6 ms·
Based on his testimony today, Mark Zuckerberg puts users last during a crisis
- StavrosK 9y agoWho are these people who, before today, thought that Zuckerberg actually did care about users? Didn't they know about the "dumb fucks" thing?
- vasilakisfil 9y agoSays an author on a site full of ads that even bypass my adblock.
- osrec 9y agoThe mobile experience wasn't actually all that bad...
- yoz-y 9y agoI dunno the ads do not seem out of place and even without an adblocker there are only a few of them. Ghostery did catch some trackers though, including Facebook's.
- elorant 9y agoSure, but their ads aren't tailor made to each user. We all see the same ones, one about Mailchimp and another for a vodka. Which means no profiling so there's no violation of users' privacy.
- closed 9y agoI don't know if seeing untargeted ads necessarily means a site is not profiling you.
- icebraining 9y agoIt doesn't; they're using Google Analytics, plus loading some crap from Facebook itself.
- wired_devil 9y agoThese ads are not intrusive. You can read the article perfectly. They are not obstructing your experience. You, however, is consuming their content and blocking their advertisers...
- CiPHPerCoder 9y agoAdblocking is the first line of defense against malware and invasive online tracking. (By adblocking I don't mean like AdBlock Plus I mean more like uBlock Origin.)
- blocked_again 9y agoThey have bills to pay and ads are probably their only source of income.
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoI think the one phrase we all need to learn these days is "Problems with your business model is not society's problem"
- Fifer82 9y agoTotally agree, I guess the apologists have business model problems.
- Blaiz0r 9y agoThen they should look for gainful employment in a stable industry that pays them consistently for their work.
- raechu 9y agoNews media is still the primary way of keeping the populace informed. The populace being informed is essential to them making good decisions when voting, without it democracy becomes a sham. This means that if being a journalist in news media is not "gainful employment in a stable industry that pays them consistently for their work" then we are going to have some serious problems as a society.
- CiPHPerCoder 9y agoHere's the kicker: We already have some serious problems as a society. They're just too nuanced and technical for most humans to care.
- sodafountan 9y agoHuh, it's almost like we need ads in order to have free content
- lancebeet 9y agoSomething very strange is going on with the scrolling on that website.
- rdiddly 9y agoAgreed - it actually crashes my browser!
- crystaln 9y agoThere are so many companies that collect and sell data on Americans that I don't understand why our Congress is grandstanding on Facebook. Hello credit card companies? These hearings seem more political based on Facebooks percieved biases than focused on protecting consumers.
- jhanschoo 9y agoBecause FB is the most visible example of it. c.f. fraud and embezzlement enforcement. Regardless, whatever comes out of the case w.r.t. FB will determine policy for the other personal-data companies.
- msravi 9y agoNo. Because FB data was used by Trump to win. FB was very visible earlier too, and the influence it weilded was well known. It was just extremely upsetting that the other side used it this time, and won. Political narratives world over, have always been monopolized by the left, via institutional control. When narratives are democratized, they invariably move to the right. Social media has democratized setting of the narrative, and that is the reason that we are seeing a wave of right wing populism across the world, from India to UK to the US. The clampdown on Facebook is an attempt to regain institutional control of the current most valuable means of setting political narrative.
- KozmoNau7 9y ago>"Political narratives world over, have always been monopolized by the left, via institutional control. When narratives are democratized, they invariably move to the right." Haha what? Nevermind the nonsense of dividing the world into "left" and "right", you are also absolutely wrong. Please back up your claims, because I see a hell of a lot of conservative media coverage control, all over the world.
- scardine 9y agoOk, credit card knows what you buy but not the last time you talked to your friends and what you said to them.
