. They are a subset of the students who don't do the work required of them. What you write is certainly true; particularly at community colleges. However, as I tell my students, for each person it requires x amount of hours (x varies from person to person) to master the material. If you don't have the time, inclination, ability, or are otherwise incapable of devoting x hours to the learning the subject then you won't learn it. Nothing will change this. If a student can't devote 5 hours a week to a 5 credit course in homework then they likely won't do well. The reason for their inability is somewhat irrelevant in the sense that one needs to put in the effort. If you can't you won't learn the material. Nothing I do can change this fact. What I can do is to try to make x as small as possible for each person. I try.
- Bjartr 9y agoIf you had a class on only apathetic students, would you put minimal effort into teaching any of them? Or would you distribute the effort you normally reserve for non-apathetic students?
- sykh 9y agoIt's an interesting hypothetical. Here's how I run the course. I have lectures for each topic (the lectures I've created). Accompanying the lectures are problem sets along with solutions. Students are expected to watch the lecture and attempted some of the problems before coming to class. In class I pass out a problem set. Usually 30 to 40 problems. At the beginning of the semester I have around 35 students in the class. When I pass out the problem set I go around helping students with the problems. They typically get into groups of 3 or 4. Since I have a lot of students I can't waste my time on someone who didn't bother to even watch the lecture. It's not fair to those who did watch the lecture and need help. I've never encountered a situation in which no one watched the lecture. I don't know what my response would be if that happened.