3 ms·
The second comment seems pretty reasonable: Set your phone as a wifi hotspot for the car to use. I don't think it's unreasonable for them to balk at spending $
by taneq 9y ago
The second comment seems pretty reasonable: Set your phone as a wifi hotspot for the car to use.
I don't think it's unreasonable for them to balk at spending $2mil to push a huge data blob out over a free connection that was probably originally scoped purely for small (<100mb) firmware updates.
- arthurcolle 9y agocouldnt they set up their own cdn or is redistribution of google maps cache files disallowed as a result of the existing Terms of Service?
- voltagex_ 9y agoEven at the corporate tier there's a whole lot of restrictions on caching Google Maps. I suspect someone at Tesla could make a call and get that sorted out, though.
- Reason077 9y agoTesla's new navigation system no longer uses Google Maps. It's now a vector based system using Mapbox data and Valhalla routing. Hence the large size of this update: the entire base map is now stored in the car rather than downloading local tiles as needed.
- voltagex_ 9y agoThat's a big win for Mapbox - good on them.
- kelnage 9y agoObviously they wouldn’t have to spend that much. Right now the majority of their customers get these updates via WiFi - so it would just be a matter of finding out which vehicles were sufficiently out of date and only sending them the data.
- taneq 9y agoFair point, either it's affecting a lot of people or it's not going to cost much to push over LTE for the few remaining ones, they need to pick one. It sounds like the other half of the issue is that there's no way to force the car to check for updates. That should be quick to add... in the next update (heh). Edit: The original poster on the Tesla forum did say they usually got their updates a couple of weeks after they were released. Maybe, to get around this very problem, the car waits for a while in hope of a friendly WiFi connection before resorting to LTE?
- usrusr 9y agoOnce it works without Wi-Fi, few people will bother too set it up. There are obvious solutions to WiFi-less home parking for a company with their very own charger network, but they take initiative, commitment and acknowledging the problem. I'm pretty sure that pointing out all the ways of how a given happy path solution won't work for everybody is not how you make a career at a company like Tesla.
- brandon272 9y agoThe Tesla employee ought to have suggested the WiFi hotspot idea. Telling the guy to leech off a Starbucks connection is just weird. And the explanation about "imagining" how much an LTE update costs Tesla is also weird. Why not offer optional LTE map updates for an additional fee? I guess I hadn't thought much about how Tesla pushes software and map updates. WiFi makes sense but I would assume it doesn't work well for some people. I know my WiFi signal in my garage and driveway is quite poor due to the architecture of my house and I assume the large number of WiFi networks in my neighbourhood. And as far as the reasoning for why they can't offer it at their service centre -- seems like an issue easily solved by a QoS feature on a router.
- FireBeyond 9y agoHere's another thought - if you think Tesla is paying retail data rates for 200,000 LTE connections, you're likely mistaken.
- joecool1029 9y ago>Here's another thought - if you think Tesla is paying retail data rates for 200,000 LTE connections, you're likely mistaken. I wouldn't be so sure of that. Operators can and do gouge for data when they know they can get away with it, including rates over what retail would typically be.[1][2] These are large file downloads and you can best believe operators are not going to give 'bulk discount rates' just to have their network slowed down every time Tesla pushes an update. [1] https://ecfsapi.fcc.gov/file/60000987609.pdf https://ecfsapi.fcc.gov/file/60000987609.pdf [2] https://ecfsapi.fcc.gov/file/7521151798.pdf https://ecfsapi.fcc.gov/file/7521151798.pdf
- improbable22 9y agoSurely Tesla could get great price for bandwidth at 3am.
- babaganoosh89 9y agoFrom the comments in the link, it seems like map downloads are triggered randomly. Someone left their phone in their car for 5 days but it didn’t sync.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The second comment seems pretty reasonable: Set your phone as a wifi hotspot for the car to use. You can't trigger the update, so you have to leave your phone with the car (remember that the whole problem here is that parking is too remote from living space to share wifi) for an extended period of time and hope for the update to trigger. And, from the comment on the article page by the author, they've tried that: I have put my phone in hotspot mode for literally 5 days, left it in one car, and connected both cars (at home, just one car at work because my wife works somewhere else) to my iPhone hotspot, leaving me completely phone-less except for once-a-day charging sessions at home. Despite this, because there is NO way to trigger a “guaranteed” maps/nav update (sounds like Elon will only allow triggering firmware updates), I might need to be without my phone for weeks on end.