4 ms·
What really needs to happen is GDPR here in the US. To force the Facebooks and Googles of the world to pay for the data breach liabilities (perhaps insurance c
by r00fus 9y ago
What really needs to happen is GDPR here in the US. To force the Facebooks and Googles of the world to pay for the data breach liabilities (perhaps insurance could cover a breach - it would at least force them to price it).
You want to profit off my data (esp. through shadow profiles)? I should have a right as to whether you should and how.
This would inherently limit the utility of such breaches like CA and whatever might happen with your Google data.
- jimmaswell 9y agoWhy should you "own" data that happens to be about you? If someone writes on a piece of paper that they saw you on a street at some time, should the paper now be your property? Going further, if we had the technology to selectively erase memories, do you think someone should have the right to have other people's memories erased pertaining to them? I just can't get behind this premise at all. Nothing is being taken from you when Facebook makes a shadow profile and you don't have any copyright or other intellectual property rights over your name, the fact that you went to x high school, the fact that you lived in town y, etc.
- sametmax 9y agoSo you are ok with me having a picture of your children naked on my CDN ? Or you having sex with your wife ? I shadowed it by using the camera on your phone, you gave permissions without reading.
- rrrazdan 9y agoAppeal to Extremes? In a society where we interact with other people we are okay with some information about us being 'out there'. I am okay with you knowing my school, but not that I am uncircumcised. Edit: Not that I am with OP on shadow profiles or what Facebook is doing. I think it is okay to use people's data for advertisements and other monetary benefit but you should tell that clearly to people and it should be a big opt-in decision point with lots of information provided. I just wanted to point out that your argument is a fallacious argument.
- sametmax 9y agoYes but where do you draw the line ? Fb would cross mine, and it's why i never had an account.
- r00fus 9y ago> Nothing is being taken from you when Facebook makes a shadow profile Something is clearly being taken. The fact that it's being assembled without my consent is disturbing, the fact that FB has repeatedly been reckless with securing that data is even more worrisome. Your privacy (and possibly safety) is being taken. If a burglar can use exfiltrated FB data to know when I'm vacationing, it's information that makes me less secure. If insurance companies think I'm at a higher risk for expensive treatments, I may be denied or forced to pay a higher premium (perhaps without knowing why).
- rhizome 9y agoLet's try a different tack than ownership: it can be seen as stalking.
- mistermann 9y ago> Why should you "own" data that happens to be about you? We are on a rock hurling through space at millions(?) of miles per hour, depending on your frame of reference. We literally write our own laws, in order to shape our destiny as we see fit. Or, we used to anyways. An entity like Facebook having so much data on such a large portion of the population (not just US citizens, but citizens of the entire planet) merged with the increasing power of big data algorithms and understanding of human psychology is a very dangerous tool of persuasion. Personally, I happen to believe that the reason this risk is suddenly getting so much "public support" is because politicians have come to a bi-partisan realization that having an independent entity with this much propaganda power is dangerous - the bi-partisan aspect is interesting as I think it's fair to say silicon valley "leans left" and would tend to be more favorable to democrats, but the last election demonstrated the risk inherent in that stance. Hence, a "spontaneous" flood of newspaper and TV articles with the subsequent (in my opinion, would be interested to hear disagreements on the chicken and egg aspect of it) awakening of "public outrage".
- Pigo 9y agoI like hearing actual proposals for how to "do something about Facebook" as opposed to all this hand-wringing. I guess I'm just expecting everyone to get upset and then go back to business as usual.
- throw2016 9y agoIf you want to solve the problem its relatively easy. Follow the money. Ban micro targeting by advertisers, with only textual context and location allowed. Ban platforms like Google and Facebook from offering micro targeting. Marketing managers and their agencies will be held accountable. This should be easy to enforce and will stop the creepy stalking and data hoovering at source as there is no incentive. But no one wants to solve the problem, only go through the motions of solving it. These capabilities are too valuable for government and propaganda.
- hbosch 9y agoThere was a statement by Senator Sullivan that I found revelatory, if not surprising; he talked about how almost every single lobbyist in D.C. is involved in the Facebook scandal in one way or another. I had never really considered the fact that virtually zero special interest groups can possibly be neutral here... tobacco, firearms, alcohol, religious groups, food and agriculture, entertainment, finance, the government itself as well as quasi-government orgs (DNC, RNC, PACs) — every single one of these has grown to rely heavily on micro-targeted advertising in modern times. Stripping FB of the means to micro-target doesn't just affect FB's bottom line, it potentially affects every industry in the country, perhaps even the entire first world. Do you think any Congressperson will sever a lucrative outreach opportunities for these groups, who are also their largest donors?
- odammit 9y agoMZ was getting grilled this AM about if FB would implement those GDPR features to protect US citizens and MZ said it would be available to all users. Which is funny to me that a congressman (it was a man, I didn’t catch his name) would push for that since they obviously aren’t interested in protecting citizens data with laws or regulations.
- r00fus 9y agoThere is a substantive difference between "FB will support GDPR compliance features in US" vs. "USG has implemented GDPR and plans to enforce it". In the latter case, FB doesn't have any requirement to actually not monetize non-EU folks.
- oflannabhra 9y agoAs the article mentions, this would possibly cement Facebook's position in the market, as they have the resources to comply, whereas "the next Facebook" might not. This is one possible explanation as to why Zuckerberg is conciliatory to any call from congressmen for regulation.
- dave5104 9y agoIf "the next Facebook" is also going to mishandle my user data because they can't possibly comply with privacy regulations, then quite frankly I don't care if they can't make it.
- oflannabhra 9y agoI don't think the article is arguing against regulation--it is arguing for competition. Thompson's point is that the real issue is not privacy, but that Facebook is incentivized to disregard privacy because that have zero competition. That is, they have the luxury of disregarding user privacy because they have a monopoly on the social network (and have been allowed to strengthen it through acquisitions). I'd argue that both regulation and competition are necessary. Regulation to make data protected and portable, while punishing breach of data, and competition to allow the market to create alternatives. Right now people don't leave Facebook because there is nowhere else to go, and no way to take their graph with them.