5 ms·
I think the missing discussion is that some bad law exists, but that SESTA/FOSTA is not that bad law: Websites should not be immune to prosecution for intention
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
I think the missing discussion is that some bad law exists, but that SESTA/FOSTA is not that bad law: Websites should not be immune to prosecution for intentionally facilitating criminal activity. Section 230 is a bad thing and it going away is a good thing. Headlines I've seen like "sex workers are the canary in the coal mine for free speech" are not really accurate, because this is about activity which is and has been illegal, not suppressing speech.
The problem is that there's no good reason for prostitution in general to be illegal in the United States. While I have no interest in partaking in such activity myself, I realize that the sole interest in banning it appears to be religion... something which cannot and should not govern our country's laws. I'm a Christian, but I don't think Christian views should be the determining factor in our legislature... that's the Constitution's job.
- AFNobody 9y ago> I think the missing discussion is that some bad law exists, but that SESTA/FOSTA is not that bad law: Websites should not be immune to prosecution for intentionally facilitating criminal activity. Section 230 Pretending that Section 230 willing enables participation in an illegal enterprise is a complete fabrication with no grounding in reality. Prosecuting Backpage without SESTA/FOSTA was possible which is why Backpage was taken down and indicted BEFORE the law was signed (and therefore, enforceable). Why do you think all the torrent sites get taken down? Or YouTube was sued? or 2903420934230 other things where a site violates some law be profiting from otherwise illegal UGC? Or the various dark net markets like the one Dread Pirate Roberts ran? Section 230 has _never_ provided more than a reasonable barrier to overcome to prevent absurd legal attacks.
- maxxxxx 9y agoThe ban on prostitution is the same thing as the war on drugs. It wasn't able to stop the practice so the only result was to move these into the criminal environment. I'd much prefer if prostitution (and drugs) was tightly regulated but in the open.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kup0 9y agoFrom the arguments I've seen, the big issue is that removing these areas from the web makes those caught in trafficking harder to rescue, as it drives the info deeper underground on the web or off the web altogether. Even the DOJ even weighed in (https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/4390361/Views-Ltr-Re-H-R-1865-Allow-States-and-Victims.pdf https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/4390361/Views-Ltr...) and said it will make catching traffickers more difficult. When you have the DOJ opposing a proposal to strengthen a law, that should be a significant red flag. Of course, I understand my comment is specifically about the implications for trafficking, not self-decided/employed sex workers. In regards to the latter, I think the article describes it well, regardless of it being illegal, SESTA/FOSTA only makes it more dangerous for both groups.
- guelo 9y ago> Section 230 is a bad thing and it going away is a good thing The last 20 years of web innovation begs to differ. Killing user-generated content will make us all worse off.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoI vehemently disagree with the rhetoric of the tech companies that holding them legally responsible for willful participation in criminal activity will "kill user-generated content".
- guelo 9y agoYour "the tech companies" is a tell to where the problem lies. In your world only well funded tech companies that can pay for a team of moderators or a team of expensive engineers to develop AI filters will be able to host user generated content. But a lot of times innovation comes from small unfunded individuals.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoOn the contrary: A couple moderators on a small site have no problem being able to say they don't willfully permit their site to be used for criminal activity. It's only "planet-scale" companies that seem to indicate they can't afford to moderate and review content reasonably. "AI" is not the answer. AI is not adequate or comparable to human moderators which small businesses employ. AI is a "solution" for providing lip service to accountability without spending the money to actually provide any sort of responsible service.
- guelo 9y ago"A couple moderators" aka goodbye user generated content that isn't generating at least six figure income.
- ocdtrekkie 9y ago
- blhack 9y ago>the sole interest in banning it appears to be religion If you can't think of any moral hazards around prostitution, then I don't believe that you are trying very hard. >I don't think Christian views should be the determining factor in our legislature Is Christianity the only moral system that looks poorly upon prostitution?
- sigzero 9y ago> Is Christianity the only moral system that looks poorly upon prostitution? No, but is it probably one of the most vocal.
- throwajay123 9y agopeople really think regulating how others have sex is going to fix the world. it would be adorably naive if it weren’t so grossly authoritarian, popular, and doomed to fail anyway.
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoThere are plenty of moral hazards around prostitution, and banning it outright makes all of them worse. It makes the women involved criminals and deprives them of legal protection when they're abused. The only reason to make prostitution a crime is if you think prostitutes themselves are committing evil. That is 100% a religious position with no rational support.
- DanBC 9y agoHow does your comment fit with children being drugged and forced into prostitution? And then adults being drugged and forced into prostitution? And then adults feeding a drug addiction? At which point of this ladder do you start to say "no, this is where we need to make it illegal"?
- s73v3r_ 9y agoAt the "forced into prostitution" part. Because prostitution itself being legal or not does not encourage the others. Outlawing it has not eliminated those other things; in fact, many say that it has made them worse.
- Ancalagon 9y agoWhat's even more obnoxious is the hypocritical legality of pornography in the US. All of the problems created by prostitution are present in the porn industry, somehow we manage to overlook this aspect though.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoClearly, the problem with prostitution is that you aren't filming it!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Shivetya 9y agoWell Soliciting Prostitution is not a federal crime in the US however what the AG and other LE officials do to get around that is go after people under The Travel Act. This is where fifty of the ninety three charges against the Backpage founder where put to nail him "for prostitution" because the Travel Act allows prosecutors to charge people with a Federal crime for violating a state crime if they cross state borders. That use of the Travel Act to combat prostitution has been used to get any site they wanted to shut down. In other words, since Congress isn't about to reign them in nor the courts prosecutors at the Federal level can do about what they please. This is not to say backpage was innocent, only in how non Federal crimes can become such by stretching intent
- shkkmo 9y ago> Websites should not be immune to prosecution for intentionally facilitating criminal activity. They are not immune from that and Section 230 doesn't make them immune to that. What section 230 means is that "implementing any moderation or filtering of user content does not automatically make you an editor and thus liable for all content on your site". Without section 230, Dang cannot do moderation on HN without HN becoming liable for EVERYTHING that is posted to the site. Facebook, Google and Twitter will be economically forced to stop filtering abhorrent content to avoid massive legal liabilities. The missing discussion is that people need to stop jumping into the discussion without understanding the historical and legal context of section 230.