3 ms·
It's also not clear to me what distinguishes this from the book EULAs that were held unenforceable in the original 1908 case. Publishers there printed purported
by _delirium 16y ago
It's also not clear to me what distinguishes this from the book EULAs that were held unenforceable in the original 1908 case. Publishers there printed purported "licenses" on the copyright page of their books, including terms like "you may not resell this book for less than $1.00". But those were held not to be enforceable, because it was held that the contractual relationship between publisher and bookbuyer is terminated when the sale is completed, at least in the normal case of books sold at retail (books provided under privately negotiated contracts, like documentation provided under an NDA, can still be enforced).
Could something like that be upheld today if the publisher were a bit more careful with its legal fictions? Perhaps something like: You are granted a single, non-transferable, non-exclusive license to read this book. For your convenience, a hardcopy, which remains the sole property of Publishing Co., has been provided for your use. You may retain this copy so long as you remain in compliance with this license, but may not transfer it to any other party.
- jhghjnmmn 16y agoThe difference is that book publishers don't make huge political donations
- Natsu 16y agoThis sort of nonsense got me to look up free software CAD programs. Sadly, the big one is BRL-CAD and the documentation for it is downright depressing. Their FAQ ( http://brlcad.org/wiki/FAQ http://brlcad.org/wiki/FAQ ) tells me that the silly thing can't even print out a drawing normally! Essentially, you render your current view to a BLR-CAD format, use a command line tool to turn that into a PNG, then print that via some other program, not supplied. Does nobody using it print enough things to want a normal print dialog? If anyone wants to see what I mean, look for the question "How do I get a hard copy of what I'm looking at in MGED?" (MGED is the geometry editor for BRL-CAD.) To be fair, their list of priorities DOES list UI improvement. I'll have to see if I can find some ways to help... assuming I figure out how to use this thing.
- _delirium 16y agoYeah, it's an unfortunate niche. I think it's the sort of thing where there are companies that would be happy to contribute back code, but only if a CAD program were already at 80% of their needs. But without commercial support, the hobbyist-CAD community is way too small to get a system to that 80% to begin with. Lots of industry doesn't really enjoy paying large per-seat license fees for the dominant CAD systems, so I think they'd be willing to work on an open-source one and contribute back, the way embedded-systems companies do with Linux, but they aren't willing to take a leap onto something that isn't there yet BRL-CAD's particular problems are because it's sort of a time-capsule project, I think. It's an Army project from the 1980s that was open-sourced in 2004, but is still very "1980s Unix workstation" in a lot of ways, and the ratio of interested developers to giant crufty codebase has meant that modernizing it is slow.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Natsu 16y agoI just started playing with BRL-CAD last night. If any of its developers are reading this, I have a number of ideas for things that can be improved significantly... A) Don't make me create a database when I fire up MGED. Start me out with an empty one and don't worry about it until I try to quit (when you can prompt me to save it). If I open my own database and the automatically created one is still empty, you just discard it. B) Let us print without having to go through three different programs. C) Autoformat the size of your prompts so that you do NOT have to resize them to read the prompt. I'm sure I can find more later, but this is what bothered me in the first few minutes. I'll have to read a lot more documentation, it seems, before I can get much further in actually using this thing... It's hard for me to accept that a tool that's been used for 30 years still has so many rough edges.