8 ms·
In the 1950s, a California teacher's annual mortgage payments were 14% of salary
- IronWolve 9y agoAnd what percentage is it for a single google/apple/facebook employee? If they make 250k a year, and the mortgage is 10k a month, thats almost 50% of net. Sounds like its extremely bad for everyone.
- ericmcer 9y agoIt's pretty awesome for property owners.
- et-al 9y agoIf their view their house as an investment. There's a good amount of people who are in the Bay Area simply because they like the weather, outdoors, and have family here. They didn't buy a house because they knew prices would go up. They bought because they wanted to settle down here.
- tapatio 9y agoWhat? The weather in the bay area sucks.
- davidw 9y agoThe statistic I saw today is that the average house in San Francisco is making $60 an hour in equity gains. That's 4 times the minimum wage.
- aetherson 9y agoIt's super not. Look, if you got a starter house let's say 5 years ago for let's say $800k, and now that house is worth $1.1M, but what you want to do is move into a 3/2 or something that used to cost $1.1M, that same better house now costs $1.5. Instead of having to add $300k equity, you have to add $400k. But actually, what's happened is that houses in like the 6th to 8th decile have appreciated more than houses in the 1st to 4th decile, so you probably have to add $500k. The only people this is good for are people who own a separate property purely as an investment, and people who are moving out of the area or downsizing their houses.
- Spooky23 9y agoSure it is. You leave. A guy I grew up with did this in Queens. He bought a house in the old neighborhood for $200k in the 90s, sold it for nearly $2M, bought an estate upstate for around $500k. His drive to Manhattan is about the same as the shitty bus/subway odyessy without the bullshit. If the weather is awful, he gets a hotel in the city. HN is weird about this. If we had a king that ended zoning, everyone would be displaced anyway. When your block was ruined by apartment towers and street retail. That’s what happened to my friends former neighbors when his former 50x100 lot was turned into 18 condo units.
- thedirt0115 9y agoHow is that bad for the single Google et al. employee? That still leaves 10k+ a month for everything not housing-related, which is plenty. Outside of housing, SF isn't that expensive (groceries, for example, aren't ~7 times more expensive than the national median like houses are). I have a friend living in SF, making about that amount of money, with a stay-at-home wife and a kid, and they're quite comfortable despite a 7k+ monthly mortgage. This is bad for people who make <100k a year who may never be able to afford a home in San Francisco, especially as the prices keep rising.
- lorenzq 9y agoBecause a house is a 15 or 30 year loan. Their job market or high pay may not extend that long
- wetpaws 9y agoIn Bay Area 250K will get you around 155K post-tax. It means you would have about 2K/month after morgage which is insane.
- pxeboot 9y agoInsane, yes, but 2k/month is still a lot more then most American families live on after paying their rent/mortgage.
- lorenzq 9y agoLets not forget property taxes, which would wipe out again half of that if not almost all of that.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoI mean if we handwave away the mortgage. A 10k/month mortgage is a $1.4 million dollar house on only a 15 year mortgage. Push to the 30 year and you're at like $2.2 mil. Besides 2k/month after mortgage isn't so bad, I wish I knew what the median after taxes and rent/mortgage income is but I guarantee it's nowhere near that high and it comes with nowhere near as nice of a house.
- Eugr 9y agoThat's almost 50% of gross. And depending on their tax situation it could be almost 100% of net...
- aetherson 9y agoIf you have a 10k/month mortgage, it's because your mortgage is for $2M. Housing prices around here are high, but they aren't that high for perfectly reasonable houses. If you house costs $2.4M (ie, you paid 20% down and got a $2M mortgage), then you paid a lot more than you had to for a house.
- axoltl 9y agoThe 10k a month figure is fairly unreasonable. For a two bedroom, that figure will be closer to 5k a month.
- asdsa5325 9y agoThis says more about California's very high cost of living than teacher's salaries.
- avs733 9y agoGiven that teaching, almost by rule, occurs locally this says something about the relationship between those two things.
- randyrand 9y agoDespite this, the student to teacher ratio in the bay area is still 19:1 - 23:1. Hardly a change. So clearly teacher pay is not a big issue.
- germinalphrase 9y agoHow does student:teacher ratio impact whether or not a teacher can afford to live in/near a community - which, presumably, they need to do to teach there?
- randyrand 9y ago> which, presumably, they need to do to teach there Clearly they still can. They can afford to live there or commute. If they couldn't the teacher-student ratio would go down.
- efa 9y agoBut couldn't you substitute teacher with any other job. It's not about teacher pay. It's the price of housing has skyrocketed compared to average salaries in general.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- unstatusthequo 9y agoSlap in the oppressive taxation on income and property and you have a state whose citizens are merely tax donkeys to support their obnoxious social programs that they can't afford to run.
- draw_down 9y agoGive me a break
- foota 9y agoOppressive taxation on property? Isn't California the state where long time home owners can get taxed at a valuation decades old?
- avs733 9y agoYes. And taxes can't be raised without a public referendum. It is oppressive taxation - just not in the way the comment above is implying.
