3 ms·
Client certs have a problem Web Authn doesn't have which is they enable tracking, very trivially. With client certs, I sign into Facebook, Hacker News, LWN, an
by tialaramex 9y ago
Client certs have a problem Web Authn doesn't have which is they enable tracking, very trivially.
With client certs, I sign into Facebook, Hacker News, LWN, and all three of them get told "This is tialaramex, serial number 183749265". So does LegitAds, and XHamster, and Penny Arcade. Which is great for advertisers, but probably not what most users want.
With this technology, each site gets a consistent but site-specific identity. So they know it's still "me", but they have to collaborate out of band to discern that all these people are the same person, as they would without any authentication framework.
The requirement for user action to authenticate has a benefit here too - advertisers even if they have Facebook's permission to check which Facebook user I am, daren't risk saying "Er, hi, can you just sign into Facebook for us?" because it's obvious what's going on. Only the places which already explicitly need authentication will ask.