2 ms·
Question: When I was an undergrad, almost all the science and engineering courses involved lectures (to convey information), recitations (to review with a TA),
by Jtsummers 9y ago
Question: When I was an undergrad, almost all the science and engineering courses involved lectures (to convey information), recitations (to review with a TA), and usually a lab (sometimes the same as recitations, to practice material).
Every time I see people saying lectures are outdated, I cannot think of an actual STEM course where I was just lectured to outside of one Calculus course (for whatever reason we didn't have recitations for that one, and the professor was the sort to write and erase at the same time).
Is the problem with courses that are too dependent on lectures (as the predominant or majority time of faculty/student interaction) or is it actually that lectures are ineffective?
Even my later CS and math courses that were too small to have a TA had very interactive "lectures" even if we didn't code or do exercises during them (very Q&A oriented). Perhaps this is also a difference between different schools and the faculty at them?
EDIT: Reading more of the comments here I'm realizing that I only had a couple classes that were "traditional" lecture-oriented courses with the instructor speaking at us for the hour. The vast majority weren't and I think that's part of my confusion with the anti-lecture movement that's happening. I consider a lecture to be a dialog (because that's most of what I experienced) and not a monologue. I would agree that monologue lectures are boring and dreadful if that's the majority of what you encounter in a class or school. Now I'm wondering what schools did that. I went to several universities (spanning the gamut from lower tier-2 to top of the country) and only at the top school (GA Tech) did I experience a traditional lecture, and only for a couple courses.