- vergessenmir 9y agoAs much as I loathe too I have to defend Facebook. Not to say the data collection practices are not egregious ,let's not forget that these are industry-wide practices and that the hearings have less to do with protecting users than it is political grand standing. Experian, anyone? It's almost as if we've collectively forgotten the data breaches of the last 12 months and how exposed American and EU citizens are now to fraud because of lax security practices by credit scoring companies. I guess the difference is that Facebook is actively sharing this data and Experian was hacked, because their breach was the action of an external agent, they are less culpable. From the UK it looks like this. Trump used data, Facebook helped, politicians are upset that Trump was helped by the Facebook platform (conveniently forgetting that every campaign before that has used large amounts of Facebook user data), let's punish Facebook. Facebook doesn't care about users, but politicians who have the power to change this care even less.
- itronitron 9y agoMost politicians care more about people than Facebook does, if for no other reason that they need to be reelected.
- agumonkey 9y agosomething about society too, how much users really care ? people may complain, rant, scream, walk, strike .. but do they really want privacy ? and do they know how to define it ? at what cost (going off facebook/web ? paying for guarantees?, doing paper work to ensure political class write these down as laws ?)
- briandear 9y agoI would say “curating” of political ideas is a big issue. See Ted Cruz’s questioning of Zuckerberg as an example. It’s not just data but how Facebook has such a dominant role in steering political discourse. There are more issues at play than simple data hygiene.
- tabeth 9y agoWhat I'm really curious about is the psychology of people that makes them engage in this whataboutism that's present in almost every post about Facebook and this data issue. By the way, both Equifax (American based) and Experian (Irish) are subject to way more regulation than Facebook, which is currently none AFAIK. P.S. Though Experian had a minor data breach in 2015 you're most likely referring to the far larger (order magnitude higher) Equifax breach.
- booleandilemma 9y agoAnd the market made it clear it still values FB.
- justherefortart 9y agoIsn't it #2 (no pun intended) behind Google as an advertisement platform? Look how much people spend on a SuperBowl commercial, it's clear Facebook still has a massive audience and that's the value.
- perlpimp 9y agoTed Cruz also did use Cambridge Analytica.
- abcdcba 9y agoNo way! I guess that makes it okay.
- briandear 9y agoAnd Obama’s and Hillary used Facebook directly with the cooperation of Facebook. Cambridge was just a proxy for what Democrat candidates were getting for free. It doesn’t make it right but it’s a false equivalence to condemn Cruz for Cambridge without condemning Facebook itself for the other candidates.
- cdubzzz 9y agoI am more than happy to condemn them all, but do you have sources on the types and manner of data used by the various campaigns via CA vs FB direct?
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoEquating what Obama/Clinton did with what Cambridge Analytica did is a false equivalence. The data Obama/Clinton collected was given voluntarily with users understanding more or less what it was going to be used for through apps that were overtly connected to their campaigns. The data Cambridge Analytica collected was collected by tricking users into giving it to them with fake quizzes with users having no idea what the data was going to be used for.
- michaelhoffman 9y agoToday?
- victorbojica 9y agoDon't want to take Zuck's side, but reaching such conclusion from only two or three sentences seems a bit unfair and misleading. The title sounds great though...
- cdubzzz 9y agoDitto this. The article doesn’t say much of anything at all and makes giant jumps in logic based on a few quotes without full context. Honestly I have been somewhat impressed with Zuckerberg’s handling of this situation, at least in comparison to public statements from other companies when it comes to issues about users and data privacy. However I am still pessimistic about the potential for any useful action after all of this kerfuffle around FB and CA.
- itronitron 9y agoI highly recommend listening to Sheryl Sandberg's interview with NPR from last week. It is a great example of the manner in which people behave in order to successfully stay out of jail.
- justherefortart 9y agoWhat did they do that was illegal? Maybe it's unethical, but is it? When people signed up, wtf did they think was going to happen to their data?
- itronitron 9y agoI don't know whether or how it is illegal, but the way she talks is a great example of how everyone should interact with law enforcement... acknowledge and agree with the concern but do not answer any questions or provide any information.