3 ms·
What is with perpetuating this idea that people have some duty to be responsible for companies' broken security practices? You're unable to prevent their fuckup
by mindslight 9y ago
What is with perpetuating this idea that people have some duty to be responsible for companies' broken security practices? You're unable to prevent their fuckups - so you can only take steps to make sure you don't end up on the hook or otherwise severely impacted due to their negligence.
It's not my job to avoid repeating public information like mother's maiden name, historical addresses, etc.
Nor is it my job to worry about whether a bank will bypass confirming "secret question" strings for anyone stating they're just random letters.
As an non-responsible third party to any possible identity-based fraud, the only thing I see the need/ability to do to protect myself is watch transactions on my accounts (automation helps here, eg OFX), and be prepared to send demand letters/sue the surveillance companies for libel if they start spouting off that "I" opened accounts that I did not.
Feeling any more responsible than this is just helping to continue their negligent/lazy/broken-ass business processes.
- philwelch 9y agoI don't really see "responsibility" as a useful lens. If you give away information that can be used to reset your passwords, you make it more likely that someone can reset your passwords. Assigning blame is something people do to make themselves feel better after bad things happen. Making it less likely for bad things to happen in the first place may or may not be worth the time and effort, but whether or not you're morally responsible is a pretty meaningless question.
- mindslight 9y ago> Assigning blame is something people do to make themselves feel better after bad things happen Eh, not really. Assigning responsibility is how we align incentives to prevent things from happening in the first place. You are responsible for not disclosing your bank password. You are not responsible for repeating public information that a bank foolishly decided to consider an authentication token. Personally fretting about whatever broken actions a bank decides to take uses up a disproportionate amount of your time, as you're unable to actually change them. And any success just encourages the bank to continue, as they suffer less from their own idiocy.
- philwelch 9y agoIt may or may not be worth the time and effort never to tell anyone your mother’s maiden name, but assigning blame is kind of beside the point. It’s not my responsibility not to get my bike stolen, but if I don’t want my bike stolen, I still lock it up, right?
- barsonme 9y agoIn a perfect world, sure. But unfortunately so many companies don't do security right, so if we want to be safe we have to take the initiative. I mean, it doesn't have to be an either/or thing, we can pressure companies to change while adhering to best practices like not publicly posting your first car and name of your first pet.
- mindslight 9y agoYes, that initiative is checking your own transactions in a timely manner, so you don't end up losing money. Due to banks' insistence on clinging to an outdated security paradigm (permissive w/ rollback), you can't actually prevent fraudulent transactions from showing up on your account.