- dumbfounder 9y agoFrom http://www.lao.ca.gov/reports/2012/tax/property-tax-primer-112912.aspx http://www.lao.ca.gov/reports/2012/tax/property-tax-primer-1... The Property Tax Is One of the Largest Taxes Californians Pay. In some years, Californians pay more in property taxes and charges than they do in state personal income taxes, the largest state General Fund revenue source. Local governments collected about $43 billion in 2010–11 from the 1 percent rate. The other taxes and charges on the property tax bill generated an additional $12 billion.
- maerF0x0 9y agoYes. So new owners are carrying a disproportionate share.
- rdiddly 9y agoYes, adding the public portion into it is like adding insult to injury, but the majority of the burden of housing expense goes into private coffers. To use your language I think we're primarily some other kind of donkey, enriching an obnoxious property-owning overclass that we can't afford to support.
- SlowBro 9y agoSo what's the solution?
- user5994461 9y agoWorld War III but it comes with other side effects.
- 0x4f3759df 9y agoTall buildings and subways.
- SlowBro 9y agoWhat prevents said structures from being built?
- moate 9y agoZoning and a culture that prefers detached homes.
- SlowBro 9y agoSo how would you go about fixing either?
- epistasis 9y agoFix the zoning and also prevent tiny minorities from having veto power on new housing. Last year, SB 35 improves this process for developments when a municipality is not yet meeting their planned amount of housing build. This year, SB 827 is up for consideration which would force municipalities to allow taller buildings close to rail and ferry terminals. These are radical changes for a state that, 30 years ago, said "we're full" and had a massive political movement to stop housing development. However, commercial office space development did not stop at the same time.
- moate 9y ago
- aaron_m04 9y agoAs @gracels pointed out, the title is misleading. > You switched from “in California” to “in San Francisco.”
- korethr 9y agoAs commented in the thread attached to that tweet, the comparison of statewide numbers in the 50s to just San Francisco today is an apples-to-oranges comparison. It honestly comes across as a bit disingenuous. I'd be more interested in the comparison of just San Francisco numbers from the 50s to now. Or statewide 50s to statewide now. Or how much an effect the San Francisco numbers are having on the statewide numbers, in either time period. But all that probably doesn't fit into a tweet.
- vladich 9y agoIt's even worse, it compares wages for "Pacific region" of 50th, whatever it is, with current San Francisco. Its not even apples to oranges comparison, more like apples to stones or something like that. I'm pretty sure it was more affordable back then before the tech boom, but the numbers provided don't make sense.
- tomohawk 9y agoIn the early 60s, a relative of mine was a new engineer with a $12K salary. A new car was around $3K and the house he bought was around $24K. How many people have starting salaries these days that are 50% of a typical suburban home in an area they can find work in?
- maxxxxx 9y agoSame for my neighbor in an LA suburb. Started as plumber in the 70s with 24k salary. Bought house for 40k. House will probably sell for 800k today. He says a plumber will probably make 60k-80k today.
- pxeboot 9y agoProbably not common, but still possible for those with professional degrees in many places in the US. After all, the median home price is still around 200k. Student loans are probably more of an issue then housing prices for new graduates in lower cost of living areas.
- Spooky23 9y agoIn the early 2000s I was making $55k and bought my first home for $130k. It was possible, although harder now as money is too easy to get. You have three problems... over consolidation of industry, over consolidation of capital and inflationary pressure via easy credit. Bay Area real estate is a shitshow in many perspectives. The root problem is that the money people are all there, and would rather not travel. It’s dumb for all stakeholders, corporate, capital and working that such an important and large component of the US economy is dependent on the Bay Area. It’s doubly stupid as the whole region could be leveled by an earthquake at any time. I’ve worked on projects where significant numbers of people contributing to the project have been on other continent. It defies all reason that we don’t have the ability to finance business in Omaha, Buffalo, or Nashville.
- shifter 9y agoNashville's getting pretty expensive, too, thought it's nothing compared to the Bay Area.
- ucaetano 9y agoAnd the blame lays on the teachers of the 50's (and other people), now retired homeowners artificially restricting housing supply for their own personal gain.
- maerF0x0 9y agoI see no problem with home ownership being out of reach, so long as housing is affordable. IMO all asset classes are at risk of exuberance and thus we cannot stop investors from over pricing them. However, their underlying value (rent price) should remain sustainable for those who need somewhere to live. How is this possible? Simple, someone who has capitalized in the past is free to rent for far lower than someone who has purchased in the present. Someone who bought in 1970 likely has extremely low operating costs and thus is free to lower rents to meet market demands, some asset owners may go bankrupt in falling rents/asset prices... Thats just how capitalism works. IMO we should be building far more supply to cause an eventual shock and real drop in housing value. Make those who are doing idiotic things like paying more than asking price for a home learn the lessons of capitalism .
