5 ms·
Broken up into what exactly? If you don't like Facebook don't use it. How about the Senate and the internet outrage machine spend time on companies like Equifax
by paxys 9y ago
Broken up into what exactly? If you don't like Facebook don't use it. How about the Senate and the internet outrage machine spend time on companies like Equifax instead, who (1) we literally cannot opt out of, (2) have private data that we didn't choose to share with them, and (3) have broken actual laws but haven't received as much as a slap on the wrist for it.
- peteretep 9y ago> If you don't like Facebook don't use it Fine, I won't. That won't stop society in general being surveilled though, and all the attendant ills of that that the article suggests. Further: more and more apps require me to use Facebook to sign in.
- colinjoy 9y agoWhy do you suggest one can “opt out” of facebook? They profile non-members and encourage users to disclose personal data of non-members by installing apps or helping them to “find my friends” based on sharing such data (e.g. address books). #1 and #2 apply to facebook as well. We might find out about #3.
- hailk 9y agoHow do they profile non-members or even people who've either deactivated their accounts or aren't using them? If I don't log in how does invites affect me? All they could possibly have is my phone number and email. Which aren't exactly private information anyway.
- colinjoy 9y agohttps://www.zdnet.com/article/firm-facebooks-shadow-profiles-are-frightening-dossiers-on-everyone/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/firm-facebooks-shadow-profiles... Note they‘ve been doing this for a long time (the article is from 2013).
- hailk 9y agoAs I mentioned, i don't think we can consider phone number and email address as private data. Everything we use, track those. It also mentions that it was a bug and not intentional. Iphone has leaked far worse things. People seem unfazed when a newer model comes out.
- doomlaser 9y agoZuckerberg's talking point from his AP photographed note sheet (https://i.imgur.com/3UP1b4X.jpg https://i.imgur.com/3UP1b4X.jpg) is a good one. If you break up the major US tech platforms, it cedes leadership of those sectors to Chinese competitors. Something to think about in discussions about breaking up Facebook, Amazon, and Google.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoSo they're "too big to fail"? If you break of the platforms into smaller separate companies, why would that cede leadership to Chinese companies?
- doomlaser 9y agoUsing the legislative branch to break apart a competitive business into smaller disconnected pieces isn't a failure from internal crisis / overleverage. > why would that cede leadership to Chinese companies? It cedes leadership because the Chinese companies, modeled after the un-splintered US platforms, have more resources, capability to undertake coordinated action, and can take advantage of greater network effects.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoThere would be consequences, but I doubt they would be that major. Facebook hasn't really contributed anything of value, other than a platform for people to get tracked mercilessly. FB's business model is based on advertising, and advertising is poison to the mind. But I do think the best solution is very strict privacy regulation, similar to GDPR. The so-called free market has failed to manifest a good solution to privacy issues, mostly because the harm done isn't directly visible and hard to contextualize for most people. But it is very real, and can have massive consequences.
- Moru 9y agoI think the modern society has forgotten how it is to not have facebook so if that would be forcefully taken away at this point, there would be a lot of angry people not knowing what to do any more.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoYou also cannot opt out of Facebook, they keep shadow profiles on basically everyone.
- a1a 9y agoFirstly, it is not possible to opt out of facebook. [1] And they do indeed collect private data that we didn't choose to share (shadow accounts, third party website trackers, etc). Facebook have broken "actual laws". There are so many cases were facebook have broken the law. [2] [3] Also, please read up on Fallacy of relative privation ("not as bad as"). [1] https://boingboing.net/2017/11/08/involuntary-profiling.html https://boingboing.net/2017/11/08/involuntary-profiling.html [2] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/feb/12/facebook-personal-data-privacy-settings-ruled-illegal-german-court https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/feb/12/facebook-... [3] https://techcrunch.com/2018/02/19/facebooks-tracking-of-non-users-ruled-illegal-again/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/02/19/facebooks-tracking-of-non-...
- thejerz 9y agoRegarding [1], it is possible to opt out of facebook: don't visit websites with Facebook like/share buttons. (This website, for example). When you access a website with facebook tracking installed, you are consenting to being tracked.
- paxys 9y agoOr just install any of the hundred ad and tracking blockers out there.
- zaarn 9y agoI did not consent to being tracked by facebook. Yet websites try again and again to load the facebook like button. As per GDPR, which is in effect but not enforced until May, tracking me without explicitly and clearly asking me if that is okay is not allowed and anything else, like withdrawing service until I agree to be tracked, does not construct consent. When I visit a new website I do not know if they have facebook like buttons. I have to load the page to check that and without a script or ad blocker I will also load the like button and facebook will track that. At which point in that process did I consent to any and all scripts on that webpage leeching of my personal data?
- 9y ago
- ILikeConemowk 9y ago>How about the Senate and the internet outrage machine spend time on companies like Equifax instead You have not understood what this outrage is about. Trump's campaign didn't use data from the Equifax breach to win the election, so it doesn't matter. No, it also doesn't matter that Obama did the same and boasted about it. He is a visionary, Trump is a baddie. Do you get it? Trump baddie, all other politicians, unless Republicans, goodies. If I had known that Trump winning would be enough to get some of my friends off Facebook, I would have urged all my American friends to vote for him! Oh, well.
- exergy 9y agoPathetic argument. How about you go back and look at the Equifax breach threads on HN. There was just as much (and ultimately, just as impotent) outrage there. How about you realize that people can be intelligent enough to get worked up about both incidents? Also, your second to last sentence is the type of glib, dimwitted and edgelord-y kind of nonchalance that reduces all internet conversation threads to "snarkiest cynic wins". Try harder.
- ILikeConemowk 9y ago> Try harder. I don't really think I have to. You are already trying hard enough to elicit an emotional reaction on my part. FYI: mine wasn't an argument, it is a sarcastic statement meant to explain why, to some extent, very few people seemed to care about the Equifax debacle and we didn't see this level of outrage. My point still stands.