- nopriorarrests 9y ago>home ownership being out of reach, so long as housing is affordable. But it does not work this way, if we actually talking about capitalism. House ownership is having an asset (stock or house) and affordable housing is a cashflow (rent + house deprecation, or dividend) which this asset generates. These two are interconnected, always. If your house provides you with 2% rent and your S&P500 portfolio gives you 0.02% dididend yield, it means that house is overvalued or portfolio is undervalued. So, point being, you can't have 3M houses ("home ownership being out of reach") AND 24k/year rent ("affordable housing"). House prices should fall or rents should rise.
- aianus 9y agoPeople aren’t rational. There are many people around here in Toronto that will buy a home and rent it at a loss because “home prices always go up”. I did the math and my previous landlord was losing money on a cash flow basis renting to me; the rent could not have covered the property tax, condo fees, and mortgage interest (or inflation / opportunity cost if he owned outright). My long distance girlfriend at the time also knew a family who owned a $2m house and left it empty while they lived in HK. We used to stay in it when she was in town. They were too rich to care and “home prices always go up”.
- 9y ago
- tapatio 9y agoBlame feminism.
- sctb 9y agoWould you please comment civilly and substantively, like the guidelines ask? We ban accounts that won't. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- skookumchuck 9y agoIf everyones' salary was raised so they could buy a house at today's prices, the housing prices would rise until they couldn't. The laws of supply & demand cannot be repealed. When you've got 100 people and 30 houses, 70 are not going to get a house one way or another.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"When you've got 100 people and 30 houses, 70 are not going to get a house one way or another." Unless you make people share houses. There are solutions, even if some of them may not be palatable in the current political climate.
- executive 9y agoNo Soldier shall, in time of peace be quartered in any house, without the consent of the Owner, nor in time of war, but in a manner to be prescribed by law.
- hollandheese 9y agoMore like we've got 100 people and 80 houses, but somehow 70 people aren't going to get a house one way or another. One of the large problems is people buying up second+ homes to rent out or AirBnB.
- epistasis 9y agoI don't think San Francisco has a bit problem here, all Airbnb units are registered with the city [1], and even before registration requirements, there were only ~11,000 units listed [2] in all of San Francisco, which is a tiny fraction. Vacancy rates are also extremely low in San Francisco: http://www.deptofnumbers.com/rent/california/san-francisco/ http://www.deptofnumbers.com/rent/california/san-francisco/ so investment properties being idle is also not a problem. The real problem is lack of supply to meet demand. A state law from the 1970s forces municipalities to produce Regional Housing Needs Assessments (RHNA), and nobody in the Bay Area is close to meeting their planned housing needs ([3] Table 4.1) for moderate or lower incomes. Overall in California, 97% of cities failed to meet their own housing goals [4] (Please note that this source is highly pro-housing, so take it with a grain of salt. I am also very pro-housing but want to be open kimono about it). [1] http://money.cnn.com/2017/05/01/technology/airbnb-san-francisco-settlement-agreement/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2017/05/01/technology/airbnb-san-franci... [2] https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/Airbnb-loses-thousands-of-hosts-in-SF-as-12496624.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/Airbnb-loses-th... [3] http://reports.abag.ca.gov/sotr/2015/section4-housing-goals-progress.php http://reports.abag.ca.gov/sotr/2015/section4-housing-goals-... [4] https://www.thebaycitybeacon.com/politics/of-california-cities-failed-to-meet-state-housing-goals-and/article_a609ae5e-09d7-11e8-a94e-3b67baeaae8b.html https://www.thebaycitybeacon.com/politics/of-california-citi...
- dfsegoat 9y agoI understand the article is about the fact that teachers salaries have not scaled over time. I wondered whether Housing inventory vs Price (homes available for sale) by decade might shed some light on the authors conclusions, and found the following Forbes article, with data from Trulia (in 2013) showing Homes built vs Asking Price, by Decade [0]: To me, it looks like Asking price increases semi-linearly starting in the 40s https://b-i.forbesimg.com/trulia/files/2013/05/Chart_Template2.png https://b-i.forbesimg.com/trulia/files/2013/05/Chart_Templat... [0] - https://www.forbes.com/sites/trulia/2013/05/02/american-homes-by-decade/#7764d2f01045 https://www.forbes.com/sites/trulia/2013/05/02/american-home...
- delbel 9y agoAnd in the 50s people bought land and order house kits from Sears. You can google image search "Sears house kit" and see hundreds of designs that might remind you of the houses in your own neighborhood that you grew up in. https://insme.info/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/sears-house-plans-luxury-1923-sears-modern-home-kit-house-sunbeam-craftsman-bungalow-of-sears-house-plans.jpg https://insme.info/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/sears-house-pl...
- thirduncle 9y agoIt honestly comes across as a bit disingenuous. It was definitely careless in regard to accuracy. But the original Trulia article it misread from comes a lot closer to making the comparisons you're after.
- jjtheblunt 9y agoBecause the planet was effectively larger (i.e., less developed) and the population was MUCH smaller: supply and demand, no?
- rdlecler1 9y agoWe need an Elon Musk for housing. If Donald Trump could solve this problem he’d win 80% of the popular vote in 2020. Housing cost is a huge tax on propsperity for the next generation.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]